Add complexity placement gate distillation package
This commit is contained in:
parent
c91e70ff42
commit
5f8d8dd1d2
File diff suppressed because it is too large
Load Diff
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
|
|||
# 00 Source Map
|
||||
|
||||
## Source Metadata
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document_path: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
source_type: five-round ChatGPT discussion draft
|
||||
source_version_note: file last modified 2026-06-12 04:59:16 local time
|
||||
source_size_bytes: 196795
|
||||
source_line_count: 5079
|
||||
sha256: 1ECF344824AF1D5DA3F1AB19C092460D41F6726D764ABD0345D7CF8AB66E53F3
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
round_boundary_rule: numeric Markdown H1 only, matching ^#\s+\d+\s*$; non-numeric H1 headings inside a round are content, not boundaries
|
||||
gpt_response_boundary_rule: ## GPT marks the GPT response start inside the current numeric round
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Round Boundaries
|
||||
|
||||
| range_id | boundary_heading | start_line | gpt_start_line | end_line | note |
|
||||
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
|
||||
| R01 | `# 1` | 1 | 843 | 1020 | deep creative workflow discussion begins |
|
||||
| R02 | `# 2` | 1021 | 1192 | 1909 | review and material-extraction workflow drafts appear inside the round |
|
||||
| R03 | `# 3` | 1910 | 1962 | 2638 | dimensional-reduction output workflow |
|
||||
| R04 | `# 4` | 2639 | 2904 | 4013 | AI development methodology expansion, including HiFi Agent Studio material |
|
||||
| R05 | `# 5` | 4014 | 4027 | 5079 | final methodology extension and GPT response |
|
||||
|
||||
## User / GPT Slice Notes
|
||||
|
||||
| range_id | user_slice | gpt_slice |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R01 | lines 1-842 | lines 843-1020 |
|
||||
| R02 | lines 1021-1191 | lines 1192-1909 |
|
||||
| R03 | lines 1910-1961 | lines 1962-2638 |
|
||||
| R04 | lines 2639-2903 | lines 2904-4013 |
|
||||
| R05 | lines 4014-4026 | lines 4027-5079 |
|
||||
|
||||
## Boundary Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- Non-numeric H1 headings such as `# 评审环节改造：信息材料抽取初稿`, `# 素材提炼改造：信息材料抽取初稿`, `# 降维输出的工作流`, and `# **HiFi Agent Studio**` are intra-round content.
|
||||
- The first three rounds focus on deep creative workflow and article/material-processing practice.
|
||||
- The last two rounds extend the same pattern into AI development methodology.
|
||||
- The user-supplied structural prior is that the deep creative workflow is the practical enactment of the AI development methodology, not a separate parallel macro-topic.
|
||||
- This map records source ranges and source assumptions only. It does not analyze or finalize topic content.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,768 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: 01-topic-map
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
artifact_type: canonical_topic_map
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
source: ../../../../diary/2026/2026-06/2026-06-12.md
|
||||
source_map: 00-source-map.md
|
||||
synthesis_prep: invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md
|
||||
human_confirmation: invocations/synthesis-prep/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
status: canonical_for_material_routing
|
||||
material_routing_log_created: true
|
||||
topic_docs_created: true
|
||||
model_assets_created: false
|
||||
writing_workbench_handoff_created: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Topic Map: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Map Status And Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
本文件是本 run 的 canonical topic map，用于后续 material routing 的结构依据。
|
||||
|
||||
它不是：
|
||||
|
||||
- `02-material-routing-log.md`
|
||||
- topic doc
|
||||
- model-mining 输出
|
||||
- model card
|
||||
- Agentic Handbook 正文
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 正文补丁
|
||||
- 第 8 篇文章提纲
|
||||
- writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
|
||||
后续 material routing 可按本 topic map 继续执行；只有出现新的用户级结构问题时才暂停确认。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Confirmed Root
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
root_topic_id: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
root_topic_title: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
root_status: confirmed
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
根主题定义：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
复杂度放置门，是指在专家型 Agentic 系统中，先判断任务到底需要购买哪一种复杂度，再决定是否启用 Agent、Skill、Runtime、真实 invocation、审计、topic docs、handoff、模型沉淀或工程化生产线。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
它不是单纯的反过度工程。它关心的是：
|
||||
|
||||
- 复杂度放在哪里。
|
||||
- 复杂度购买了什么。
|
||||
- 成本记在哪个账本。
|
||||
- 哪些环节必须真实执行。
|
||||
- 什么时候必须停。
|
||||
- 哪些材料进入文章、HiFi 纲领或 Agentic 守则。
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Canonical Topic Graph
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
topic_graph_type: tree_backed_mixed_graph
|
||||
tree_backbone_required: true
|
||||
cross_links_required: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 Root Node
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
title: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
role: root
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
核心判断：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
本材料的最大收获不是“少用流程”，而是建立一个入口判断：当 Agentic 系统足以把任何任务治理化时，必须先判断该任务是内容产出、系统建设、校准实验还是探索预演；再决定用 Lite、Standard 还是 Full；并在真实执行、成本分账、任务漂移和停止条件上保留硬边界。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 Primary Child: ROI 异常与成本账本
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
title: ROI 异常与成本账本
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: trigger_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
内容范围：
|
||||
|
||||
- 5 万字讨论稿处理消耗约 3000 万 tokens 的怪异感。
|
||||
- 内容产出成本与系统研发成本被混在一个账本。
|
||||
- SuperPowers / Skill / Runtime 不是唯一原因；核心是任务分层和入口 gate 缺失。
|
||||
- Cost Ledger 应区分 Content Cost、System-Building Cost、Calibration Cost、Exploration Cost。
|
||||
|
||||
反范围：
|
||||
|
||||
- 不把本轮结论写成“插件导致浪费”。
|
||||
- 不把成本问题简化为省 token。
|
||||
- 不把系统研发成本误记为单次素材处理成本。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 Primary Child: 实践案例层
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: practice-cases
|
||||
title: 实践案例层
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: evidence_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
实践案例层只作为证据层，不作为多个平级根主题。
|
||||
|
||||
#### 3.3.1 写作评审流程：流程幻觉与执行真实性
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
title: 写作评审流程：流程幻觉与执行真实性
|
||||
parent: practice-cases
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
cross_link_targets:
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- hifi-principle-real-execution
|
||||
- handbook-execution-authenticity
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
核心材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 文件结构完整不等于多 Agent 真实执行。
|
||||
- 主会话模拟张辽、韩愈、认知显影、巨人认知等输出，会制造流程幻觉。
|
||||
- `Agent Invocation Packet`、`prompt-to-send`、`invocation record`、`simulation-only` 标记是必要的真实性复杂度。
|
||||
|
||||
用途：
|
||||
|
||||
- 文章素材：第一次“像真的但不是真的”。
|
||||
- HiFi patch：正式产物必须真实执行。
|
||||
- Handbook：Execution Authenticity 细则。
|
||||
|
||||
#### 3.3.2 素材提炼流程：whole-source gestalt 与治理过载
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
title: 素材提炼流程：whole-source gestalt 与治理过载
|
||||
parent: practice-cases
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
cross_link_targets:
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
核心材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- Chunk-first 会让局部真实冒充整体结构。
|
||||
- Coherent long source 需要先 whole-source gestalt，再分段处理。
|
||||
- Full Runtime 可追溯、真实、完整，但用于单篇普通蒸馏可能过重。
|
||||
- Stop Rule 应防止 topic docs、coverage audit、handoff、repair pass 无限增殖。
|
||||
|
||||
用途：
|
||||
|
||||
- 文章素材：第二次“真的但太贵”。
|
||||
- HiFi patch：默认轻量、证据驱动升级。
|
||||
- Handbook：Mode Selector、Scope Drift、Stop Rule。
|
||||
|
||||
#### 3.3.3 降维输出流程：生产线型 MVP
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
title: 降维输出流程：生产线型 MVP
|
||||
parent: practice-cases
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
cross_link_targets:
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
核心材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 深度创作像专家诊断室 / 实验室。
|
||||
- 降维输出像生产线，更适合先 Agentic 化。
|
||||
- 优先自动化低判断、高摩擦、验收清楚、错了易改、不会伤害核心思想质量的环节。
|
||||
|
||||
边界：
|
||||
|
||||
- 只作为实践案例层和 MVP 分类材料。
|
||||
- 不创建 `video-workbench` topic。
|
||||
- 不创建视频工作流 handoff。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Diagnostic Model Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### 4.1 QPI Drift
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: qpi-drift
|
||||
title: QPI Drift：P 入口滑入 I 域治理
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: diagnostic_model_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
核心判断：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
一项任务表层可能是 P：明确产物、明确路径、局部自动化。但当它开始涉及真实性边界、角色权力、状态污染、成本分账、复用要求、审计追踪、停止规则和长期治理时，已经滑入 I 域。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
保留方式：
|
||||
|
||||
- 作为 `复杂度放置门` 的诊断子节点。
|
||||
- 不抽取 QPI model card。
|
||||
- 不重写 QPI 全体系。
|
||||
|
||||
### 4.2 复杂度购买价值
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: complexity-buys-value
|
||||
title: 复杂度购买价值
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: diagnostic_model_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
复杂度只有在购买以下价值时才应保留、升级或工程化：
|
||||
|
||||
- 真实性
|
||||
- 独立性
|
||||
- 保真性
|
||||
- 结构性
|
||||
- 可追溯性
|
||||
- 可复盘性
|
||||
- 可复用性
|
||||
- 风险控制
|
||||
- 下游依赖稳定性
|
||||
|
||||
未购买上述价值的复杂度应删除、降级、延后或标为探索成本。
|
||||
|
||||
### 4.3 成本分账
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: cost-ledger
|
||||
title: 成本分账
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: diagnostic_model_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
cross_link_targets:
|
||||
- hifi-principle-cost-separation
|
||||
- handbook-cost-ledger
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
成本账本：
|
||||
|
||||
- Content Cost：为当前内容产出支付的成本。
|
||||
- System-Building Cost：为构建可复用机器支付的成本。
|
||||
- Calibration Cost：为校准角色、标准、上下文、评估支付的成本。
|
||||
- Exploration Cost：为前瞻、试错、踩坑、方法论预演支付的成本。
|
||||
|
||||
规则：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
禁止把系统建设成本伪装为单次内容任务成本。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Agentic 专家系统运行治理
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: agentic-governance
|
||||
title: 专家型 Agentic 运行治理
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: governance_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本节点是根主题的核心展开对象。它回答：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
当专家工作被 Agentic 化时，如何建模入口、角色、上下文、真实执行、成本、漂移、停止和文档承接。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.1 Project Intake / Mode Selector
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
title: Project Intake / Mode Selector
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
handbook_group: Project Intake + Mode Selector
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
功能：
|
||||
|
||||
- 先判断任务是 Q / P / I。
|
||||
- 再判断是内容产出、可复用流程、治理级系统、校准实验还是探索预演。
|
||||
- 默认从 Lite 开始，只有证据推动才升级 Standard / Full。
|
||||
|
||||
边界：
|
||||
|
||||
- 不因系统有 Agent、Skill、Runtime 能力就自动启用重档位。
|
||||
- 不把一次性素材处理默认提升为 governed runtime。
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.2 Execution Authenticity
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: execution-authenticity
|
||||
title: Execution Authenticity / no-simulation
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
handbook_group: Execution Authenticity
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
原则：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
正式 Agentic 产物必须来自真实执行；主会话不得冒充独立 Agent、Worker 或 Auditor。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
机制：
|
||||
|
||||
- Agent Invocation Packet。
|
||||
- prompt-to-send。
|
||||
- invocation record。
|
||||
- returned-output。
|
||||
- thread_id / carrier 记录。
|
||||
- simulation-only 标记。
|
||||
- excluded-from-synthesis 标记。
|
||||
- blocked_waiting_for_participant_output。
|
||||
|
||||
机制不是父主题；父主题是执行真实性。
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.3 Cost Ledger
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: handbook-cost-ledger
|
||||
title: Cost Ledger
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
handbook_group: Cost Ledger
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
功能：
|
||||
|
||||
- 将内容产出、系统建设、校准、探索分账。
|
||||
- 将一次任务中的“做内容”和“造机器”拆成不同解释口径。
|
||||
- 避免 ROI 怪味被误判为单次任务失败。
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.4 Scope Drift / Stop Rule
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
title: Scope Drift / Stop Rule
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
handbook_group:
|
||||
- Scope Drift
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Scope Drift 触发信号：
|
||||
|
||||
- 内容任务开始设计 Agent / Skill / Runtime / Protocol。
|
||||
- 一次性任务开始设计复用目录和通用标准。
|
||||
- 开始讨论 invocation、authority、state、audit、handoff。
|
||||
- 成本明显超过原任务规模。
|
||||
- 原始产物被中间流程持续推迟。
|
||||
|
||||
Stop Rule 功能：
|
||||
|
||||
- 定义最小可用产物。
|
||||
- 定义 optional 产物。
|
||||
- 定义升级后才生成的产物。
|
||||
- 定义 sufficient 条件。
|
||||
- 定义人类决策等待点。
|
||||
- 定义禁止自动扩展条件。
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.5 Human Gate / Authority / Trace
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
title: Human Gate / Authority / Trace
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
范围：
|
||||
|
||||
- Human gate 不是自动化失败，而是专家系统接口。
|
||||
- Authority Matrix 定义谁能观察、建议、起草、修改、决定、执行、阻断。
|
||||
- Trace 记录谁被调用、用什么 prompt、读什么输入、产出什么、主会话如何整合、哪些进入正式 synthesis。
|
||||
|
||||
地位：
|
||||
|
||||
- 作为治理层支撑 topic。
|
||||
- 可进入 Handbook 后续素材。
|
||||
- 不列入当前 Handbook 第一版六组核心，除非后续用户扩展范围。
|
||||
|
||||
### 5.6 Context / Fidelity / Evaluation Cross-Link Group
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
title: Context Compiler / Fidelity / Evaluation
|
||||
parent: agentic-governance
|
||||
status: cross_link_candidate
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
confirmed_core_topic: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
确认边界：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Context Compiler 只作为候选 / cross-link 材料保留，暂不升为核心 topic。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
可连接：
|
||||
|
||||
- whole-source gestalt。
|
||||
- premise-context-pack。
|
||||
- role-specific dispatch pack。
|
||||
- source digest。
|
||||
- Fidelity Ladder。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
|
||||
不得：
|
||||
|
||||
- 创建模型资产。
|
||||
- 作为本次 topic map 的核心父节点。
|
||||
- 直接创建 Handbook 正文章节。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. 文档与工程承接层
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: document-layering
|
||||
title: 文档与工程承接层
|
||||
parent: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
role: downstream_container_layer
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 6.1 HiFi Agent Studio：纲领补丁
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
title: HiFi Agent Studio：纲领补丁
|
||||
parent: document-layering
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tag: hifi_patch_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
最小补丁五原则：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
hifi_minimal_patch_principles:
|
||||
- id: hifi-principle-default-light
|
||||
title: 默认轻量，证据驱动升级
|
||||
- id: hifi-principle-real-execution
|
||||
title: 正式产物必须真实执行
|
||||
- id: hifi-principle-cost-separation
|
||||
title: 内容成本与系统建设成本必须分账
|
||||
- id: hifi-principle-scope-drift
|
||||
title: 任务漂移必须重定性
|
||||
- id: hifi-principle-stop-rule
|
||||
title: 系统必须拥有停止权
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
边界：
|
||||
|
||||
- 这些是补丁素材和纲领原则，不是正式 HiFi Agent Studio 正文。
|
||||
- 具体表格、模板、字段、阻断条件下放 Agentic Handbook。
|
||||
- `Production Workshop` 只作候选 / cross-link，不升为核心 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
### 6.2 Agentic Handbook：第一版守则素材
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
title: Agentic Handbook：第一版守则素材
|
||||
parent: document-layering
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tag: handbook_material
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
第一版先按六组组织：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
handbook_first_pass_groups:
|
||||
- Project Intake
|
||||
- Mode Selector
|
||||
- Cost Ledger
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity
|
||||
- Scope Drift
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
用户补充边界：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
这六组只是撰写 Agentic Handbook 时的原始素材组织方式，不是唯一素材，也不代表最终 Handbook 只包含这六组。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
暂不升为第一版核心的扩展项：
|
||||
|
||||
- Authority Matrix。
|
||||
- Artifact Contract。
|
||||
- Simulation Labeling。
|
||||
- Human Gate Design。
|
||||
- Context Compiler。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
- Platform Adapters。
|
||||
|
||||
这些可在 material routing 中作为 related / expansion material 标注。
|
||||
|
||||
### 6.3 CCPE System：建造工坊
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
title: CCPE System：Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊
|
||||
parent: document-layering
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tag: archival_context
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
地位：
|
||||
|
||||
- CCPE System 用于分类和建造 Prompt、Agent、Skill、Runtime、Model Card 等资产。
|
||||
- 本 run 只把它作为文档体系和工程承接层的一部分。
|
||||
- 本 run 不创建 CCPE assets、model cards 或 model index entries。
|
||||
|
||||
### 6.4 Project Runbook：本地流程规程
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
title: Project Runbook：本地流程规程
|
||||
parent: document-layering
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
downstream_task_tag: archival_context
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
地位：
|
||||
|
||||
- writing-workbench、knowledge-vault 等具体项目流程规程应在 project runbook 层承接。
|
||||
- 本 run 不创建 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
- 本 run 不创建 article outline。
|
||||
- `video-workbench` 不作为本 run topic。
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Candidate / Cross-Link Materials
|
||||
|
||||
### 7.1 Context Compiler
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
title: Context Compiler
|
||||
status: candidate_cross_link_only
|
||||
confirmed_core_topic: false
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
连接对象：
|
||||
|
||||
- 素材提炼流程中的 whole-source gestalt。
|
||||
- 深度创作流程中的 premise-context-pack。
|
||||
- 降维输出流程中的 article model digest / public-topic framing pack。
|
||||
- Handbook 后续的 Context Engineering 扩展项。
|
||||
- CCPE System 的 context protocol engineering。
|
||||
|
||||
### 7.2 Production Workshop
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
title: Production Workshop / 生产工坊
|
||||
status: candidate_cross_link_only
|
||||
confirmed_core_topic: false
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
连接对象：
|
||||
|
||||
- 降维输出流程作为生产线型 MVP 的案例。
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 中逻辑轮机与战略透镜之间的候选产品形态分类。
|
||||
- Agentic Handbook 中低判断高摩擦自动化的分诊材料。
|
||||
|
||||
禁止：
|
||||
|
||||
- 不创建 `video-workbench` topic。
|
||||
- 不创建视频生产 runbook。
|
||||
- 不把生产工坊升为本次核心父主题。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Article 8 Material Direction
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
id: article-8-material-direction
|
||||
title: 第 8 篇文章素材方向
|
||||
status: material_direction_only
|
||||
source_rounds:
|
||||
- R01
|
||||
- R02
|
||||
- R03
|
||||
- R04
|
||||
- R05
|
||||
creates_outline: false
|
||||
creates_writing_workbench_handoff: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
可保留素材线：
|
||||
|
||||
- 我以为在蒸馏材料，结果在测试一台知识加工机器。
|
||||
- 第一次“像真的但不是真的”，第二次“真的但太贵”。
|
||||
- 深度创作是实验室，降维输出是生产线。
|
||||
- Agentic 时代的过度工程不是 Agent 太多，而是没有判断复杂度放在哪里。
|
||||
- 纲领稳定、守则可变；复杂度也应放在正确文档层级。
|
||||
|
||||
边界：
|
||||
|
||||
- 只作为素材方向。
|
||||
- 不进入正式文章提纲。
|
||||
- 不创建 writing-workbench 项目。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Anti-Scope And Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
本 topic map 明确禁止以下误读：
|
||||
|
||||
1. 把 `复杂度放置门` 简化成反复杂度或反工程化。
|
||||
2. 把深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出升为三个独立父主题。
|
||||
3. 把第 8 篇文章、HiFi patch、Handbook 三个下游任务合并成单一输出。
|
||||
4. 把 Handbook 降为 HiFi Studio 的唯一执行承接子层；二者是不同任务方向。
|
||||
5. 把 Context Compiler 或 Production Workshop 升为核心 topic。
|
||||
6. 为 `video-workbench` 创建 topic。
|
||||
7. 从 GPT 建议中直接抽取模型资产。
|
||||
8. 核验或提升 GPT 外部链接为正式知识依据。
|
||||
9. 创建 writing-workbench handoff、文章提纲或正文草稿。
|
||||
10. 在未确认 topic 展开边界前创建 topic docs 或 audits。
|
||||
|
||||
## 10. Material Routing Readiness
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
topic_map_status: canonical
|
||||
ready_for_material_routing: true
|
||||
may_create_material_routing_log_without_additional_user_confirmation: true
|
||||
pause_only_if_new_user_level_decisions_appear: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
后续 material routing 应从以下 primary nodes 开始：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
route_targets:
|
||||
- trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
- writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
- material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
- dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
- qpi-drift
|
||||
- complexity-buys-value
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
- hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
- agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
- document-layering
|
||||
- ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
- project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
- production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
- article-8-material-direction
|
||||
- archival-context
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
可按本 topic map 继续创建：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,321 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: 02-material-routing-log
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
artifact_type: material_routing_log
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
source_map: 00-source-map.md
|
||||
topic_map: 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
status: canonical_routing_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
topic_docs_created: false
|
||||
model_assets_created: false
|
||||
writing_workbench_handoff_created: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Material Routing Log: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Scope And Routing Basis
|
||||
|
||||
本文件把五个 broad-fidelity worker 的 material units 路由到已确认的 `01-topic-map.md` 节点。
|
||||
|
||||
路由依据：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
01-topic-map.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本文件不做：
|
||||
|
||||
- topic docs 正文
|
||||
- model assets
|
||||
- model-mining
|
||||
- external link verification
|
||||
- writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
- article outline
|
||||
- source-disposable claim
