# CCPE Upgrade Report

## 1. Original Artifact

Name: 张辽 - 建设性批判智能体  
Path: `C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\prompts\ccpe\legacy-ccpe\强哥的虎贲卫\张辽\张辽1.2.md`  
Version: 1.2  
Original Format: CCPE 2.0 self-contained single-agent prompt

## 2. Original Classification

Primary: CCPE-Lite candidate  
Secondary Components: red-team reviewer, Socratic coach, dynamic subject-matter framing, review workflow, source/retrieval policy  
Operating Mode: Expert Mode  
Depth vs Automation: Depth-Oriented

## 3. Target Classification

Primary: `original-kernel-minimal-lite`  
Secondary Outputs: none in this pass  
Runtime Need: deferred until Outline Review Runtime construction

Source Decision: `repair source first`  
Source Judgment Report: `workbench/analysis/zhang-liao-original-source-judgment-report.md`

## 4. Preserved Elements

- 修复后的源版本 `张辽1.2.md` prompt body 已置于 `## Original Kernel` 后逐字保留。
- 同行评审员与启发式教练的双相角色。
- 结构主义拆解、第一性原理分析、反例与边界测试。
- “动态领域高置信专家模式”、事实审查纪律、动态学科领域专家等 1.2 源稿术语保留在 Original Kernel 中。
- 智识诚实优先于表面建设性的价值排序。
- 《建设性批判报告》的核心报告形态。
- 报告后进入多轮讨论的工作方式。

## 5. Extracted Elements

No separate Model Card, Skill, or Agent Spec was extracted in this pass.

Rationale: current goal is Fast Migration Lane. 张辽 is still mainly a portable expert reviewer. Additional Agent Spec or Skill extraction should wait until the Outline Review Runtime defines stable handoff, input/output contracts, and reuse needs.

## 6. Modified Elements

- Added front matter for CCPE-Lite classification, source judgment, and migration metadata.
- Added Minimal Lite Wrapper before `## Original Kernel`.
- Added Source Judgment Result block documenting Gemini review and the `repair source first` decision.
- Added platform boundary so retrieval language cannot exceed the current platform's actual capabilities.
- Added source / retrieval boundary for distinguishing user text, provided search material, actual platform retrieval, model background knowledge, and inference.
- Added hidden reasoning disclosure repair: internal checks remain analysis discipline, but hidden chain-of-thought must not be output.
- Added output validation discipline while preserving the original report form.

## 7. Deprecated or Removed Elements

- Nothing was removed from the Original Kernel.
- The earlier source-level defects from `张辽1.1.md` were repaired in `张辽1.2.md` before kernel wrapping.
- Any remaining conflict between wrapper and retrieval language is resolved by the wrapper's platform boundary.
- Any hidden chain-of-thought disclosure risk is resolved by the wrapper's reasoning disclosure repair.

## 8. Generated Files

- `workbench/upgraded/zhang-liao-original-kernel-minimal-lite.prompt.md`
- `workbench/upgraded/zhang-liao-original-kernel-minimal-lite-upgrade-report.md`
- `agents/lite/zhang-liao.prompt.md`

## 9. Model Index Updates

None.

## 10. Human Decisions Required

- Whether 张辽 should later receive an Agent Spec for Runtime participation.
- Whether its red-team method should later become a reusable Skill.
- Whether the earlier rewritten draft should be renamed or retained as a `refined-lite candidate`.

## 11. Next Step

Run a small regression comparison for `agents/lite/zhang-liao.prompt.md` when ready. Agent Spec, Skill, or Runtime extraction remains deferred until an Outline Review Runtime or repeated reuse scenario requires it.