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Route Target Legend
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
trigger-roi-ledger: ROI 异常与成本账本
|
||||
writing-review-execution-authenticity: 写作评审流程：流程幻觉与执行真实性
|
||||
material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload: 素材提炼流程：whole-source gestalt 与治理过载
|
||||
dimensional-reduction-production-line: 降维输出流程：生产线型 MVP
|
||||
qpi-drift: QPI Drift：P 入口滑入 I 域治理
|
||||
complexity-buys-value: 复杂度购买价值
|
||||
cost-ledger: 成本分账
|
||||
project-intake-mode-selector: Project Intake / Mode Selector
|
||||
execution-authenticity: Execution Authenticity / no-simulation
|
||||
scope-drift-stop-rule: Scope Drift / Stop Rule
|
||||
hifi-agent-studio-principles: HiFi Agent Studio：纲领补丁
|
||||
agentic-handbook-operating-law: Agentic Handbook：第一版守则素材
|
||||
document-layering: 文档与工程承接层
|
||||
ccpe-system-forge: CCPE System：建造工坊
|
||||
project-runbook-local-procedure: Project Runbook：本地流程规程
|
||||
context-compiler-crosslink: Context Compiler / Fidelity / Evaluation cross-link
|
||||
production-workshop-crosslink: Production Workshop / 生产工坊 cross-link
|
||||
article-8-material-direction: 第 8 篇文章素材方向
|
||||
archival-context: 归档上下文
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Routing Summary
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
rounds_routed:
|
||||
R01: 16
|
||||
R02: 16
|
||||
R03: 18
|
||||
R04: 15
|
||||
R05: 16
|
||||
total_material_units_routed: 81
|
||||
routing_source: worker_returned_outputs_only
|
||||
all_primary_units_have_route: true
|
||||
external_links_verified: false
|
||||
external_links_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
model_asset_extraction: prohibited
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. R01 Routing
|
||||
|
||||
R01 是触发层：ROI 异常、现有重型流程背景、CCPE 分类和 Lite / Standard / Full 初始分档。
|
||||
|
||||
| Unit | Primary Route | Secondary / Cross-Link Routes | Downstream Use |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R01-U01 | trigger-roi-ledger | project-intake-mode-selector; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U02 | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | execution-authenticity; project-runbook-local-procedure; archival-context | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U03 | execution-authenticity | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload; project-runbook-local-procedure; agentic-handbook-operating-law | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U04 | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | scope-drift-stop-rule; execution-authenticity; project-runbook-local-procedure | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U05 | ccpe-system-forge | project-intake-mode-selector; hifi-agent-studio-principles | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U06 | ccpe-system-forge | project-intake-mode-selector; agentic-handbook-operating-law | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U07 | ccpe-system-forge | complexity-buys-value; hifi-agent-studio-principles | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U08 | trigger-roi-ledger | cost-ledger; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U09 | cost-ledger | trigger-roi-ledger; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U10 | project-intake-mode-selector | complexity-buys-value; material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U11 | trigger-roi-ledger | project-intake-mode-selector; scope-drift-stop-rule | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U12 | complexity-buys-value | scope-drift-stop-rule; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U13 | project-intake-mode-selector | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U14 | project-intake-mode-selector | cost-ledger; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R01-U15 | project-intake-mode-selector | agentic-handbook-operating-law; scope-drift-stop-rule | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R01-U16 | complexity-buys-value | trigger-roi-ledger; hifi-agent-studio-principles; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
|
||||
R01 routing note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R01 的主要用途是给复杂度放置门提供触发叙事、账本错配和 mode selector 入口材料。README/runbook/CCPE 背景材料保留为 archival_context，不直接升为核心父主题。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. R02 Routing
|
||||
|
||||
R02 是核心证据轮：写作评审流程的假执行、素材提炼流程的治理过载、QPI drift 和复杂度购买价值。
|
||||
|
||||
| Unit | Primary Route | Secondary / Cross-Link Routes | Downstream Use |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R02-U01 | writing-review-execution-authenticity | context-compiler-crosslink; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U02 | context-compiler-crosslink | writing-review-execution-authenticity; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U03 | execution-authenticity | writing-review-execution-authenticity; agentic-handbook-operating-law; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U04 | execution-authenticity | complexity-buys-value; hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U05 | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | context-compiler-crosslink; project-runbook-local-procedure; scope-drift-stop-rule | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U06 | qpi-drift | article-8-material-direction; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U07 | writing-review-execution-authenticity | execution-authenticity; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U08 | execution-authenticity | writing-review-execution-authenticity; complexity-buys-value | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U09 | material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | scope-drift-stop-rule; cost-ledger; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U10 | qpi-drift | scope-drift-stop-rule; hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U11 | complexity-buys-value | execution-authenticity; context-compiler-crosslink; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U12 | complexity-buys-value | execution-authenticity; hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U13 | project-intake-mode-selector | writing-review-execution-authenticity; material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U14 | project-intake-mode-selector | qpi-drift; scope-drift-stop-rule; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U15 | scope-drift-stop-rule | cost-ledger; project-intake-mode-selector; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R02-U16 | article-8-material-direction | complexity-buys-value; cost-ledger; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
|
||||
R02 routing note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R02 支撑两个关键反例：第一次流程像真的但不是真的，第二次流程真的但太贵。前者主要路由到 execution-authenticity，后者主要路由到 material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload、cost-ledger 和 scope-drift-stop-rule。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. R03 Routing
|
||||
|
||||
R03 是专家型 Agentic 系统外推轮：深度创作作为实验室，降维输出作为生产线，专家判断位置需要被建模。
|
||||
|
||||
| Unit | Primary Route | Secondary / Cross-Link Routes | Downstream Use |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R03-U01 | dimensional-reduction-production-line | production-workshop-crosslink; project-intake-mode-selector; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R03-U02 | article-8-material-direction | writing-review-execution-authenticity; qpi-drift; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R03-U03 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | agentic-handbook-operating-law; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U04 | article-8-material-direction | dimensional-reduction-production-line; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U05 | article-8-material-direction | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; archival-context | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U06 | dimensional-reduction-production-line | project-intake-mode-selector; production-workshop-crosslink; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U07 | dimensional-reduction-production-line | qpi-drift; project-intake-mode-selector; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U08 | execution-authenticity | scope-drift-stop-rule; agentic-handbook-operating-law; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U09 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | ccpe-system-forge; execution-authenticity; agentic-handbook-operating-law | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R03-U10 | scope-drift-stop-rule | execution-authenticity; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U11 | execution-authenticity | human-gate-authority-trace; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U12 | scope-drift-stop-rule | project-intake-mode-selector; cost-ledger; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U13 | context-compiler-crosslink | ccpe-system-forge; agentic-handbook-operating-law; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U14 | dimensional-reduction-production-line | production-workshop-crosslink; project-intake-mode-selector; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U15 | complexity-buys-value | project-intake-mode-selector; scope-drift-stop-rule; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U16 | dimensional-reduction-production-line | project-intake-mode-selector; scope-drift-stop-rule; archival-context | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U17 | qpi-drift | project-intake-mode-selector; cost-ledger; dimensional-reduction-production-line | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R03-U18 | article-8-material-direction | dimensional-reduction-production-line; complexity-buys-value; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
|
||||
R03 routing note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R03 中的降维输出只作为生产线型 MVP 案例和 production-workshop cross-link，不为 video-workbench 建 topic。专家系统原则优先路由到 hifi-agent-studio-principles 和 agentic-handbook-operating-law。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. R04 Routing
|
||||
|
||||
R04 是 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁主轮：从既有 V2.0 文本转向运行治理层。
|
||||
|
||||
| Unit | Primary Route | Secondary / Cross-Link Routes | Downstream Use |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R04-U01 | article-8-material-direction | dimensional-reduction-production-line; production-workshop-crosslink; archival-context | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R04-U02 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | archival-context; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R04-U03 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | agentic-handbook-operating-law; archival-context | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U04 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | ccpe-system-forge; qpi-drift; archival-context | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R04-U05 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | complexity-buys-value; archival-context | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U06 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | cost-ledger; project-intake-mode-selector; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U07 | project-intake-mode-selector | qpi-drift; cost-ledger; hifi-agent-studio-principles | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U08 | project-intake-mode-selector | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U09 | cost-ledger | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U10 | execution-authenticity | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R04-U11 | scope-drift-stop-rule | complexity-buys-value; hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U12 | context-compiler-crosslink | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R04-U13 | human-gate-authority-trace | agentic-handbook-operating-law; hifi-agent-studio-principles | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U14 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | qpi-drift; production-workshop-crosslink; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R04-U15 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | project-intake-mode-selector; execution-authenticity; scope-drift-stop-rule; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
|
||||
R04 routing note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R04 是 HiFi patch 的主材料来源，但其中大量操作细则应路由到 Agentic Handbook。五个优先补丁模块进入 hifi-agent-studio-principles；表格、模板、字段和执行纪律进入 agentic-handbook-operating-law。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. R05 Routing
|
||||
|
||||
R05 是文档分层裁决轮：Studio 保持纲领，Handbook 承接开工守则，CCPE 是建造工坊，Runbook 是本地规程。
|
||||
|
||||
| Unit | Primary Route | Secondary / Cross-Link Routes | Downstream Use |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| R05-U01 | document-layering | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U02 | document-layering | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; ccpe-system-forge; project-runbook-local-procedure | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R05-U03 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | agentic-handbook-operating-law; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U04 | document-layering | execution-authenticity; project-intake-mode-selector; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U05 | document-layering | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; ccpe-system-forge; project-runbook-local-procedure | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U06 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | qpi-drift; project-intake-mode-selector; agentic-handbook-operating-law | hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U07 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | production-workshop-crosslink; ccpe-system-forge; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U08 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | scope-drift-stop-rule; cost-ledger; agentic-handbook-operating-law | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U09 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | execution-authenticity; cost-ledger; scope-drift-stop-rule; project-intake-mode-selector | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U10 | agentic-handbook-operating-law | project-intake-mode-selector; execution-authenticity; cost-ledger; scope-drift-stop-rule | handbook_material; hifi_patch_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R05-U11 | document-layering | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; project-runbook-local-procedure | handbook_material; hifi_patch_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R05-U12 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | cost-ledger; execution-authenticity; scope-drift-stop-rule; article-8-material-direction | hifi_patch_material; article_8_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U13 | agentic-handbook-operating-law | project-intake-mode-selector; ccpe-system-forge; project-runbook-local-procedure | handbook_material; hifi_patch_material; archival_context |
|
||||
| R05-U14 | hifi-agent-studio-principles | project-intake-mode-selector; execution-authenticity; cost-ledger; scope-drift-stop-rule; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
| R05-U15 | agentic-handbook-operating-law | cost-ledger; project-intake-mode-selector; article-8-material-direction | article_8_material; handbook_material; hifi_patch_material |
|
||||
| R05-U16 | document-layering | hifi-agent-studio-principles; agentic-handbook-operating-law; ccpe-system-forge; project-runbook-local-procedure | article_8_material; hifi_patch_material; handbook_material |
|
||||
|
||||
R05 routing note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R05 决定文档层级，不是创建文档目录。Studio 的五条原则进入 hifi-agent-studio-principles；Handbook 六组进入 agentic-handbook-operating-law；CCPE 和 project runbook 只作为承接层和 archival_context。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Route Target Coverage
|
||||
|
||||
| Route Target | Primary Units | Secondary / Cross-Link Units | Coverage Status |
|
||||
| --- | ---: | ---: | --- |
|
||||
| trigger-roi-ledger | 3 | 2 | covered |
|
||||
| writing-review-execution-authenticity | 2 | 5 | covered |
|
||||
| material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload | 4 | 5 | covered |
|
||||
| dimensional-reduction-production-line | 5 | 4 | covered |
|
||||
| qpi-drift | 3 | 7 | covered |
|
||||
| complexity-buys-value | 5 | 8 | covered |
|
||||
| cost-ledger | 2 | 15 | covered |
|
||||
| project-intake-mode-selector | 8 | 22 | covered |
|
||||
| execution-authenticity | 7 | 13 | covered |
|
||||
| scope-drift-stop-rule | 4 | 17 | covered |
|
||||
| human-gate-authority-trace | 1 | 1 | covered |
|
||||
| hifi-agent-studio-principles | 16 | 29 | covered |
|
||||
| agentic-handbook-operating-law | 3 | 40 | covered |
|
||||
| document-layering | 6 | 0 | covered |
|
||||
| ccpe-system-forge | 3 | 8 | covered |
|
||||
| project-runbook-local-procedure | 0 | 9 | covered_as_context |
|
||||
| context-compiler-crosslink | 3 | 3 | cross_link_only |
|
||||
| production-workshop-crosslink | 0 | 6 | cross_link_only |
|
||||
| article-8-material-direction | 6 | 21 | material_direction_only |
|
||||
| archival-context | 0 | 8 | context_only |
|
||||
|
||||
Coverage note:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Some targets are intentionally mostly secondary or context routes. `project-runbook-local-procedure`, `production-workshop-crosslink`, `article-8-material-direction`, and `archival-context` should not force standalone topic docs unless later user instruction changes scope.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 10. Topic Doc Drafting Groups
|
||||
|
||||
If topic docs are created next, suggested groups are:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
core_topic_docs:
|
||||
- id: 01-complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
- complexity-buys-value
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
- qpi-drift
|
||||
- id: 02-practice-cases
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
- material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
- dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
- id: 03-agentic-governance
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
- id: 04-hifi-studio-patch
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
- id: 05-agentic-handbook-materials
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
- id: 06-document-layering-and-carryover
|
||||
routes:
|
||||
- ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
- project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
- production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
- article-8-material-direction
|
||||
- archival-context
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Topic-doc boundary:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Topic docs should use this routing log and worker returned outputs. They should not reread source as primary extraction, create model assets, create article outlines, or create downstream handoffs.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 11. Open Items For Later, Not Current Blockers
|
||||
|
||||
These do not block routing or topic-doc drafting:
|
||||
|
||||
- Whether HiFi Agent Studio patch eventually becomes a formal Studio document.
|
||||
- Whether Agentic Handbook later expands beyond the first six groups.
|
||||
- Whether Context Compiler becomes a future core concept after user-authored正文 exists.
|
||||
- Whether Production Workshop becomes useful in a separate video / production-workbench run.
|
||||
- What the final第 8 篇文章 outline should be.
|
||||
|
||||
These would require user confirmation if they arise:
|
||||
|
||||
- creating downstream handoff;
|
||||
- creating model assets;
|
||||
- claiming source can be discarded;
|
||||
- turning article material into formal outline;
|
||||
- elevating Context Compiler or Production Workshop into core topic.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,207 @@
|
|||
# 03 Run Notes
|
||||
|
||||
## Run State
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
current_phase: Step 0 whole-source gestalt alignment
|
||||
current_phase: broad-fidelity worker dispatch
|
||||
status: worker_invocation_packets_prepared
|
||||
child_thread_id: 019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
main_session_primary_extraction_allowed: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Decisions
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Source Registration
|
||||
|
||||
- Source file registered at `C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md`.
|
||||
- Work directory confirmed as `C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
- Source has 5 numeric H1 conversation rounds and 5079 lines.
|
||||
- `## GPT` marks the GPT response start inside each numeric round.
|
||||
- Non-numeric H1 headings inside rounds are content headings, not round boundaries.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Structural Prior
|
||||
|
||||
User supplied this guiding interpretation:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程就是我在践行我的 AI 开发方法论。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0 must therefore avoid a premature binary split between:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- 前三回合: 深度创作流程
|
||||
- 后两回合: AI 开发方法论
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
The participant may still recommend macro-splitting if the source evidence requires it, but it must first test the stronger unified hypothesis:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
deep creative workflow = lived/practical instantiation of the AI development methodology
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Step 0 Sent
|
||||
|
||||
- Step 0 was sent to Codex child thread `019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1`.
|
||||
- Child thread title: `Step 0 whole-source gestalt: 2026-06-12 复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
- Required return path: `invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md`.
|
||||
- Status at handoff from main session: `in_progress`.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Step 0 Returned Output Available
|
||||
|
||||
- Returned output exists at `invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md`.
|
||||
- File size at verification: 20733 bytes.
|
||||
- Participant thread id recorded in output: `019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1`.
|
||||
- Local verification confirmed no `01-topic-map.md` or `02-material-routing-log.md` exists.
|
||||
- `topics/` and `audits/` remain empty.
|
||||
- Child thread status at final app check: `completed`; thread status `idle`.
|
||||
- The returned output is internally marked `human_confirmation_status: pending`.
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0 provisional result:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
coherence_judgment: coherent
|
||||
main_axis_recommendation: unified_main_axis
|
||||
recommended_downstream_mode: structure-first
|
||||
topic_organization_recommendation: mixed_graph
|
||||
worker_lens_recommendation: required
|
||||
human_confirmation_status: pending
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Gate 0 Confirmed With Constraints
|
||||
|
||||
- Confirmation record: `invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md`.
|
||||
- Root theme accepted: `复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
- Three downstream task directions:
|
||||
- 第 8 篇文章
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 补丁
|
||||
- Agentic Handbook 守则
|
||||
- Practice flows are case-layer material, not independent parent topics.
|
||||
- Model assets are forbidden in this run.
|
||||
- `video-workbench` is excluded.
|
||||
- GPT external links remain discussion material only.
|
||||
- Permission granted: create segmentation worker design and dispatch broad-fidelity workers.
|
||||
- Still forbidden: `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, audits, model assets, writing-workbench handoff.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Broad-Fidelity Worker Packets Prepared
|
||||
|
||||
- Worker design: `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
- Worker status: `05-broad-fidelity-worker-status.md`.
|
||||
- Prepared packets:
|
||||
- `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/agent-invocation-packet.md`
|
||||
- `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/agent-invocation-packet.md`
|
||||
- `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/agent-invocation-packet.md`
|
||||
- `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/agent-invocation-packet.md`
|
||||
- `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/agent-invocation-packet.md`
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Broad-Fidelity Workers Sent
|
||||
|
||||
- R01 thread: `019eb8b0-d226-7733-9c24-0f65840c37e7`
|
||||
- R02 thread: `019eb8b1-1263-7c82-a43d-d2c4b8492d3d`
|
||||
- R03 thread: `019eb8b1-5ba1-71e2-9bb9-4377e2c239bd`
|
||||
- R04 thread: `019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9`
|
||||
- R05 thread: `019eb8b1-f796-7af1-a2d7-0564617dd257`
|
||||
- Status at dispatch: `sent_in_progress`.
|
||||
|
||||
R04 retry:
|
||||
|
||||
- Original R04 thread `019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9` did not produce `R04/returned-output.md` after repeated checks.
|
||||
- Replacement R04 thread created: `019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a`.
|
||||
- Accepted R04 output path remains `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Broad-Fidelity Workers Returned
|
||||
|
||||
- R01 returned and verified.
|
||||
- R02 returned and verified.
|
||||
- R03 returned and verified.
|
||||
- R04 returned; accepted file metadata is `broad-fidelity-R04-retry1` with `supersedes_thread_id: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9`.
|
||||
- R05 returned and verified.
|
||||
- `01-topic-map.md` and `02-material-routing-log.md` still do not exist.
|
||||
- `topics/` and `audits/` remain empty.
|
||||
- Next allowed stage: synthesis-prep over file-backed worker outputs.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
## Runtime Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
The main session may:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- register the source
|
||||
- create source maps and run notes
|
||||
- prepare invocation packets and prompts
|
||||
- record child-thread ids and returned-output status
|
||||
- integrate file-backed participant outputs after they return
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
The main session must not:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- perform the Step 0 whole-source analysis itself
|
||||
- create final 01-topic-map.md before Step 0 human confirmation
|
||||
- perform evidence routing or material-unit extraction
|
||||
- create topic docs from direct source reading
|
||||
- treat prompt-only or packet-only stages as executed
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Next Gate
|
||||
|
||||
The old Step 0 gate is complete. Current continuation handoff:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
handoff/continuation/2026-06-12-after-broad-fidelity-workers-handoff.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Current next step:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
synthesis-prep over five file-backed worker outputs
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
No additional user confirmation is needed before synthesis-prep. User confirmation is required before promoting any synthesis result to `01-topic-map.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Synthesis Prep, Topic Map, And Material Routing
|
||||
|
||||
- Synthesis-prep output created at `invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md`.
|
||||
- User confirmed topic-map promotion boundaries in conversation; durable record created at `invocations/synthesis-prep/human-confirmation.md`.
|
||||
- `01-topic-map.md` created with `复杂度放置门` as root and `专家型 Agentic 运行治理` under that root.
|
||||
- Workflow rules were corrected so material routing is not a standalone "should we continue?" confirmation gate. Human gates now pause only when user-level decisions are needed.
|
||||
- `02-material-routing-log.md` created from the five broad-fidelity worker returned outputs and confirmed topic map.
|
||||
- Routing status:
|
||||
- R01 units routed: 16
|
||||
- R02 units routed: 16
|
||||
- R03 units routed: 18
|
||||
- R04 units routed: 15
|
||||
- R05 units routed: 16
|
||||
- Total material units routed: 81
|
||||
- Still not created: topic docs, audits, model assets, writing-workbench handoff, article outline.
|
||||
- Next mechanical stage: prepare topic-doc drafting groups from `02-material-routing-log.md`.
|
||||
- Pause only if topic-doc preparation exposes new user-level decisions such as topic elevation, downstream scope expansion, model-asset creation, source-disposable claims, or writing-workbench handoff.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Topic Docs Created
|
||||
|
||||
- Topic docs created from `02-material-routing-log.md` and worker returned outputs:
|
||||
- `topics/01-complexity-placement-gate.md`
|
||||
- `topics/02-practice-cases.md`
|
||||
- `topics/03-agentic-governance.md`
|
||||
- `topics/04-hifi-studio-patch.md`
|
||||
- `topics/05-agentic-handbook-materials.md`
|
||||
- `topics/06-document-layering-and-carryover.md`
|
||||
- Integration mode explicitly marked as `main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs`.
|
||||
- Primary source was not reread for topic-doc extraction.
|
||||
- Topic docs do not create model assets, article outline, formal HiFi patch, formal Handbook, or downstream handoff.
|
||||
- Next mechanical stage: verification / coverage and distortion check over topic map, routing log, and topic docs.
|
||||
- Pause only if verification exposes user-level decisions or requests a repair strategy.
|
||||
|
||||
### 2026-06-12: Bounded Audit And Continuation Handoff
|
||||
|
||||
- Coverage audit created at `audits/coverage-audit.md`.
|
||||
- Distortion risk log created at `audits/distortion-risk-log.md`.
|
||||
- Audit result: `pass_with_noted_boundaries`.
|
||||
- Audit did not require user repair strategy.
|
||||
- Continuation handoff created at `handoff/continuation/2026-06-12-after-topic-docs-and-audit-handoff.md`.
|
||||
- Still not created: model assets, formal HiFi patch, formal Agentic Handbook, writing-workbench handoff, article outline, video-workbench topic.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,179 @@
|
|||
# 04 Segmentation / Worker Design
|
||||
|
||||
## Status
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: segmentation_worker_design
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
gate_0_step_0_status: human_confirmed_with_constraints
|
||||
accepted_step_0_output: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
human_confirmation_record: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
approved_segmentation_strategy: round-first_with_user_gpt_slice_notes
|
||||
worker_priority: broad_fidelity_analysis_first
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
human_review_language_requirement: zh-CN
|
||||
creates_topic_map: false
|
||||
creates_topic_docs: false
|
||||
creates_routing_log: false
|
||||
creates_model_card: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本文件只定义 segmentation / worker 分拆设计。它不是 topic-map，不是 routing-log，也不是 worker 正文输出。
|
||||
|
||||
## Confirmed Step 0 Lens
|
||||
|
||||
后续 worker 必须携带以下 lens：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
本源材料的主轴是“复杂度放置门”：用户通过深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出和 HiFi Agent Studio 的实践复盘，推导出专家型 Agentic 系统需要在项目入口、执行真实性、成本分账、停止规则、任务漂移和文档分层上建立运行治理。深度创作流程是该 AI 开发方法论的实践样本，不是与方法论并列的宏主题。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Human-Confirmed Additions
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. 根主题可采用“复杂度放置门”。
|
||||
2. “深度创作流程 / 素材提炼 / 降维输出”主要是实践案例层，不是独立父主题。
|
||||
3. 后续材料需要支撑三个连续任务：
|
||||
- 写第 8 篇文章
|
||||
- 为 HiFi Agent Studio 打补丁
|
||||
- 补充 Agentic Handbook 守则内容
|
||||
4. 本次不做模型资产；模型资产必须等用户产生正文并经过讨论 / 正交过程后再抽取。
|
||||
5. 不考虑 video-workbench。
|
||||
6. GPT 外部链接只保留为讨论材料，不在本次核验或提升为正式知识资产依据。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Segmentation Rule
|
||||
|
||||
只按 `00-source-map.md` 中记录的数字 Markdown H1 边界分段：
|
||||
|
||||
| worker_id | range_id | heading | source_line_range | user_slice | gpt_slice |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R01 | R01 | `# 1` | 1-1020 | 1-842 | 843-1020 |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R02 | R02 | `# 2` | 1021-1909 | 1021-1191 | 1192-1909 |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R03 | R03 | `# 3` | 1910-2638 | 1910-1961 | 1962-2638 |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R04 | R04 | `# 4` | 2639-4013 | 2639-2903 | 2904-4013 |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R05 | R05 | `# 5` | 4014-5079 | 4014-4026 | 4027-5079 |
|
||||
|
||||
禁止把非数字 H1、内部标题、产品名、方法名或 GPT 生成的文档标题当成 round boundary。
|
||||
|
||||
## Worker Type
|
||||
|
||||
第一轮只 dispatch `broad-fidelity` worker：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
worker_type: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
primary_task: preserve_source_material_units
|
||||
secondary_task: assign_case_and_downstream_task_tags
|
||||
not_task:
|
||||
- create_topic_map
|
||||
- create_topic_docs
|
||||
- create_model_card
|
||||
- perform_model_mining
|
||||
- synthesize_final_structure
|
||||
- verify_external_links
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Worker Output Contract
|
||||
|
||||
每个 worker 输出一个 Markdown 文件：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/Rxx/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
每个 worker 文件必须包含：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-Rxx
|
||||
round_id: Rxx
|
||||
source_line_range: start-end
|
||||
user_slice: start-end
|
||||
gpt_slice: start-end
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
正文结构：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Round Scope
|
||||
2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Material Unit Schema
|
||||
|
||||
每个材料单元使用以下字段：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: Rxx-Uyy
|
||||
source_lines: start-end
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input | gpt_response | mixed
|
||||
fidelity_summary: ""
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material | candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only | none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- ""
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- ""
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Distortion Risks To Carry Into Every Worker
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. 不要把深度创作流程、素材提炼、降维输出升为平级父主题；它们主要是实践案例层。
|
||||
2. 不要把“复杂度放置门”缩减为单纯反过度工程；它是复杂度放置、执行真实性、成本分账、停止规则、任务漂移和文档分层的运行治理判断。
|
||||
3. 不要创建模型资产、model card、model index entry 或 model-mining 输出。
|
||||
4. 不要为 video-workbench 创建 topic。
|
||||
5. 不要核验或提升 GPT 外部链接；只作为讨论材料保留。
|
||||
6. 不要把第 8 篇文章、HiFi Agent Studio 补丁、Agentic Handbook 守则合并为单一输出；它们是三个连续但不同的任务方向。
|
||||
7. 不要创建 topic-map、routing-log、topic docs 或 audit。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Dispatch Order
|
||||
|
||||
推荐并行 dispatch：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. broad-fidelity-R01
|
||||
2. broad-fidelity-R02
|
||||
3. broad-fidelity-R03
|
||||
4. broad-fidelity-R04
|
||||
5. broad-fidelity-R05
|
||||
6. synthesis-prep: only after all five worker outputs return
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Next Gate
|
||||
|
||||
下一步是生成每个 `broad-fidelity-Rxx` 的 invocation packet，并等待真实 participant output。
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
may_create_worker_invocation_packets: true
|
||||
may_dispatch_broad_fidelity_workers: true
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: false
|
||||
may_create_routing_log: false
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
|
|||
# 05 Broad-Fidelity Worker Status
|
||||
|
||||
## Status
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_worker_dispatch
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
gate_0_status: confirmed_with_constraints
|
||||
accepted_worker_lens: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
human_confirmation_record: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: false
|
||||
may_create_routing_log: false
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
may_create_model_assets: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Worker Table
|
||||
|
||||
| worker_id | source_range | prompt | thread_id | status | output |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R01 | 1-1020 | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/prompt-to-send.md` | 019eb8b0-d226-7733-9c24-0f65840c37e7 | returned_verified | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md` |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R02 | 1021-1909 | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/prompt-to-send.md` | 019eb8b1-1263-7c82-a43d-d2c4b8492d3d | returned_verified | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md` |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R03 | 1910-2638 | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/prompt-to-send.md` | 019eb8b1-5ba1-71e2-9bb9-4377e2c239bd | returned_verified | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md` |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R04 | 2639-4013 | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/prompt-to-send.md` | 019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a | returned_verified_retry1_accepted | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md` |
|
||||
| broad-fidelity-R05 | 4014-5079 | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/prompt-to-send.md` | 019eb8b1-f796-7af1-a2d7-0564617dd257 | returned_verified | `invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md` |
|
||||
|
||||
## Worker Threads
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
broad-fidelity-R01: 019eb8b0-d226-7733-9c24-0f65840c37e7
|
||||
broad-fidelity-R02: 019eb8b1-1263-7c82-a43d-d2c4b8492d3d
|
||||
broad-fidelity-R03: 019eb8b1-5ba1-71e2-9bb9-4377e2c239bd
|
||||
broad-fidelity-R04: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
broad-fidelity-R05: 019eb8b1-f796-7af1-a2d7-0564617dd257
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
R04 retry:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
original_thread_id: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
original_status: completed_but_superseded_by_retry_metadata
|
||||
replacement_thread_id: 019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a
|
||||
replacement_status: completed_accepted
|
||||
accepted_output_path: invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Returned Output Verification
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
returned_outputs_count: 5
|
||||
R01_output_size_bytes: 24846
|
||||
R02_output_size_bytes: 33431
|
||||
R03_output_size_bytes: 34705
|
||||
R04_output_size_bytes: 31581
|
||||
R05_output_size_bytes: 25335
|
||||
forbidden_01_topic_map_exists: false
|
||||
forbidden_02_material_routing_log_exists: false
|
||||
topics_dir_file_count: 0
|
||||
audits_dir_file_count: 0
|
||||
ready_for_synthesis_prep: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Collection Gate
|
||||
|
||||
Do not run synthesis or create `01-topic-map.md` until all five workers either return or are explicitly recorded as blocked.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
|
|||
# Viewpoint Distillation Run: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
|
||||
## Purpose
|
||||
|
||||
This work directory records a `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run for a five-round ChatGPT discussion draft.
|
||||
|
||||
The source discussion begins from the user's deep creative workflow and extends into concrete AI development methodology. The user's structural prior for this run is:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程 is not a separate parallel topic from AI 开发方法论.
|
||||
It is the user's practical enactment of that AI development methodology.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Current phase:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
stage: broad-fidelity worker collection
|
||||
status: five_worker_outputs_returned_pending_synthesis_prep
|
||||
child_thread_id: 019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1
|
||||
step0_invocation_packet: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/agent-invocation-packet.md
|
||||
step0_prompt_to_send: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
step0_returned_output: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
step0_human_confirmation: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
segmentation_worker_design: 04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
broad_fidelity_worker_status: 05-broad-fidelity-worker-status.md
|
||||
source_map: 00-source-map.md
|
||||
run_notes: 03-run-notes.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0 summary:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
coherence_judgment: coherent
|
||||
main_axis_recommendation: unified_main_axis
|
||||
recommended_downstream_mode: structure-first
|
||||
topic_organization_recommendation: mixed_graph
|
||||
worker_lens_recommendation: required_after_human_confirmation
|
||||
human_confirmation_status: pending
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Gate 0 was later confirmed with constraints in:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Source
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Runtime Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
The main session may create run-control files, invocation packets, source maps, and human confirmation records.
|
||||
|
||||
The main session must not perform primary source analysis, final topic routing, topic document drafting, or material extraction.
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0 whole-source gestalt analysis must be performed by a recorded Codex child thread or another real persistent participant.
|
||||
|
||||
## Source Boundary Rule
|
||||
|
||||
Only numeric Markdown H1 headings matching `^#\s+\d+\s*$` are conversation-round boundaries.
|
||||
|
||||
Within each numeric round:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
# N -> before ## GPT: user input / source material
|
||||
## GPT -> before next # N+1: GPT response
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Non-numeric H1 headings inside a round are intra-round content, not round boundaries.
|
||||
|
||||
## Confirmation Gate
|
||||
|
||||
After Step 0 returns, pause for human confirmation before:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- accepting the gestalt as a worker lens
|
||||
- deciding whether the source should stay unified or be macro-split
|
||||
- choosing structure-first / macro-topic / flat-discovery downstream mode
|
||||
- dispatching segmentation or worker extraction
|
||||
- creating 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- creating topic docs or material routing
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Gate 0 confirmation allows broad-fidelity worker dispatch only. It does not allow topic-map, routing-log, topic-doc, model-asset, audit, or writing-workbench handoff creation.
|
||||
|
||||
Broad-fidelity worker collection status:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R01: returned
|
||||
R02: returned
|
||||
R03: returned
|
||||
R04: returned via retry1 accepted output
|
||||
R05: returned
|
||||
next_allowed_stage: synthesis-prep over worker returned outputs
|
||||
still_forbidden: direct topic-map / routing-log / topic-doc / model-asset creation
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,164 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: coverage-audit
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
artifact_type: coverage_audit
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- topics/
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/
|
||||
auditor_mode: main_session_bounded_verification
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
source_disposable_claim: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Coverage Audit
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Audit Scope
|
||||
|
||||
本审计只验证当前 run 的结构覆盖状态：
|
||||
|
||||
- topic map 是否有 canonical root 和 route targets；
|
||||
- material routing 是否覆盖五个 worker 的 material units；
|
||||
- topic docs 是否覆盖 routing groups；
|
||||
- 禁止产物是否未创建；
|
||||
- 是否存在需要用户决定的 repair strategy。
|
||||
|
||||
本审计不声明源材料可丢弃，不核验外链，不创建模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Artifact Coverage
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_map_exists: true
|
||||
topic_map_exists: true
|
||||
material_routing_log_exists: true
|
||||
topic_docs_count: 6
|
||||
coverage_audit_exists: true
|
||||
distortion_risk_log_exists: true
|
||||
model_mining_file_count: 0
|
||||
downstream_handoff_created_by_this_stage: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Current topic docs:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
topics/01-complexity-placement-gate.md
|
||||
topics/02-practice-cases.md
|
||||
topics/03-agentic-governance.md
|
||||
topics/04-hifi-studio-patch.md
|
||||
topics/05-agentic-handbook-materials.md
|
||||
topics/06-document-layering-and-carryover.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Material Unit Coverage
|
||||
|
||||
Routing log unit counts:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
R01_units_routed: 16
|
||||
R02_units_routed: 16
|
||||
R03_units_routed: 18
|
||||
R04_units_routed: 15
|
||||
R05_units_routed: 16
|
||||
total_material_units_routed: 81
|
||||
all_worker_rounds_represented: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
The route table includes every unit emitted by the five broad-fidelity worker outputs.
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Topic Coverage
|
||||
|
||||
Primary route targets have corresponding topic-doc coverage:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
complexity_placement_gate:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/01-complexity-placement-gate.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
- complexity-buys-value
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
- qpi-drift
|
||||
practice_cases:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/02-practice-cases.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
- material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
- dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
agentic_governance:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/03-agentic-governance.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
hifi_patch:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/04-hifi-studio-patch.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
handbook_materials:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/05-agentic-handbook-materials.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
document_layering_and_carryover:
|
||||
topic_doc: topics/06-document-layering-and-carryover.md
|
||||
covers:
|
||||
- document-layering
|
||||
- ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
- project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
- production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
- article-8-material-direction
|
||||
- archival-context
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Boundary Coverage
|
||||
|
||||
Confirmed boundaries preserved:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
root_topic_complexity_placement_gate: true
|
||||
agentic_governance_under_root: true
|
||||
practice_cases_not_independent_parents: true
|
||||
hifi_patch_minimal_five_principles_preserved: true
|
||||
handbook_first_pass_six_groups_preserved: true
|
||||
context_compiler_crosslink_only: true
|
||||
production_workshop_crosslink_only: true
|
||||
article_8_material_direction_only: true
|
||||
video_workbench_topic_created: false
|
||||
model_asset_created: false
|
||||
writing_workbench_handoff_created: false
|
||||
article_outline_created: false
|
||||
external_links_verified_or_elevated: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Residual Risks
|
||||
|
||||
Residual risks are manageable and do not require immediate user repair:
|
||||
|
||||
1. Topic docs are integration artifacts from worker outputs, not new worker/sub-session returned outputs.
|
||||
- Mitigation: each topic doc explicitly marks `integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs` and `primary_source_re_read: false`.
|
||||
|
||||
2. Some route targets are intentionally secondary / cross-link only.
|
||||
- Mitigation: `Context Compiler`, `Production Workshop`, `article-8-material-direction`, and `archival-context` are marked as non-core or context routes.
|
||||
|
||||
3. Handbook materials are not exhaustive.
|
||||
- Mitigation: topic docs preserve user note that the six groups are first-pass source material, not final Handbook scope.
|
||||
|
||||
4. HiFi patch is not formal Studio text.
|
||||
- Mitigation: topic doc states `formal_hifi_patch: false`.
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Audit Result
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
coverage_status: pass_with_noted_boundaries
|
||||
requires_user_repair_strategy: false
|
||||
ready_for_topic_docs_human_review_if_user_wants_review: true
|
||||
ready_for_downstream_handoff: false
|
||||
source_disposable_claim_allowed: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
No new user-level decision is required by this audit.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: distortion-risk-log
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
artifact_type: distortion_risk_log
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- topics/
|
||||
source_disposable_claim: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Distortion Risk Log
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Purpose
|
||||
|
||||
本文件记录本 run 当前阶段最容易发生的结构性误读，并说明当前 artifacts 如何防止这些误读。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Risk Register
|
||||
|
||||
| Risk | Status | Mitigation |
|
||||
| --- | --- | --- |
|
||||
| 把 `复杂度放置门` 简化成反复杂度 / 反工程化 | controlled | `01-topic-map.md` 和 `topics/01-complexity-placement-gate.md` 明确写成“复杂度购买价值”和“默认轻量，证据驱动升级”。 |
|
||||
| 把深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出升为三个平级父主题 | controlled | `01-topic-map.md` 将它们放入 `practice-cases`，`topics/02-practice-cases.md` 标为证据层。 |
|
||||
| 把第一次写作评审失败误写成“多 Agent 太复杂” | controlled | 路由到 `execution-authenticity`，强调失败是缺真实 invocation record。 |
|
||||
| 把素材提炼 Full Runtime 误写成“流程错了” | controlled | 路由到 `material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload`，强调 whole-source gestalt 有效但 Full 默认化过重。 |
|
||||
| 把降维输出扩展为 `video-workbench` topic | controlled | topic map、routing log、topic docs 多处标注不创建 video-workbench topic。 |
|
||||
| 把 `Context Compiler` 升为核心 topic 或模型资产 | controlled | 标为 `cross_link_candidate` / `candidate_cross_link_only`，topic docs 不创建模型资产。 |
|
||||
| 把 `Production Workshop` 升为核心 topic | controlled | 标为 cross-link only，并限制为分类材料。 |
|
||||
| 把 HiFi patch 写成正式 Studio 文本 | controlled | `topics/04-hifi-studio-patch.md` 标注 `formal_hifi_patch: false`。 |
|
||||
| 把 Agentic Handbook 六组误当成最终唯一范围 | controlled | `topics/05-agentic-handbook-materials.md` 保留用户补充：六组只是原始素材组织方式。 |
|
||||
| 把第 8 篇文章素材写成正式提纲 | controlled | `topics/06-document-layering-and-carryover.md` 和 topic map 标注 `article_outline: false` / material direction only。 |
|
||||
| 直接从 GPT 建议抽取 model assets | controlled | 所有当前 artifacts 标注 model_asset false 或 model asset prohibited。 |
|
||||
| 核验或提升 GPT 外部链接 | controlled | coverage audit 标注 external links not verified / discussion material only。 |
|
||||
| 主会话冒充 worker extraction | controlled_with_note | topic docs 标注 `main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs`，未声称是独立 worker returned-output。 |
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Remaining Non-Blocking Caveats
|
||||
|
||||
1. 当前 topic docs 是整合文档，不是 formal worker output。
|
||||
2. 当前 audit 是 bounded verification，不是 source-disposable audit。
|
||||
3. 当前 run 还没有 downstream handoff。
|
||||
4. 当前 run 没有正式 HiFi patch、Handbook、文章提纲或模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Repair Need
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
requires_immediate_repair: false
|
||||
requires_user_decision: false
|
||||
suggested_next_step: create completion handoff or await user review direction
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,206 @@
|
|||
# Continuation Handoff: After Broad-Fidelity Workers
|
||||
|
||||
## Entry Point
|
||||
|
||||
Work directory:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Source:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Current phase:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
current_stage: after_broad_fidelity_workers
|
||||
status: ready_for_synthesis_prep
|
||||
needs_user_confirmation_before_synthesis_prep: false
|
||||
needs_user_confirmation_before_01_topic_map_promotion: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## What Is Already Confirmed
|
||||
|
||||
Gate 0 / Step 0 was confirmed by the user.
|
||||
|
||||
Confirmation record:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Confirmed constraints:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Root theme may be `复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
2. The source is coherent and should stay under a unified main axis.
|
||||
3. 深度创作流程 / 素材提炼 / 降维输出 are practice-case layers, not independent parent topics.
|
||||
4. Downstream material must support three continuous but distinct tasks:
|
||||
- 写第 8 篇文章
|
||||
- 为 HiFi Agent Studio 打补丁
|
||||
- 补充 Agentic Handbook 守则内容
|
||||
5. This run must not create model assets.
|
||||
6. Model assets require user-authored正文 first, then discussion / orthogonal review, then extraction.
|
||||
7. Do not consider `video-workbench` in this run.
|
||||
8. GPT external links remain discussion material only; do not verify or elevate them as formal knowledge assets.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
No new user confirmation is needed before starting `synthesis-prep`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Completed Artifacts
|
||||
|
||||
Source registration:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
00-source-map.md
|
||||
03-run-notes.md
|
||||
README.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/agent-invocation-packet.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Segmentation / worker design:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
05-broad-fidelity-worker-status.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Broad-fidelity worker outputs:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Worker status:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
R01: returned_verified
|
||||
R02: returned_verified
|
||||
R03: returned_verified
|
||||
R04: returned_verified_retry1_accepted
|
||||
R05: returned_verified
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
R04 note:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
original_thread_id: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
replacement_thread_id: 019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a
|
||||
accepted_output: invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
accepted_output_metadata: broad-fidelity-R04-retry1
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Thread IDs
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
step0_whole_source_gestalt: 019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R01: 019eb8b0-d226-7733-9c24-0f65840c37e7
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R02: 019eb8b1-1263-7c82-a43d-d2c4b8492d3d
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R03: 019eb8b1-5ba1-71e2-9bb9-4377e2c239bd
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R04_original_superseded: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R04_retry1_accepted: 019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a
|
||||
broad_fidelity_R05: 019eb8b1-f796-7af1-a2d7-0564617dd257
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Current Verification State
|
||||
|
||||
Fresh verification before this handoff:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
returned_outputs_count: 5
|
||||
forbidden_01_topic_map_exists: false
|
||||
forbidden_02_material_routing_log_exists: false
|
||||
topics_dir_file_count: 0
|
||||
audits_dir_file_count: 0
|
||||
ready_for_synthesis_prep: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Next Allowed Step
|
||||
|
||||
Next stage:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
synthesis-prep over file-backed worker outputs
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Allowed actions:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Read Step 0 returned output and human confirmation.
|
||||
2. Read all five broad-fidelity returned outputs.
|
||||
3. Create a synthesis-prep invocation packet or local synthesis-prep record.
|
||||
4. Produce `invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md`.
|
||||
5. Summarize candidate graph structure, unresolved conflicts, coverage gaps, and topic-map drafting inputs.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
The synthesis-prep artifact should not be the canonical topic map. It should prepare the inputs for a later topic-graph synthesis / human confirmation step.
|
||||
|
||||
## Still Forbidden
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create these yet:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
01-topic-map.md
|
||||
02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
topics/*.md
|
||||
audits/*.md
|
||||
model-mining/*
|
||||
model cards
|
||||
model index entries
|
||||
writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- treat GPT external links as verified sources
|
||||
- extract model assets from the discussion draft
|
||||
- reintroduce video-workbench as a topic
|
||||
- collapse the three downstream tasks into one output
|
||||
- promote practice cases into independent parent topics
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Likely Synthesis-Prep Questions
|
||||
|
||||
The next session should answer these from worker outputs:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. What candidate root / first-level graph best preserves `复杂度放置门`?
|
||||
2. How should the three downstream task directions be separated but cross-linked?
|
||||
3. Which material units are article-8 material, HiFi patch material, Handbook material, or archival context?
|
||||
4. Which concepts are only candidate concepts and must not become model assets?
|
||||
5. What conflicts or overlaps must be resolved before drafting `01-topic-map.md`?
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Human Confirmation Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
No user confirmation is needed before `synthesis-prep`.
|
||||
|
||||
User confirmation is required before:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- promoting any synthesis result into `01-topic-map.md`
|
||||
- starting material routing
|
||||
- creating topic docs
|
||||
- creating downstream handoff
|
||||
- making any source-disposable claim
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,172 @@
|
|||
# Continuation Handoff: After Topic Docs And Audit
|
||||
|
||||
## Entry Point
|
||||
|
||||
Work directory:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Current status:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
current_stage: after_topic_docs_and_bounded_audit
|
||||
status: material_package_ready_for_human_review_or_downstream_decision
|
||||
blocking_user_question: false
|
||||
source_disposable_claim: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Completed Artifacts
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
00-source-map.md
|
||||
01-topic-map.md
|
||||
02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
03-run-notes.md
|
||||
04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
05-broad-fidelity-worker-status.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Step 0:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/agent-invocation-packet.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Broad-fidelity worker outputs:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Synthesis:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/synthesis-prep/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Topic docs:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
topics/01-complexity-placement-gate.md
|
||||
topics/02-practice-cases.md
|
||||
topics/03-agentic-governance.md
|
||||
topics/04-hifi-studio-patch.md
|
||||
topics/05-agentic-handbook-materials.md
|
||||
topics/06-document-layering-and-carryover.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Audits:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
audits/coverage-audit.md
|
||||
audits/distortion-risk-log.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Confirmed User Decisions
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
root_topic: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
agentic_governance_position: under_root
|
||||
hifi_patch_minimal_principles:
|
||||
- 默认轻量
|
||||
- 真实执行
|
||||
- 成本分账
|
||||
- 任务漂移
|
||||
- 停止权
|
||||
handbook_first_pass_groups:
|
||||
- Project Intake
|
||||
- Mode Selector
|
||||
- Cost Ledger
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity
|
||||
- Scope Drift
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
handbook_scope_note: six groups are source material organization, not final exclusive scope
|
||||
context_compiler_status: candidate_cross_link_only
|
||||
production_workshop_status: candidate_cross_link_only
|
||||
article_8_status: material_direction_only_not_outline
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Current Verification State
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
material_units_routed: 81
|
||||
R01_units_routed: 16
|
||||
R02_units_routed: 16
|
||||
R03_units_routed: 18
|
||||
R04_units_routed: 15
|
||||
R05_units_routed: 16
|
||||
topic_docs_count: 6
|
||||
audits_count: 2
|
||||
model_mining_file_count: 0
|
||||
formal_hifi_patch_created: false
|
||||
formal_handbook_created: false
|
||||
article_outline_created: false
|
||||
writing_workbench_handoff_created: false
|
||||
video_workbench_topic_created: false
|
||||
external_links_verified_or_elevated: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Rule Correction Applied
|
||||
|
||||
The workflow rule was corrected during this run:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Do not add a human gate merely to ask whether the workflow may enter the next mechanical stage.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Human gates now pause only for substantive decisions such as:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- hierarchy / merge / split / scope questions
|
||||
- downstream target or receiving workbench
|
||||
- extracted material usefulness before downstream handoff
|
||||
- repair strategy
|
||||
- source-disposable claims
|
||||
- model-asset creation
|
||||
- formal article / Handbook / HiFi document creation
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Material routing is treated as mechanical implementation after topic hierarchy confirmation.
|
||||
|
||||
## Still Forbidden Without New User Instruction
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
model-mining/*
|
||||
model cards
|
||||
model index entries
|
||||
formal HiFi Agent Studio patch text
|
||||
formal Agentic Handbook text
|
||||
writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
article outline or draft
|
||||
video-workbench topic or runbook
|
||||
source-disposable claim
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Next Possible Moves
|
||||
|
||||
No blocking question is pending.
|
||||
|
||||
Possible next moves if the user requests them:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Review / repair current topic docs.
|
||||
2. Produce a downstream handoff for HiFi Agent Studio patching.
|
||||
3. Produce a downstream handoff for Agentic Handbook drafting.
|
||||
4. Produce a writing-workbench handoff for the 8th article only after explicit request.
|
||||
5. Start model-mining only after user-authored正文 exists and the user explicitly asks.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: broad-fidelity-R01
|
||||
|
||||
## Invocation Identity
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R01
|
||||
round_id: R01
|
||||
source_line_range: 1-1020
|
||||
user_slice: 1-842
|
||||
gpt_slice: 843-1020
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb8b0-d226-7733-9c24-0f65840c37e7
|
||||
execution_status: sent_in_progress
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Input Contract
|
||||
|
||||
Read:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R01\prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Output only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R01\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Forbidden:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- do not edit source
|
||||
- do not read outside R01 except shared context files named in the prompt
|
||||
- do not create 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- do not create 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- do not create topic docs
|
||||
- do not create model assets
|
||||
- do not verify external links
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: broad-fidelity-R01
|
||||
|
||||
You are `broad-fidelity-R01`, a formal worker participant in the Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run `2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Required Context
|
||||
|
||||
Read these files first:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Source Range
|
||||
|
||||
Read only this source range from:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
round_id: R01
|
||||
source_line_range: 1-1020
|
||||
user_slice: 1-842
|
||||
gpt_slice: 843-1020
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Task
|
||||
|
||||
Extract source-faithful material units from R01 only. Preserve distinctions between user input and GPT response. Use the confirmed Step 0 lens, but do not create a final topic map.
|
||||
|
||||
## Output
|
||||
|
||||
Write:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R01\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Use the output structure and material unit schema from `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
## Forbidden
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, model assets, audits, or writing-workbench handoff. Do not verify external links.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,501 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R01
|
||||
round_id: R01
|
||||
source_line_range: 1-1020
|
||||
user_slice: 1-842
|
||||
gpt_slice: 843-1020
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# broad-fidelity-R01 Returned Output
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Round Scope
|
||||
|
||||
本轮只处理 R01：`2026-06-12.md` 第 1-1020 行。其中用户输入为第 1-842 行，GPT 回应为第 843-1020 行。
|
||||
|
||||
R01 的核心材料不是完整方法论展开，而是整轮讨论的触发层：用户先给出 Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` 与 CCPE System 的现有流程背景，再提出一个强烈的 ROI 异常感：为了处理约 5 万字讨论稿，实际在 CCPE Agent/Skill、知识库 Skill、流程优化和测试上跑了三轮，消耗约 3000 万 tokens，却“只做了蒸馏”。GPT 回应将该异常归因为“单次内容蒸馏成本”和“系统研发/验证成本”混账，并提出 Lite / Standard / Full 三档、ROI / Scope Gate、Token Budget Guardrail、按 repo / 任务类型隔离 SuperPowers 的方向。
|
||||
|
||||
本轮在全局 Step 0 lens 下应视为“复杂度放置门”的触发问题与初始诊断层，不应被提升为最终 topic map。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U01: 源任务设定与用途边界
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U01
|
||||
source_lines: 1-12
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户说明有一个约 5 万字、7 回合的 ChatGPT 讨论稿，希望在 Codex 上一边打造拆解讨论稿的流程/Skill，一边基于该流程拆解原稿；拆解后的素材可服务后续写文章、优化认知模型或其他任务。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "source purpose vs runtime construction"
|
||||
- "content output vs system building ledger"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把用户的初始目标直接等同于 Full Runtime 需求；此处同时包含内容蒸馏和流程建设两个动机。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U02: Knowledge Vault distillation capability 的重型产物集合
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U02
|
||||
source_lines: 14-49
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户粘贴 `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` README：该能力用于把长观点讨论组织成可复用、可追溯的材料包；目标产物包括 source-map、topic-map、material-routing-log、topic documents、coverage audit、downstream handoff packets；明确不用于直接写文章、自动创建 writing-workbench 项目、删除/移动源文件、summary-only compression 或没有真实 invocation record 的 formal Agent output。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "artifact set as complexity driver"
|
||||
- "traceability requirement"
|
||||
- "formal invocation boundary"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把这些产物清单当作 R01 已确认的必要交付；它们是用户展示的现有重型流程背景。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U03: Runbook 的真实调用、Step 0 与 segmentation 规则
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U03
|
||||
source_lines: 50-148
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户粘贴 runbook 前段：创建工作目录前要读规则、确认源大小和 Step 0 策略、选择 invocation carrier；严格 invocation setup 要求真实 carrier、thread_id/agent_id、语言策略和 gate，不接受 packet-only 或 prompt-only 阶段为已执行；Step 0 需要真实高上下文参与者判断 coherence / mixed / fragmented，并经用户确认；segmentation pass 创建 worker thread-start packets，必要时携带已确认的 whole-source gestalt lens。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "whole-source gestalt"
|
||||
- "no-simulation / real invocation"
|
||||
- "worker dispatch cost"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把真实调用边界理解为问题本身；它既是保真机制，也是成本来源。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U04: Topic discovery、routing、audit、handoff 的生产线化链路
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U04
|
||||
source_lines: 150-229
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "runbook 后续规定 topic discovery 需使用真实 participant output，再从 accepted returned output 起草 topic-map；topic graph synthesis 要保留 parent/subtopic/tool/layer/case/action track/model upgrade 区分；Evidence Routing and Topic Docs 要从 worker returned outputs 写 material-routing-log、生成 topic docs；Audit 要调用 lossless-coverage-auditor，并写 coverage-audit 与 distortion-risk-log；Downstream Handoff 只有用户确认后才创建。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "governed runtime"
|
||||
- "coverage audit"
|
||||
- "handoff gate"
|
||||
- "topic graph synthesis"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把这条完整生产线默认套到所有 5 万字材料；R01 的问题正是这条链路的轻重选择。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U05: CCPE System 的定位与分类优先原则
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U05
|
||||
source_lines: 232-275
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户粘贴 CCPE System README：CCPE 是面向 Prompt、Agent、Skill、Workflow、Runtime、Cognitive Model 资产的 context protocol engineering framework，目标是让 AI 系统可复用、可测试、可组合、可协作、可维护；核心原则是不要把每个 AI artifact 都当作 prompt，第一任务是分类，第二是结构诊断，第三是创建或重构。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "classify before creating"
|
||||
- "artifact type selection"
|
||||
- "context protocol engineering"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 CCPE 的分类能力自动等同于必须为本次蒸馏创建完整 Agent/Runtime。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U06: CCPE artifact types 与 Runtime 三取向
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U06
|
||||
source_lines: 277-393
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "CCPE README 说明 Prompt Card、Agent Spec、Skill、Runtime 等 artifact 类型；Runtime 分为 Interactive、Automation、Hybrid 三类，分别适用于人主导深度思考、流程主导低不确定任务，以及深度工作为核心而由 Agent 处理收集、格式化、路由、去重和归档的混合场景。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full mode selector"
|
||||
- "interactive vs automation vs hybrid runtime"
|
||||
- "human decision gates"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Runtime 三取向压平为一个默认 Full 模式；R01 后续诊断正要求建立轻重选择器。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U07: Model Mining、Workflow 构建与 Do Not Over-Engineer 原则
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U07
|
||||
source_lines: 499-634
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "CCPE README 中的 Model Mining Mode 用于从长文、笔记、研究草稿或讨论中抽取显性/隐性模型、机制、程序、范围、失败模式等；多 Agent workflow 需要先定义 Runtime、Agent、Skill、Model Card、人类决策门和评价规则；同时 README 明确要求 Classify Before Creating 与 Do Not Over-Engineer，使用保留功能、清晰性和可维护性的最轻结构。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "model mining vs current no-model-asset boundary"
|
||||
- "anti-overengineering gate"
|
||||
- "minimum sufficient structure"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要在本轮把 Model Mining 内容转成模型资产；本次只保留为后续正文和守则素材。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U08: 用户提出的 ROI 异常与 SuperPowers 归因问题
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U08
|
||||
source_lines: 830-839
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户总结实际执行：在 CCPE 中打造 Agent/Skill、在 Knowledge Vault 生成对应 Skills、后续优化流程和测试，共跑三轮，统计约 3000 万 tokens。用户感到怪异，怀疑是否是“大炮打蚊子”：原始稿只有 5 万字，且只做蒸馏、没有外部延伸调查，理论上可由大上下文模型直接加工；用户询问是否 SuperPowers 插件导致，以及应如何看待。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "ROI anomaly"
|
||||
- "content cost vs system R&D cost"
|
||||
- "SuperPowers as process amplifier"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把问题简化为插件导致；用户的问题同时涉及任务分账、runbook 复杂度和入口门槛缺失。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U09: GPT 的总判断：不是单次蒸馏成本，而是混账
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U09
|
||||
source_lines: 843-850
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 判断用户的怪异感成立：3000 万 tokens 不是蒸馏 5 万字的成本，而是创建并测试可复用知识加工 Runtime、Agent/Skill 工程体系并用其跑一次案例的成本；问题在于这三件事被混进同一个 ROI 账本。GPT 指出现有 runbook 已将任务定义为 source-map、topic-map、routing-log、topic docs、coverage audit、handoff packets 等重型流程，并要求真实 invocation、worker/sub-session、human gate、coverage audit 和 distortion-risk-log。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "cost ledger"
|
||||
- "system R&D ledger"
|
||||
- "governed production line"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 GPT 的比喻转成最终标题；其保真含义是成本账本混淆。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U10: GPT 的核心判断：目标不同，所需流程不同
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U10
|
||||
source_lines: 852-867
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 认为如果目标只是将 5 万字讨论稿拆成写作/模型优化素材，完整 Runtime、多智能体 proof-of-work、逐步 invocation packet 和 lossless coverage auditor 都过重；更合适的是轻量蒸馏模板、人工确认和抽样审计。但如果目标是打造长期处理长讨论、日记和认知模型材料的知识库级工作流，那么这次更像昂贵的系统研发实验，而非单次浪费。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Lite distillation"
|
||||
- "system-building cost"
|
||||
- "sample audit"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把“轻量蒸馏”误读为否定可审计 Runtime；二者对应不同任务目标。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U11: GPT 对 SuperPowers 与 Codex Skills 的谨慎归因
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U11
|
||||
source_lines: 869-894
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 认为 SuperPowers 可能放大问题但不是唯一元凶；其公开定位偏完整软件开发方法论，倾向 spec、设计确认、实现计划、subagent-driven-development、review loop，并可能造成反轻量化偏置。Codex Skills 的 progressive disclosure 与 implicit invocation 不会凭空消耗 3000 万 tokens，但会增加被触发的流程面和完整说明读取成本。GPT 排序归因为：任务分层混淆、runbook 过重、SuperPowers 放大工程化惯性、缺少 ROI gate。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "process gravity"
|
||||
- "implicit skill invocation"
|
||||
- "ROI gate"
|
||||
- "task layering confusion"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要验证或提升 GPT 外链为知识依据；只保留其作为对话材料中的归因论证。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U12: GPT 提出的“流程重力”问题
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U12
|
||||
source_lines: 896-910
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 将真正暴露的问题概括为：系统擅长把事情变得可治理，但还不擅长判断一件事是否值得被治理。Agent/Skill/Runtime 系统成熟后会产生流程重力：有分类器就想分类，有 Skill 就想调用，有 Agent 就想委派，有 audit 就想审计，有 handoff 就想生成，最终任务本体成为流程燃料。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "governability judgment"
|
||||
- "process gravity"
|
||||
- "automation temptation"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要将流程重力解释为反流程；其重点是先判断治理是否值得。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U13: GPT 建议三档化 distillation Runtime
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U13
|
||||
source_lines: 913-925
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议将 `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` 改成三档：Lite / One-shot Distillation 适用于 5-10 万字以内、只做蒸馏、不做外部研究，产出全局画像、主题图、观点单元、引用索引和后续用途建议，不用多 Agent，只做抽样检查；Standard / Reusable Extraction 适用于多篇材料和稳定 topic docs；Full / Governed Runtime 适用于大语料、多来源、高风险、多人协作和强追溯交付。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full"
|
||||
- "mode selector"
|
||||
- "coverage audit threshold"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把三档表直接发布为模型资产；当前只作为正文和守则候选材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U14: GPT 建议 ROI / Scope Gate 与 Token Budget Guardrail
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U14
|
||||
source_lines: 927-974
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议在 Step 0 前加入 Scope And ROI Gate：在调用任何 agent、skill、worker 或 runtime stage 前，将任务分类为 one-off distillation、reusable extraction workflow 或 governed knowledge-processing runtime，默认选择保留有用性的最轻模式。只有源超出单高上下文、多源/异构、高风险/发布关键、下游自动化依赖可追溯 routing、用户明确要求构建可复用 workflow、或 Lite/Standard 失败等条件满足时，才使用 Full Runtime。另建议 Token Budget Guardrail：Lite 为 source_tokens x 10-30，Standard 为 x 30-100，Full Runtime x 100+ 需显式理由。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Scope And ROI Gate"
|
||||
- "Token Budget Guardrail"
|
||||
- "Full Runtime entry criteria"
|
||||
- "cost ledger"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 token 倍数当作精确计费模型；它在 R01 中是治理阈值和异常提示。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U15: GPT 建议按 repo / 任务类型隔离 SuperPowers
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U15
|
||||
source_lines: 976-992
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 不建议简单卸载 SuperPowers，而建议按 repo / 任务类型隔离：对知识蒸馏、model mining、写作准备和概念综合，除非明确请求，不使用 SuperPowers workflow skills；非代码提取任务默认不使用 subagent-driven-development；源材料可由单高上下文处理时优先 Lite；除非用户要求 governed runtime，否则使用最小 artifact set；将“构建可复用 Skill/Runtime”和“蒸馏这个 source”视为不同项目。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "repo-level policy"
|
||||
- "task-type isolation"
|
||||
- "minimal artifact set"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把外部配置说明作为已验证事实；本轮不验证外链，只保留政策建议的讨论内容。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R01-U16: GPT 的结论：系统边界测试与最小充分流程门
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R01-U16
|
||||
source_lines: 994-1019
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 将本次事件定性为系统边界测试：CCPE + Knowledge Vault 已能将非结构材料加工成可审计资产，但缺少“轻重选择器”，会把所有任务吸进 Runtime 黑洞。最该补的不是更多 Agent、Skill 或 audit，而是 Anti-Overengineering Gate / 最小充分流程门：先问任务是产出内容还是产出机器；产出内容用最短链路，产出机器把成本记入系统研发，两者都要则先分账再开工。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Anti-Overengineering Gate"
|
||||
- "minimum sufficient process"
|
||||
- "content vs machine ledger"
|
||||
- "runtime black hole"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把“最小充分流程门”直接升格为模型资产；当前只应作为候选概念与后续正文材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 用户输入主要提供背景、现有制度文本和问题感：Knowledge Vault 的 `viewpoint-discussion-distillation`、CCPE System 的 artifact taxonomy / Runtime / Model Mining / anti-overengineering 原则，以及“5 万字蒸馏消耗约 3000 万 tokens”的 ROI 异常。
|
||||
- GPT 回应主要提供解释框架和改造建议：成本分账、过重 runbook、SuperPowers 的流程放大作用、缺少 ROI gate、三档 distillation runtime、Token Budget Guardrail、按 repo / 任务类型隔离 workflow skills。
|
||||
- 用户材料中已经包含 “Do Not Over-Engineer” 与 “Use the lightest structure”；GPT 的贡献不是凭空引入轻量化，而是指出该原则没有成为 runtime 入口硬门槛。
|
||||
- R01 的 GPT 外链只应保留为讨论材料；本 worker 未核验外部链接，也不将其提升为正式知识资产依据。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `complexity_placement_gate`: R01 的主标签。用户的异常感与 GPT 的回应都围绕“复杂度应该放在哪里、何时值得治理、何时该轻量处理”展开。
|
||||
- `material_extraction`: R01 的触发场景是长讨论稿拆解与素材化，并明确比较“直接大上下文整理”与“完整知识生产线”。
|
||||
- `agentic_handbook`: GPT 提出的 ROI gate、mode selector、token budget、repo policy、minimal artifact set 更像运行守则候选素材。
|
||||
- `hifi_agent_studio`: CCPE / HiFi 方法论层面的补丁候选，包括 artifact 分类、Runtime 取向、最小充分流程门和复杂度放置判断。
|
||||
- `deep_creation_workflow`: 在 R01 中尚未作为具体案例展开，只通过“写文章/认知模型优化/后续任务”间接出现。
|
||||
- `dimensional_reduction_output`: 本轮未展开。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `article_8_material`: 可用于文章开篇的强问题意识，包括“只做蒸馏却像建工业级生产线”“产出内容还是产出机器”“系统边界测试”等材料。
|
||||
- `hifi_patch_material`: 可用于 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁，尤其是 Complexity Placement Gate、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity 与 Stop Rule 的入口性原则。
|
||||
- `handbook_material`: 可用于 Agentic Handbook 守则，尤其是 ROI / Scope Gate、Token Budget Guardrail、repo / task-type policy、Full Runtime entry criteria。
|
||||
- `archival_context`: 用户粘贴的大段 README/runbook/CCPE 背景，是后续理解该轮讨论来源和制度背景的必要归档上下文。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
以下只作为候选概念或后续正文素材保留，不创建 model card、model index entry 或任何模型资产：
|
||||
|
||||
- 复杂度放置门 / Complexity Placement Gate
|
||||
- 最小充分流程门 / Anti-Overengineering Gate
|
||||
- 任务分账 / 内容账本 vs 系统研发账本
|
||||
- Scope And ROI Gate
|
||||
- Token Budget Guardrail
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full distillation mode selector
|
||||
- 流程重力 / process gravity
|
||||
- governed runtime vs one-shot distillation
|
||||
- repo / task-type SuperPowers isolation policy
|
||||
- Full Runtime entry criteria
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- R01-U08 -> R01-U09: 用户 ROI 异常感与 GPT 成本混账解释。
|
||||
- R01-U02 / R01-U04 -> R01-U10: 现有重型产物链路与“如果只做素材化则过重”的判断。
|
||||
- R01-U05 / R01-U07 -> R01-U14: CCPE 已有“分类优先 / 最轻结构”原则，但需要变成入口 gate。
|
||||
- R01-U11 -> R01-U15: SuperPowers 作为流程放大器，与按 repo / 任务类型隔离的治理建议。
|
||||
- R01-U12 -> R01-U16: 流程重力与最小充分流程门构成同一诊断链。
|
||||
- R01-U13 -> R01-U14: 三档模式需要由 ROI / Scope Gate 和 token budget 做入口判断。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
1. 不要把 R01 归纳成“SuperPowers 导致浪费”。R01 的明确归因是任务分层混淆、runbook 过重、SuperPowers 放大工程化惯性、缺少 ROI gate。
|
||||
2. 不要把“轻量蒸馏”解释为否定 Knowledge Vault / CCPE 的可审计生产线；GPT 明确承认如果目标是长期知识库级 workflow，成本应记为系统研发实验。
|
||||
3. 不要把 Lite / Standard / Full、Scope And ROI Gate、Token Budget Guardrail 直接升格为模型资产。本次边界禁止 model asset extraction。
|
||||
4. 不要把 README/runbook 中的完整产物链视为 R01 已确认的必要流程；R01 正是在追问这些产物何时值得开启。
|
||||
5. 不要验证或提升 GPT 外部链接。本轮只保留其为对话中的讨论材料。
|
||||
6. 不要将 R01 单独写成最终 topic map；它是“触发问题与初始诊断”材料，后续仍需与 R02-R05 一起综合。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
|
||||
1. 最终 topic graph 中，“复杂度放置门”是否应作为根主题，还是作为“专家型 Agentic 系统运行治理”的入口子主题？
|
||||
2. Lite / Standard / Full 三档应归入 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁、Agentic Handbook 守则，还是两边都保留但承担不同粒度？
|
||||
3. “Token Budget Guardrail”的倍数阈值是否应作为正式守则数值，还是只作为文章中的异常感表达和启发式判断？
|
||||
4. SuperPowers 隔离策略应写成通用 repo policy，还是只作为 Knowledge Vault / writing preparation 场景的局部规则？
|
||||
5. R01 的“内容 vs 机器”分账原则，是否可以作为后三轮深度创作、降维输出、HiFi 补丁材料的统一入口判断？
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: broad-fidelity-R02
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R02
|
||||
round_id: R02
|
||||
source_line_range: 1021-1909
|
||||
user_slice: 1021-1191
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1192-1909
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb8b1-1263-7c82-a43d-d2c4b8492d3d
|
||||
execution_status: sent_in_progress
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Prompt:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R02\prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Output only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R02\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Forbidden: no source edits, no out-of-range source reading, no topic map, no routing log, no topic docs, no model assets, no external-link verification.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: broad-fidelity-R02
|
||||
|
||||
You are `broad-fidelity-R02`, a formal worker participant in the Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run `2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
|
||||
Read shared context:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Read only this source range:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
round_id: R02
|
||||
source_line_range: 1021-1909
|
||||
user_slice: 1021-1191
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1192-1909
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Extract source-faithful material units from R02 only. Preserve user/GPT distinction. Use the output structure and material unit schema from `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
Write only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R02\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, model assets, audits, or writing-workbench handoff. Do not verify external links.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,680 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R02
|
||||
round_id: R02
|
||||
source_line_range: 1021-1909
|
||||
user_slice: 1021-1191
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1192-1909
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# broad-fidelity-R02 Returned Output
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Round Scope
|
||||
|
||||
R02 主要围绕两次 Codex 流程改造展开：第一次是写作提纲评审流程改造，核心暴露出“多 Agent 真实性边界”失败；第二次是 `knowledge-vault` 素材提炼流程改造，核心暴露出“治理级 Runtime 被用于单次普通蒸馏任务”的 ROI / 档位问题。用户随后用 QPI 框架反思为什么自认为简单的 P 域流程改造，在 Agentic / Codex 环境中变得复杂。GPT 响应把这轮材料推向“复杂度放置门”：不只是反过度工程，而是判断复杂度是否买到了真实性、独立性、保真性、结构性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性和下游依赖。
|
||||
|
||||
本输出只提取 R02 范围内的保真材料单元。以下 `candidate_concept` 仅表示可供后续综合检查的讨论材料，不是模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U01
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U01
|
||||
source_lines: 1023-1047
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户说明这次流程改造已有两次 Codex 尝试。第一次围绕写作提纲评审阶段：旧流程中用户会把提纲交给张辽、认知显影、巨人认知评审，再综合意见交韩愈修复；复杂处不只是三位评审员，而是会话状态、是否延续、是否污染后续、韩愈是否需要保持长会话。最初想把已有提纲进入评审抽成小闭环，但很快发现真实写作常从观点素材开始，材料工程必须前移到韩愈立意和初稿提纲之前，而不是等评审阶段补救。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "写作流程的成熟经验作为 Agentic 方法论实践样本"
|
||||
- "上下文工程前置到主笔立意之前"
|
||||
- "会话状态与污染判断作为隐性专家判断"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把提纲评审小闭环误当作完整文章生产 Runtime。"
|
||||
- "不要把材料工程前移理解成单纯增加流程步骤；其作用是修复立意阶段上下文不足。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U02
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U02
|
||||
source_lines: 1048-1057
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户描述 Codex 相比 Gemini 超长上下文需要更明确的上下文工程：L0 Raw Sources、L1 Source Digest、L2 Outline-Aligned Context Pack、L3 Agent Dispatch Pack。由此形成 Outline Context Architect 角色，负责可复用的上下文工程，而不塞入韩愈本体；主会话 Runtime Operator / Article Production Orchestrator 负责项目控制、状态、决策门、调度、综合和 repair-request；韩愈、张辽、认知显影、巨人认知根据职责区分连续会话和 report-only。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Context Architect / Context Compiler"
|
||||
- "主会话 orchestration 与子会话材料处理边界"
|
||||
- "Agent Dispatch Pack 与角色裁剪上下文"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Outline Context Architect 升为总项目经理；源文明确说它只接管上下文工程层。"
|
||||
- "不要把所有角色都默认长期连续；源文区分韩愈、张辽和 report-only 角色。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U03
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U03
|
||||
source_lines: 1058-1080
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户复盘 `2026-06-04-Sanguo-temp-slug` 测试：项目从已有提纲评审转为从观点素材开始，并暴露概念标星需要服务附录脚手架。真正失败点发生在追问张辽原始提示词、发送指令和直接回复文件时：`dispatch-pack.md` 只是主会话任务说明，没有完整 canonical prompt 启动方式；张辽报告以及韩愈、Outline Context Architect、张辽、认知显影、巨人认知等产物实际由主会话读取约束后模拟生成，不是独立 agent 执行。由此补出 Agent Invocation Packet / prompt-to-send / invocation record / simulation-only / excluded-from-synthesis / formal_output:false 等 no-simulation 规则，并确认真实调用可来自独立 Codex Thread、外部平台或通用 sub-agent 工具。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity / no-simulation"
|
||||
- "Agent Invocation Packet"
|
||||
- "prompt-to-send 与真实 returned output"
|
||||
- "主会话只 orchestration，不冒充 canonical agent"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把这次失败归因为目录或文件太多；源文强调关键执行边界是假的。"
|
||||
- "不要把主会话角色扮演产物纳入正式 synthesis。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U04
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U04
|
||||
source_lines: 1082-1095
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户从第一次改造中提炼初步原则：过度工程表面症状不一定是目录、Agent 或协议太多；有时相反，是文件结构完整但关键执行边界是假的。Anti-Overengineering Gate 应问该阶段是否需要独立角色判断、角色输出是否必须有真实 invocation record、上下文工程是否发生在正确时机、dispatch pack 是索引还是可投递启动包、不能真实调用时系统是否会停止、当前复杂度是否服务于可追溯、可复盘、可裁决而不是制造流程幻觉。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Anti-Overengineering Gate -> Complexity Placement Gate"
|
||||
- "流程幻觉"
|
||||
- "真实性复杂度"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 gate 简化为少用 Agent；源文强调是否需要真实独立判断和真实调用记录。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U05
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U05
|
||||
source_lines: 1099-1145
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户描述第二次素材提炼阶段的尝试，即 `knowledge-vault` 中 `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` 改造。针对 `2026-06-05-失望性情感隔离` 的三次蒸馏形成从旧方法缺陷、升级机制重跑到完成态链条的轨迹。第一次 chunk-first 先按 R01-R07 分块提取主题，容易让局部真实冒充整体结构；第二次引入 Step 0 whole-source gestalt，先判断 coherent / mixed / fragmented，再决定结构优先或分块；第三次形成包含 broad-fidelity workers、synthesis-prep、topic map、material routing、topic-doc workers、coverage audit 等完整链条。用户总结其实质是把长讨论摘要升级为可追溯观点材料生产，同时明确 `knowledge-vault` 与 `writing-workbench` 边界，不自动创建写作项目、文章提纲或 model-mining。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "whole-source gestalt"
|
||||
- "chunk-first distortion"
|
||||
- "source-map / topic-map / material-routing-log / topic docs / coverage audit"
|
||||
- "Knowledge Vault 与 Writing Workbench 分工"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把第一次旧流程产物当作 routing authority。"
|
||||
- "不要把第三次完成态链条自动视为所有单源材料的默认档位。"
|
||||
- "不要让素材提炼自动越界创建 writing-workbench 项目或 model assets。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U06
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U06
|
||||
source_lines: 1148-1188
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户反思自己成熟写作流程已人工跑过 200 多篇，只是在一两个环节做自动化，且自认擅长抽象、建模和软件开发；但实际流程改造比预期复杂。用户感到 Codex / copilot / Agentic 协作与 Web 单智能体有本质区别，并用《人月神话》类比：调流程是本质复杂，写代码是偶然复杂。用户引入 QPI 理论：Q 是信息缺失、P 是路径受阻、I 是系统纠缠；原先认为开发系统是 P 域，个人流程改造也应是 P 域，只是工具不熟，因此请求 GPT 点评补充。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "QPI 问题颗粒度光谱"
|
||||
- "P 域入口滑入 I 域治理"
|
||||
- "Agentic 协作与 Web 单智能体差异"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 QPI 抽成模型资产；本轮只能保留为讨论材料。"
|
||||
- "不要忽略用户自我误判：受众只有自己并不必然意味着纯 P 域。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U07
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U07
|
||||
source_lines: 1194-1237
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 将两次尝试重新命名：第一次不是写作评审流程改造失败，而是多 Agent 真实性边界实验失败；第二次不是素材提炼流程成功但 ROI 差，而是知识加工 Runtime 全规格验证成功但误用于一次普通蒸馏任务。GPT 指出用户以为只是把成熟写作流程的一两个环节搬进 Codex，实际是在把长期由本人承担的隐性判断密集的人肉 Runtime，翻译成机器可执行、可追溯、可中断、可复盘、可证明没有伪执行的协议系统。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "人肉 Runtime -> 机器可执行协议系统"
|
||||
- "隐性专家判断外显化"
|
||||
- "真实性边界实验 / Full Runtime 误用"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 GPT 的重新命名当成用户最终命名；它是后续综合可检查的材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U08
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U08
|
||||
source_lines: 1241-1281
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 进一步解释第一次尝试的真正失败：系统产出了看起来像多 Agent 评审的文件，但没有发生多 Agent 调用。旧流程中评审员价值来自独立视角，主会话模拟多个角色只是角色扮演。漂亮产物可能包含 dispatch pack、report、目录、输出文件和流程痕迹，但缺失谁被真实调用、canonical prompt、输入上下文、原始结果、主会话是否越权代写等执行事实。因此第一次是“假工程化”反例，Agent Invocation Packet、prompt-to-send、invocation record、simulation-only 标记不是多余复杂度，而是在修复真实性边界。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "假工程化"
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity"
|
||||
- "复杂度放在真实性边界上"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把真实性协议视为流程装饰；GPT 明确说这部分复杂度值得保留。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U09
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U09
|
||||
source_lines: 1285-1335
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 判断第二次素材提炼在方法论上成功，修正了 chunk-first 让局部真实冒充整体结构的问题；对 coherent 5 万字讨论稿，先做 whole-source gestalt，再进入 topic map 和材料组织是高级原则。但问题在于为单篇材料启用了接近治理级 Runtime 的规格，包括 source-map、topic-map、material-routing-log、topic docs、worker outputs、human gates、coverage audit、distortion-risk-log、handoff packets 和 no-simulation invocation discipline。这套东西适合多材料、多轮研究、高价值知识资产、多人协作、未来复用、可追责复盘场景；若只是整理单篇讨论稿为写作和模型优化素材，则过重。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Full Runtime vs Lite / Standard"
|
||||
- "治理级 Runtime"
|
||||
- "局部真实冒充整体结构"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Full Runtime 的成功误读为所有材料都应该 Full 处理。"
|
||||
- "不要否定 whole-source gestalt；GPT 区分了方法有效与档位过重。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U10
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U10
|
||||
source_lines: 1339-1410
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 修正用户对 QPI 的判断：这两次调流程表层是 P，底层是 I。P/I 区别不只在是否多人博弈，而在是否存在唯一成功标准、是否一次求解闭环、是否能快速测试验收、是否存在多个合理但冲突目标、是否需要持续治理。主会话何时代劳或停止、report-like output 与真实 agent output 边界、独立视角成本、source fidelity、whole-source gestalt、topic docs 细度、audit 级别、ROI、Runtime 沉淀与一次性工作记录，都属于治理题。GPT 建议 QPI 增补：Issue 不一定来自多人组织，只要存在多个有效目标之间的持续权衡，就是 I。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "QPI drift / P 任务滑入 I 治理"
|
||||
- "多主体、多状态、多目标系统治理"
|
||||
- "持续权衡作为 Issue 判据"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 I 域只理解为多人组织；源文强调单人流程也可能因多目标权衡成为 I。"
|
||||
- "不要把工具不熟当作全部原因；GPT 区分偶然复杂和本质复杂。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U11
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U11
|
||||
source_lines: 1413-1548
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 对比 Vibe Coding 与流程改造：代码有编译器、测试、运行结果等硬反馈，流程没有编译器；流程正确性包括角色是否独立、上下文是否合适、抽取是否保真、层级是否符合思想结构、产物是否对未来写作有用、成本是否值得、机制是否复用、是否制造流程幻觉。Web 单智能体环境是人类主导的软 Runtime，角色、上下文、调用边界可由用户凭感觉调度；Codex / Agentic 环境将工作落到文件、路径、技能、调用、线程、子任务、状态、diff、artifacts、runbook、execution record，并逼问是否真实执行。流程改造还会揭露真正依赖的是用户判断，而不是步骤本身。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "流程没有编译器"
|
||||
- "Web 单智能体软 Runtime"
|
||||
- "文件化、协议化、可追溯的认知生产系统"
|
||||
- "人的判断被流程改造暴露出来"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Agentic 环境差异缩减为上下文窗口更小；源文强调执行事实和 trace 物理化。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U12
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U12
|
||||
source_lines: 1552-1592
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 将 Anti-Overengineering Gate 升级为 Complexity Placement Gate / 复杂度放置门：不要只问流程是否太复杂，而要问当前复杂度买到了什么。复杂度只有在买到真实性、独立性、保真性、结构性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性、下游依赖时才值得。Agent Invocation Packet 买到真实性，whole-source gestalt 买到结构性；每个单源材料都做 full coverage audit、每个 topic 都生成厚 topic docs、每次蒸馏都生成 handoff packets、所有 worker 都真实调用，则未必值得。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Complexity Placement Gate"
|
||||
- "真实性 / 独立性 / 保真性 / 结构性 / 可追溯性 / 可复盘性 / 可复用性 / 下游依赖"
|
||||
- "真实性复杂度 vs 流程装饰复杂度"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把复杂度放置门缩减为反复杂或降本；源文强调复杂度必须购买具体价值。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U13
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U13
|
||||
source_lines: 1595-1700
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议两个流程都改成三档制。写作评审流程：Lite 为人工主导评审辅助，可用单模型模拟但不声明真实多 Agent；Standard 为真实评审小闭环，适合重要文章和复杂立意，包含真实韩愈、真实张辽、可选认知显影/巨人认知、invocation record、用户 synthesis decision 和韩愈修复；Full 为文章生产 Runtime，包含 premise-context-pack、outline-aligned context、多评审员真实调用、多轮修复、附录脚手架、正文 drafting、审稿、归档、downstream model extraction。素材提炼流程：Lite 为单源讨论稿蒸馏，保留 whole-source gestalt、topic map、reusable material units、source index、downstream suggestions、抽样 coverage check；Standard 为可复用材料包，含 source-map、confirmed topic-map、material-routing-log、若干 topic docs、human confirmation、targeted coverage audit；Full 为治理级知识加工 Runtime，含 workers、invocation records、coverage audit、distortion-risk-log、downstream handoff packets、repair pass、archival protocol。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Mode Selector / Lite-Standard-Full"
|
||||
- "写作评审流程三档"
|
||||
- "素材提炼流程三档"
|
||||
- "Standard 最小真实闭环"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Lite 的模拟视为正式多 Agent 输出；源文明确要求不声明为真实多 Agent。"
|
||||
- "不要把 Full 默认化；源文建议第一次失败后先做 Standard 最小真实闭环。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U14
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U14
|
||||
source_lines: 1702-1756
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议把 QPI 前置嵌入 Runtime 入口。Q 型任务是问答、查询、局部判断，处理方式是搜索、检索、局部阅读、直接回答，不建 Runtime。P 型任务是明确转换或明确产物，使用 Skill / Template / 单 Agent 或少量真实调用，重点完成产物，不默认治理化。I 型任务是流程治理、标准生成、长期系统，使用 Runtime / Human gate / 多轮讨论 / 审计，重点是治理权衡，不假装一次解决。两次尝试失控，是因为从 P 型入口进入却不断冒出 I 型问题：自动化提纲评审是 P，真实多 Agent 评审定义是 I；蒸馏讨论稿是 P，可追溯知识加工生产线是 I。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Project Intake"
|
||||
- "QPI 分类前置"
|
||||
- "任务账本：做任务还是造系统"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 P 入口和 I 子问题混为同一成本账本。"
|
||||
- "不要把 QPI 前置直接升级为模型资产；本轮仅作为候选概念材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U15
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U15
|
||||
source_lines: 1759-1854
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 修正用户的人月神话类比：写代码并不总是偶然复杂，只是近期小系统的复杂度被框架、硬反馈、现成库和 Agent 实现能力吸收；这次调流程的复杂度集中在成功标准不稳定、流程目标变化、产物质量依赖用户判断、工具能力边界不清、agent 是否真的执行需定义、上下文裁剪改变结果、过度自动化伤害认知质量、不自动化又难复用等方面。GPT 判断用户当前已有三项资产：no-simulation 硬底线、whole-source gestalt 前置、human gate 是深度工作一部分；同时缺 Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Kill Criteria。Cost Ledger 要区分 token 花在内容产出还是系统研发；Kill Criteria 要规定已有 gestalt、confirmed topic map、可用 material units、足够下游写作、无重大遗漏、不打算立即 model-mining 时就停止。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Mode Selector"
|
||||
- "Cost Ledger"
|
||||
- "Kill Criteria / Stop Rule"
|
||||
- "Human gate"
|
||||
- "no-simulation 与 whole-source gestalt"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 human gate 当作自动化失败；源文强调它是深度工作的一部分。"
|
||||
- "不要把 3000 万 tokens 全记入单次内容任务；Cost Ledger 需要拆分内容产出与系统研发。"
|
||||
- "不要因为流程还能生成中间物就继续跑。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### R02-U16
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R02-U16
|
||||
source_lines: 1857-1909
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 判断这两份材料适合形成文章命题：Agentic 时代的过度工程，不是用了太多 Agent，而是没有区分产出内容和建造生产内容的机器；好流程不是轻流程，而是每个重环节都有真实执行边界；从 Prompt 到 Runtime 的迁移，是把人的隐性判断外显为机器可执行协议。两次尝试一正一反：第一次系统像真的但不是真的；第二次系统真的但太贵。真正问题不是要不要工程化，而是什么时候、在哪里、为了什么工程化。最后短定性是：第一次像炮但炮弹没出膛；第二次真炮打中蚊子；实际需要的可能是电蚊拍，外加造炮图纸单独归档。后续要拆分内容任务和系统建设任务、真实性复杂度和流程装饰复杂度，并把 Q/P/I 分类前置到每次 Runtime 启动之前。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "第 8 篇文章候选主线"
|
||||
- "内容任务 vs 系统建设任务"
|
||||
- "真实性复杂度 vs 流程装饰复杂度"
|
||||
- "人的隐性判断外显为机器可执行协议"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把文章命题提前变成正式文章提纲；它只是 R02 中的 GPT 建议材料。"
|
||||
- "不要把“电蚊拍 / 造炮图纸”比喻简化成否定 CCPE；源文明确说不要否定 CCPE，也不要全怪 Codex 或 SuperPowers。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 用户输入层提供了两类一手实践材料：写作评审流程改造失败样例，以及素材提炼流程从 chunk-first 到 whole-source gestalt / completed chain 的改造样例。
|
||||
- 用户输入层还提供了自我判断：成熟写作流程、本以为只是局部自动化、QPI 中倾向将个人流程改造归入 P 域、对 Codex / Agentic 与 Web 单智能体差异的体感。
|
||||
- GPT 响应层主要是解释、重命名和结构化补充：把第一次定义为真实性边界实验失败，把第二次定义为 Full Runtime 误用于普通蒸馏任务，并提出 Complexity Placement Gate、Lite/Standard/Full、QPI 前置、Cost Ledger、Kill Criteria 等候选概念。
|
||||
- 后续 synthesis 不应把 GPT 建议直接当作用户确认的最终体系；但这些建议确实是 R02 源材料内的高价值候选概念。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
deep_creation_workflow:
|
||||
covered_units:
|
||||
- R02-U01
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
note: "写作评审流程、韩愈/张辽/认知显影/巨人认知、多轮提纲评审和上下文工程，是本轮最重要的实践案例之一。"
|
||||
material_extraction:
|
||||
covered_units:
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
note: "素材提炼流程提供 chunk-first 误判、whole-source gestalt 修复、Full Runtime 过载和停止规则材料。"
|
||||
dimensional_reduction_output:
|
||||
covered_units: []
|
||||
note: "R02 尚未展开降维输出流程，后续应主要从 R03/R04 检查。"
|
||||
hifi_agent_studio:
|
||||
covered_units:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
note: "R02 为 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁提供真实性边界、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Stop Rule、QPI drift 等候选材料。"
|
||||
agentic_handbook:
|
||||
covered_units:
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
note: "大量操作性规则更适合后续进入 Agentic Handbook 守则材料，而不是全部塞入 HiFi 纲领。"
|
||||
complexity_placement_gate:
|
||||
covered_units:
|
||||
- R02-U01
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
note: "R02 是复杂度放置门的核心证据轮之一：真实性复杂度值得保留，流程装饰复杂度和 Full Runtime 默认化需要被 gate。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
primary_units:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
likely_use: "支撑第 8 篇文章的叙事主线：我以为在自动化写作流程，结果发现自己在设计认知劳动的操作系统；第一次像真的但不是真的，第二次是真的但太贵。"
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
primary_units:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
likely_use: "支撑 HiFi Agent Studio 运行治理补丁：复杂度放置门、执行真实性、QPI drift、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Stop Rule。"
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
primary_units:
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
likely_use: "支撑 Agentic Handbook 的操作守则：invocation packet 字段、prompt-to-send、simulation labeling、worker 何时需要真实调用、Lite/Standard/Full 档位、Kill Criteria。"
|
||||
archival_context:
|
||||
primary_units:
|
||||
- R02-U01
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
likely_use: "保留流程演化背景，防止后续只看到抽象原则而丢失实践样本。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
以下概念在 R02 中可标为 `candidate_concept`，但本 run 禁止创建 model card、model index entry 或其他模型资产：
|
||||
|
||||
- `Complexity Placement Gate / 复杂度放置门`
|
||||
- `Execution Authenticity / no-simulation`
|
||||
- `Agent Invocation Packet`
|
||||
- `prompt-to-send`
|
||||
- `invocation record`
|
||||
- `simulation-only / excluded-from-synthesis`
|
||||
- `whole-source gestalt`
|
||||
- `chunk-first distortion`
|
||||
- `Mode Selector / Lite-Standard-Full`
|
||||
- `Cost Ledger`
|
||||
- `Kill Criteria / Stop Rule`
|
||||
- `QPI drift / P 任务滑入 I 域治理`
|
||||
- `内容任务 vs 系统建设任务`
|
||||
- `真实性复杂度 vs 流程装饰复杂度`
|
||||
- `Web 单智能体软 Runtime`
|
||||
- `文件化、协议化、可追溯的认知生产系统`
|
||||
|
||||
这些概念应在后续 synthesis 中按用户确认的三个任务方向路由：第 8 篇文章、HiFi Agent Studio 补丁、Agentic Handbook 守则。不得在本 worker 阶段将其整理为正式模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- R02 的写作评审流程材料与 R01 的 ROI / 大炮打蚊子直觉应交叉检查：R02 给出“不是少文件，而是真实性边界”的反例。
|
||||
- R02 的素材提炼流程材料与后续 R03 的降维输出流程应交叉检查：R02 主要说明 Full Runtime 何时过重，R03 可能提供更适合先 Agentic 化的生产线对照。
|
||||
- `Agent Invocation Packet`、`prompt-to-send`、`returned-output`、`invocation record` 应作为真实性机制处理，不应被升为父主题。
|
||||
- `whole-source gestalt` 与 `chunk-first distortion` 是保真和结构性机制，应连接到 Complexity Placement Gate，而不是作为独立宏主题。
|
||||
- `Mode Selector`、`Cost Ledger`、`Kill Criteria` 三者构成运行治理补丁候选组，可同时支撑 HiFi Agent Studio 和 Agentic Handbook。
|
||||
- QPI 在 R02 中的关键不是重复 Q/P/I 定义，而是补上 P 入口滑入 I 治理的漂移判断。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
1. 不要把 R02 的写作评审流程和素材提炼流程拆成两个与“复杂度放置门”平级的父主题；它们是实践案例层和证据层。
|
||||
2. 不要把第一次测试失败写成“多 Agent 太复杂所以失败”；源文强调失败在于没有真实多 Agent 调用。
|
||||
3. 不要把第二次素材提炼写成“流程错了”；源文/GPT 的判断是方法有效，但 Full Runtime 档位可能过重。
|
||||
4. 不要把 Complexity Placement Gate 缩减成 Anti-Overengineering；它更关心复杂度购买了什么价值，以及复杂度放置在哪一层。
|
||||
5. 不要把 QPI 变成孤立理论介绍；R02 的新材料在于 P/I 混合、P 任务滑入 I 治理、Runtime 入口前置分类。
|
||||
6. 不要把 GPT 提出的文章命题直接变成正式文章提纲或 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
7. 不要创建或暗示已创建模型资产；R02 中所有概念均停留在 discussion_material 或 candidate_concept。
|
||||
8. 不要核验或提升外部链接；R02 范围内未出现需要核验的外链。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
|
||||
1. 第 8 篇文章是否以“我以为在自动化写作流程，结果发现自己在设计认知劳动的操作系统”为主叙事，还是以“Agentic 时代的过度工程不是用了太多 Agent”为主叙事？
|
||||
2. HiFi Agent Studio 补丁中，哪些内容应进入纲领层：复杂度放置门、执行真实性、QPI drift、停止权，还是只保留少数原则？
|
||||
3. Agentic Handbook 是否应单独承接 Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Kill Criteria、Invocation Packet 字段、Simulation Labeling、Authority Matrix 等操作守则？
|
||||
4. 素材提炼流程的默认档位应是 Lite 还是 Standard？哪些条件才触发 Full？
|
||||
5. 写作评审流程下一次验证是否应采用 Standard 最小真实闭环：真实韩愈 + 真实张辽 + 一个修复回合 + 用户决策记录？
|
||||
6. Cost Ledger 在后续 runbook 中如何拆分内容产出成本与系统研发成本，避免把 Runtime 原型成本误记为单次材料处理成本？
|
||||
7. 对 `human gate` 的定位应如何表述，才能避免被误解为自动化失败，同时保留其作为深度判断的一部分？
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: broad-fidelity-R03
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R03
|
||||
round_id: R03
|
||||
source_line_range: 1910-2638
|
||||
user_slice: 1910-1961
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1962-2638
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb8b1-5ba1-71e2-9bb9-4377e2c239bd
|
||||
execution_status: sent_in_progress
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Prompt:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R03\prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Output only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R03\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Forbidden: no source edits, no out-of-range source reading, no topic map, no routing log, no topic docs, no model assets, no external-link verification.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: broad-fidelity-R03
|
||||
|
||||
You are `broad-fidelity-R03`, a formal worker participant in the Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run `2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
|
||||
Read shared context:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Read only this source range:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
round_id: R03
|
||||
source_line_range: 1910-2638
|
||||
user_slice: 1910-1961
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1962-2638
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Extract source-faithful material units from R03 only. Preserve user/GPT distinction. Use the output structure and material unit schema from `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
Write only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R03\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, model assets, audits, or writing-workbench handoff. Do not verify external links.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,693 @@
|
|||
```yaml
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R03
|
||||
round_id: R03
|
||||
source_line_range: 1910-2638
|
||||
user_slice: 1910-1961
|
||||
gpt_slice: 1962-2638
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
# 1. Round Scope
|
||||
|
||||
R03 处理第三轮数字 H1 范围 `1910-2638`。本轮用户先给出“降维输出流程”的完整阶段描述，并说明它与深度创作流程配套但不是同一流程；随后把自己的写作 / 降维实践外推到真实生产环境中的专家型 Agentic 系统，提出两个问题：方向对不对，方式对不对。
|
||||
|
||||
GPT 回应认可“相通”，但限定其相通点不是“文章生产”，而是“专家生产系统”：专家如何把隐性判断、材料处理、角色协作、产物转换和人工裁决交给 AI 系统部分接管。R03 的核心材料价值在于把“降维输出流程”定位为更适合先 Agentic 化的生产线，并把深度创作流程定位为高不确定性的专家诊断室 / 实验室，由此导出专家赋能型 Agentic 系统的运行原则、MVP 顺序和 QPI 重新定性。
|
||||
|
||||
本输出只抽取 R03 内材料单元，不创建 topic-map、routing-log、topic docs、model assets、audits 或 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
|
||||
# 2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U01
|
||||
source_lines: 1912-1938
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户描述一套与深度创作流程配套但独立的降维输出流程：从深度文章模型中抽取一两个点，面向大众话题制作不超过 10 分钟的视频；流程包含剧集统筹、破题提案、视频总纲、分镜骨架、音画深潜、素材生成、剪辑和发布。用户明确此前已有单智能体“强哥的徒弟”，且 Codex 下很多手工环节可被取代。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "降维输出流程作为生产线 / Agentic MVP"
|
||||
- "低判断高摩擦环节自动化"
|
||||
- "human gate 在剧集拆分、切入角度、总纲、分镜确认中的位置"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把降维输出流程并列提升为根主题；它是复杂度放置门下的实践案例层和先行 MVP 场景。"
|
||||
- "不要把视频工作流扩展为 video-workbench topic；本轮只保留其作为降维输出案例。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U02
|
||||
source_lines: 1940-1953
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户在两次测试之后反思：已有 Web 单智能体深度创作流程包含 40+ Agent、上百次运行、200 多篇文章和 100 万字产出；这些流程看似写作类、单用户，但与人类组织协作、客户方案、报价、分析报告等商业场景相通。用户认为迁移到 Agentic 下的成功或摩擦，能暴露未来专家 / 用户使用 AI 系统时会遇到的问题，尤其是真实生产环境中大量专家隐性经验无法一蹴而就。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "深度创作流程作为专家型组织协作缩影"
|
||||
- "专家隐性经验显性化"
|
||||
- "预测偏差作为复杂度放置门的触发点"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把用户经验缩窄为个人写作流程；用户明确将其类比到企业专家协作和商业交付。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U03
|
||||
source_lines: 1955-1961
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户提出本轮指令：询问 GPT 是否认可这些流程与 Agentic 系统相通，并要求补充专家辅助 / 赋能角度下的 Agentic 系统设计要点。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "专家赋能型 Agentic 系统"
|
||||
- "从个人流程复盘转向系统设计原则"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 GPT 的后续原则视为无源泛化；它们是对用户显式提问的回应。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U04
|
||||
source_lines: 1962-1976
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 明确认可用户判断，并加强表述：写作 / 降维输出流程是专家型 Agentic 系统的高密度缩影；它代表的不是文章生产，而是专家把隐性判断、材料处理、角色协作、产物转换和人工裁决交给 AI 系统部分接管。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "专家型 Agentic 系统"
|
||||
- "专家生产系统"
|
||||
- "隐性判断 / 材料处理 / 角色协作 / 产物转换 / 人工裁决"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把相通点写成“写作流程普遍化”；GPT 限定为专家生产系统普遍化。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U05
|
||||
source_lines: 1978-2016
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 解释用户流程的普遍性：深度创作流程像压缩在一个人身上的小型专家组织，包含主笔、红队、结构检查、模型检查、素材提炼、上下文架构、提纲修复、降维输出、分镜、视觉提示词、配音和发布等角色；企业中对应项目负责人、行业专家、分析师、方案经理、售前、交付、品牌、法务、财务和客户成功。摩擦不是创作者特殊痛苦，而是专家型组织把隐性协作搬进 Agentic 系统时的必然摩擦。GPT 还引用外部资料讨论 agentic 应用、workflow / agent 区分、简单方案优先与复杂度成本。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "专家组织压缩到个人流程"
|
||||
- "workflow vs agent"
|
||||
- "复杂度必须换来足够价值"
|
||||
- "3000 万 tokens 的成本怪味"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "外部链接未核验，只能保留为讨论材料。"
|
||||
- "不要把企业类比提升为已验证行业事实；它是 GPT 在本轮内给出的结构类比。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U06
|
||||
source_lines: 2018-2053
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议先不要把最深的创作流程作为 Agentic 改造主战场，而应优先改造降维输出流程。理由是其阶段边界更清楚、产物更容易验收，并天然适合 Hybrid Runtime：核心判断由用户保留，周边重活自动化，高随机性部分保留人工。GPT 将其总结为专家赋能型 Agentic 系统的健康形态：不是替专家做最终判断，而是吃掉专家判断前后的机械、格式、素材和试错成本。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Hybrid Runtime"
|
||||
- "低判断高摩擦自动化"
|
||||
- "专家判断保留，人机分工"
|
||||
- "降维输出作为先行战场"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要理解为降维输出没有判断；GPT 只说它比深度创作更容易验收、更适合先自动化。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U07
|
||||
source_lines: 2055-2099
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 区分深度创作流程和降维输出流程：深度创作像专家诊断室，负责从复杂材料中形成判断、模型、立意和结构，问题颗粒度常从 P 滑向 I；降维输出像生产线，负责把已形成深度模型转译成大众可消费的媒介产品，更多属于 P 域 / Workflow 域。建议深度创作先做协议化、轻量化和真实性边界，降维输出先做自动化、工具链和批量生产。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "专家诊断室 vs 生产线"
|
||||
- "P 滑向 I"
|
||||
- "保真地想清楚 / 高效地讲出去"
|
||||
- "深度创作 Lite/Standard/Full 分档"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把两个流程混成一个 runbook；GPT 明确要求分开设计。"
|
||||
- "不要把深度创作流程自动化优先级排在降维输出之前。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U08
|
||||
source_lines: 2101-2134
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 认可用户关于真实生产环境中专家隐性经验无法一蹴而就的判断。真实企业专家型 Agentic 系统不会主要卡在 API 调用，而会卡在专家判断标准、AI 可接管边界、何时停下来问人、报告权威来源、草稿与正式交付区分、agent 意见冲突裁决、真实执行证明、成本 / 时延 / 质量控制、成功经验沉淀为 skill 等问题。GPT 将前两次测试对应为流程幻觉和治理过载。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "流程幻觉"
|
||||
- "治理过载"
|
||||
- "skill 复用"
|
||||
- "真实执行证明"
|
||||
- "agent 冲突裁决"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把“流程幻觉”和“治理过载”抽成模型资产；本轮只能标为候选概念或文章 / 手册素材。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U09
|
||||
source_lines: 2136-2168
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 提出专家赋能型 Agentic 系统的重点不是更多 Agent，而是专家判断位置被正确建模：角色为什么存在、消费什么上下文、输出什么判断、是否有裁决权、是否需要连续会话、能否被 Skill 替代、输出是否必须真实 invocation、如何复核、失败时如何停。GPT 建议不要急着把每个旧 Agent 升级成 Agent Spec，很多旧 Agent 应拆成轻角色、模型卡和 Skill；未来强度来自 Role / Model / Skill / Runtime 分层准确。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Role / Model / Skill / Runtime 分层"
|
||||
- "Agent Spec 升级边界"
|
||||
- "真实 invocation"
|
||||
- "专家判断位置建模"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "外部 Skills 文档引用只作为讨论材料，不作为本次正式知识资产依据。"
|
||||
- "不要把所有旧 Agent 直接映射为 Codex Agent；GPT 明确主张分层拆解。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U10
|
||||
source_lines: 2170-2208
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出专家赋能型 Agentic 系统原则 1-2：先影子运行，不要先自动化；把专家的“不做什么”写出来。影子运行要求系统先旁观专家如何工作，记录输入、判断、修改、拒绝、返工和例外，再逐渐形成流程。negative rule 包括素材提炼不自动创建 writing project、蒸馏不自动 model-mining、主会话不冒充真实 agent、不能真实调用时停止、某些概念不升层、剪辑不自动化等。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "影子运行"
|
||||
- "negative rule / 不做什么"
|
||||
- "no-simulation"
|
||||
- "停止边界"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把影子运行误写成自动化前的可选小步骤；GPT 将其放在真实专家系统入口处。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U11
|
||||
source_lines: 2209-2278
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出原则 3-5：人类决策门要产品化；给每个 Agent 一个权力边界；追踪不是工程洁癖，而是防止流程幻觉。human gate 应像 API 一样记录 decision_id、owner、输入、选项、采纳 / 拒绝、理由、下游影响和回滚条件；降维输出中的人工门包括是否拆系列、选破题角度、确认总纲和隐喻、确认分镜骨架、抽查配音稿、是否生成素材、是否发布。Agent 需要明确结构提出 / 挑战 / 修改、工具调用、正式产物生成、synthesis 进入和人工确认权限。trace 至少要记录谁被调用、何时、用哪个 canonical prompt、读了哪些输入、输出了什么、主会话如何整合、哪些进入正式 synthesis、哪些是 simulation-only。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "human gate API"
|
||||
- "Authority Matrix"
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity / trace"
|
||||
- "simulation-only 标记"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 human-in-the-loop 写成系统能力不足的补丁；GPT 将其视为专家系统核心接口。"
|
||||
- "外部 handoff / tracing 链接未核验，只保留为讨论材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U12
|
||||
source_lines: 2279-2323
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出原则 6-7：先设计 Mode Selector，再设计 Runtime；专家流程要有停止规则。入口判断应包含 Lite / Standard / Full、Q / P / I、一次性产物 / 可复用流程 / 治理级系统、内容生产成本 / 系统建设成本。没有入口门，系统会天然往复杂处滑。Stop Rule 用于防止系统持续生产 audit、handoff、topic doc、review、prompt、protocol 等中间产物。降维输出的停止条件可包括时长明确、破题角度已选、总纲确认、分镜数量和预算确认、每个分镜已有配音稿 / 视觉提示词 / 画面规划、素材路径生成，然后文本侧停止。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Mode Selector"
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full"
|
||||
- "QPI drift"
|
||||
- "Stop Rule"
|
||||
- "成本分账"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Stop Rule 限定为降维输出；本轮将其作为专家流程和 Agentic 系统的普遍治理机制。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U13
|
||||
source_lines: 2324-2374
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出原则 8-9：把上下文工程当成独立产品能力；不要把专家判断全部变成 prompt。Context Compiler 应把原始材料转成 source digest、task-specific context pack、role-specific dispatch pack、output-specific constraints 和 traceable source references。深度创作需要 premise-context-pack、outline-aligned context、reviewer-specific context；降维输出需要 article model digest、public-topic framing pack、episode context pack、visual style pack、platform-specific output pack。专家经验至少可分为 Prompt、Model、Skill、Runtime、Rubric，不能全塞进超级 prompt；关键是不要每次把所有层都启用。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Context Compiler"
|
||||
- "premise-context-pack"
|
||||
- "role-specific dispatch pack"
|
||||
- "Prompt / Model / Skill / Runtime / Rubric"
|
||||
- "超级 prompt 反模式"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Context Compiler 直接升为模型资产；本次只能保留候选概念和素材。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U14
|
||||
source_lines: 2375-2405
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出原则 10：专家系统 MVP 应该选择低判断、高摩擦环节。适合先自动化的是人烦、AI 做得还可以、错了容易改、验收标准明确、提升产能明显、不会伤害核心思想质量的环节。在用户系统中包括视频字数预算、剧集拆分初稿、三个破题角度、分镜骨架、配音稿初稿、生图提示词、多平台标题 / 简介 / 标签、口播节奏优化、素材文件命名归档、TTS 批处理、图片批量生成。GPT 明确说这比先改造最深判断流程更靠谱。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "低判断高摩擦 MVP"
|
||||
- "视频生产自动化清单"
|
||||
- "自动化优先级"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 MVP 选择原则写成泛泛效率建议；它直接服务复杂度放置门和模式选择。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U15
|
||||
source_lines: 2407-2495
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 解释用户预测偏差：用户原以为成熟流程、建模能力和软件开发能力足以让 Codex 迁移变成工程落地；实际是成熟流程里的大量隐性判断被 Codex 逼成显性协议，并暴露状态、边界、调用、上下文、权限、成本和验收问题。方向是对的，因为用户从真实运行 200 多篇文章的流程出发，且已撞到专家型 Agentic 系统的关键问题；方式需要收敛：保留 no-simulation、分层、source fidelity、human gate、whole-source gestalt、项目边界、流程分开等正确部分，收掉默认 Full Runtime、混账、多 Agent、coverage audit、topic docs、旧 Agent 全升级、先自动化最深判断等倾向。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "预测偏差"
|
||||
- "工具使用者到系统设计者"
|
||||
- "方向继续，方式收敛"
|
||||
- "默认 Full Runtime 的风险"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把预测偏差解释为方向错误；GPT 明确判断方向对、方式要调。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U16
|
||||
source_lines: 2497-2566
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出下一步落地：深度创作流程先降复杂度，建立一个主笔 + 红队 + 用户裁决 + 一次修复的真实调用最小闭环，暂不上认知显影、巨人认知、完整正文、附录、topic docs、coverage audit。降维输出流程作为 Agentic MVP，可输入深度文章、关联 model card / rules、目标平台、目标时长，输出剧集拆分建议、三个破题提案、用户选择记录、视频总纲、分镜骨架、分镜深潜产出、配音稿、生图提示词、TTS 文本和素材清单；图片、配音、文件夹、剪辑清单、标题简介标签可进一步自动生成，但剪辑、发布和图生视频先不自动化。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "深度创作最小真实调用闭环"
|
||||
- "降维输出 Standard Runtime"
|
||||
- "素材生成清单"
|
||||
- "剪辑 / 发布暂不自动化"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 model card / rules 的输入要求理解为允许本 run 创建 model assets；此处只是降维输出 MVP 的输入设想。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U17
|
||||
source_lines: 2568-2606
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 用 QPI 重新定性三类流程：深度创作起点是 P，核心常进入 I，适合 Interactive / Hybrid Runtime；素材提炼 Lite 是 P、Full 是 I，3000 万 tokens 是 P 任务滑入 I 系统建设；降维输出大部分是 P，边缘带一点 I，比如系列定位、受众、平台策略、长期内容资产，因此最适合先自动化。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "QPI 重新定性"
|
||||
- "P 任务滑入 I 系统建设"
|
||||
- "Interactive / Hybrid Runtime"
|
||||
- "降维输出先自动化"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 QPI 独立抽成模型资产；本次只记录其在流程定性中的用法。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R03-U18
|
||||
source_lines: 2608-2638
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 最后判断：用户流程与专家型 Agentic 系统相通，其价值不只是内容产出，而是沉淀一条经验：专家型 Agentic 系统不是让 AI 直接替专家干活，而是先显性化专家工作的材料、判断、角色、上下文、裁决和产物链条，再把低判断高摩擦部分自动化，把高判断高风险部分协议化，把关键输出可追踪化。用户暂停不是方向错，而是从工具使用者切到系统设计者。总结为方向继续、方式收敛、先用降维输出流程做 Agentic MVP、深度创作流程先保守协议化。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "实验室 vs 生产线"
|
||||
- "高判断高风险协议化"
|
||||
- "关键输出可追踪化"
|
||||
- "方向继续，方式收敛"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "末尾外链列表只作为 GPT 讨论材料，不核验、不提升。"
|
||||
- "不要把“生产线”理解为本次要创建 video-workbench；它是降维输出流程的比喻和案例。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
# 3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 用户输入集中在两部分：一是降维输出流程的真实工作流描述，二是把个人写作 / 降维输出流程迁移到 Agentic 系统后产生预测偏差，并询问其与专家赋能型 Agentic 系统是否相通。
|
||||
- 用户明确说降维输出与深度创作“没有直接关联，是不同的流程”，但它们配套服务于从深度文章到大众视频的转换。
|
||||
- GPT 的贡献是结构化外推：将用户流程解释为“专家生产系统”缩影，并提出生产线 / 实验室分工、专家判断位置建模、human gate、trace、Mode Selector、Stop Rule、Context Compiler 和 MVP 选择原则。
|
||||
- GPT 引用外部资料和链接的部分只应作为本轮 GPT 论证材料保留，不在本次 worker 输出中核验或提升为正式知识资产。
|
||||
- 用户原文是第一手案例材料；GPT 原文是结构诊断与建议材料。后续 synthesis 不应把 GPT 的建议伪装成用户已经确认的运行规程。
|
||||
|
||||
# 4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
deep_creation_workflow:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U09
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
role_in_round: "深度创作被定位为高不确定性的专家诊断室 / 实验室，适合先做协议化、轻量化、真实性边界和最小真实调用闭环。"
|
||||
|
||||
material_extraction:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U08
|
||||
- R03-U10
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
role_in_round: "素材提炼作为前两次测试之一，被用于说明流程幻觉、治理过载、P 任务滑入 I 系统建设、Stop Rule 和不要自动 model-mining。"
|
||||
|
||||
dimensional_reduction_output:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U04
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
- R03-U14
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
role_in_round: "降维输出是本轮最重要的实践案例，被建议作为先行 Agentic MVP / 生产线，因为边界清楚、验收明确、低判断高摩擦环节多。"
|
||||
|
||||
hifi_agent_studio:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U05
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U09
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
role_in_round: "本轮为 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁提供运行治理素材：Mode Selector、Role/Model/Skill/Runtime 分层、Execution Authenticity、Context Compiler、Stop Rule 和复杂度放置。"
|
||||
|
||||
agentic_handbook:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U03
|
||||
- R03-U04
|
||||
- R03-U08
|
||||
- R03-U10
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R03-U14
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
role_in_round: "本轮包含大量可进入 Agentic Handbook 的守则素材，尤其是人类决策门、权力边界、trace、Mode Selector、Stop Rule、上下文工程和 MVP 选择。"
|
||||
|
||||
complexity_placement_gate:
|
||||
source_units:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U05
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U08
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
role_in_round: "本轮直接支撑复杂度放置门：不是反复杂度，而是判断哪些流程该自动化、哪些该协议化、哪些该保留人工裁决，以及何时 Lite/Standard/Full。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
# 5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
high_value_units:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U04
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
usable_angles:
|
||||
- "从预测偏差讲起：成熟专家流程迁移到 Agentic 后，隐性判断被迫显性化。"
|
||||
- "深度创作是实验室，降维输出是生产线；先跑生产线，再改造实验室。"
|
||||
- "专家型 Agentic 系统不是替专家干活，而是显性化、自动化、协议化和追踪化。"
|
||||
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
high_value_units:
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U09
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
usable_angles:
|
||||
- "HiFi Agent Studio 需要补运行治理入口：Mode Selector、Lite/Standard/Full、QPI drift、成本分账。"
|
||||
- "Role / Model / Skill / Runtime 分层要替代旧 Agent 全部升级的冲动。"
|
||||
- "复杂度必须购买真实性、可追踪性、保真性或复用性，否则应收敛。"
|
||||
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
high_value_units:
|
||||
- R03-U08
|
||||
- R03-U10
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R03-U14
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
usable_angles:
|
||||
- "专家系统开工前先影子运行，记录专家判断、拒绝、返工和例外。"
|
||||
- "human gate、Authority Matrix、trace、Stop Rule 应成为项目守则。"
|
||||
- "MVP 应选低判断、高摩擦、验收明确、错了容易改的环节。"
|
||||
|
||||
archival_context:
|
||||
high_value_units:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U05
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
usable_angles:
|
||||
- "保留用户原始降维输出流程阶段清单。"
|
||||
- "保留用户关于 40+ Agent、200 多篇文章、100 万字经验的背景判断。"
|
||||
- "保留 GPT 对旧 Agent 拆分、降维输出 MVP 和深度创作最小闭环的建议。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
# 6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
以下均为 R03 内可供后续 synthesis 使用的候选概念或材料标签，不是模型资产，不得在本 run 中创建 model card、model index entry 或 model-mining 输出。
|
||||
|
||||
- **专家生产系统**：相通点不是写作，而是专家如何把隐性判断、材料处理、角色协作、产物转换和人工裁决交给 AI 系统部分接管。
|
||||
- **专家诊断室 / 实验室 vs 生产线**：深度创作负责高不确定性的判断、模型、立意和结构；降维输出负责把已成型深度模型高效转译为大众媒介产品。
|
||||
- **低判断高摩擦 MVP**：优先自动化人烦、AI 可做、错了易改、验收明确、提升产能明显、不会伤害核心思想质量的环节。
|
||||
- **流程幻觉**：产物看似完整，但真实 invocation、trace 或独立执行未发生。
|
||||
- **治理过载**：流程真实执行但成本和复杂度超出任务价值，典型表现是 P 任务滑入 I 系统建设。
|
||||
- **专家判断位置建模**：Agent 数量不是重点，重点是角色存在理由、上下文消费、判断输出、裁决权、复核和失败停止。
|
||||
- **human gate API**：把人工确认门产品化为有 owner、输入、选项、采纳 / 拒绝、理由、下游影响和回滚条件的决策记录。
|
||||
- **Authority Matrix**：明确谁能提出、挑战、修改结构，谁能调用工具、生成正式产物、进入 synthesis、需要人工确认。
|
||||
- **Mode Selector**：每次启动流程前判断 Lite / Standard / Full、Q / P / I、一次性产物 / 可复用流程 / 治理级系统、内容成本 / 系统建设成本。
|
||||
- **Stop Rule**：为专家流程设置明确停止条件，防止 audit、handoff、topic doc、review、prompt、protocol 等中间产物无限增殖。
|
||||
- **Context Compiler**：将原始材料转成 source digest、task-specific context pack、role-specific dispatch pack、output-specific constraints 和 traceable source references。
|
||||
- **Role / Model / Skill / Runtime / Rubric 分层**：不要把专家经验全部塞进 prompt，也不要每次启用所有层。
|
||||
|
||||
# 7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- `R03-U01` 与 `R03-U06` / `R03-U14` / `R03-U16`：用户给出的降维输出阶段清单，是 GPT 后续“先用降维输出做 Agentic MVP”的直接源材料。
|
||||
- `R03-U02` 与 `R03-U04` / `R03-U05`：用户自述深度创作流程和商业场景相通，GPT 将其抽象为“专家生产系统”。
|
||||
- `R03-U07` 与 `R03-U17`：深度创作 / 降维输出的诊断室与生产线区分，对应 QPI 中 I/P 分布差异。
|
||||
- `R03-U08` 与前两轮材料：流程幻觉对应第一次测试的假执行，治理过载对应第二次测试的重流程成本。
|
||||
- `R03-U09` 与 HiFi / CCPE 分层：旧 Agent 不应全部升 Agent Spec，应拆为 Role / Model / Skill / Runtime / Rubric。
|
||||
- `R03-U11` 与 no-simulation：trace、invocation record、simulation-only 标记是防止假流程进入 synthesis 的机制。
|
||||
- `R03-U12` 与复杂度放置门：Mode Selector 和 Stop Rule 是控制复杂度滑坡的入口与出口。
|
||||
- `R03-U13` 与深度创作 / 降维输出两个实践：Context Compiler 在深度创作中表现为 premise-context-pack / reviewer context，在降维输出中表现为 article digest / public-topic framing / visual style pack。
|
||||
- `R03-U18` 与第 8 篇文章：可作为文章收束句材料，即“方向继续，方式收敛；先生产线，后实验室”。
|
||||
|
||||
# 8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
- 不要把 R03 误读为“用户要做 video-workbench”。用户描述的是降维输出流程；本 run 确认不为 video-workbench 单独保留 topic。
|
||||
- 不要把降维输出流程升为与复杂度放置门平级的父主题。它是实践案例层、先行 MVP 场景和复杂度放置门的证据。
|
||||
- 不要把深度创作流程与降维输出流程合并成同一 runbook。R03 明确要求两者分开设计：深度创作先协议化，降维输出先自动化。
|
||||
- 不要把 GPT 的原则清单直接当作用户已确认的正式方法论。它们是 R03 的 GPT 结构诊断，需要后续 synthesis 和人工确认。
|
||||
- 不要基于 R03 创建任何模型资产。即使出现 Context Compiler、Mode Selector、Stop Rule、Execution Authenticity、QPI 重新定性等候选概念，本 run 仍禁止 model-mining。
|
||||
- 不要核验或提升 GPT 引用的外部链接。外部链接只作为讨论材料保留。
|
||||
- 不要把“专家系统 MVP 选低判断高摩擦环节”写成纯效率原则；它服务的是复杂度放置、风险控制、验收清晰和 human gate。
|
||||
- 不要把“方向对”理解为“方式也完全对”。GPT 明确说方向继续、方式收敛。
|
||||
|
||||
# 9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
|
||||
1. 第 8 篇文章是否应以 R03 的“预测偏差 -> 专家生产系统 -> 实验室 / 生产线 -> 复杂度放置门”作为核心叙事线，还是只把 R03 作为其中一个案例段落？
|
||||
2. 后续 topic graph 中，“低判断高摩擦 MVP”应作为 `复杂度放置门` 的子原则，还是作为 `Agentic Handbook` 的项目分诊守则？
|
||||
3. `Context Compiler` 在本 run 中应只作为候选概念保留，还是在 handbook material routing 中拆成深度创作版和降维输出版两个操作条目？
|
||||
4. `Role / Model / Skill / Runtime / Rubric` 分层是否应进入 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁的纲领层，还是主要放入 Agentic Handbook 的执行守则层？
|
||||
5. R03 提出的降维输出 MVP 是否需要在后续 material routing 中细分为文本侧、素材生成侧、剪辑 / 发布保留人工三组材料？
|
||||
6. “流程幻觉”和“治理过载”是否应作为第 8 篇文章的两类核心反例，还是作为 Handbook 中的两个风险标签？
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: broad-fidelity-R04
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R04
|
||||
round_id: R04
|
||||
source_line_range: 2639-4013
|
||||
user_slice: 2639-2903
|
||||
gpt_slice: 2904-4013
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb8bc-8d94-7382-ad6c-8ee5c586b36a
|
||||
supersedes_thread_id: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
execution_status: retry1_sent_in_progress
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Prompt:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R04\prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Output only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R04\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Forbidden: no source edits, no out-of-range source reading, no topic map, no routing log, no topic docs, no model assets, no external-link verification.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: broad-fidelity-R04
|
||||
|
||||
You are `broad-fidelity-R04`, a formal worker participant in the Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run `2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
|
||||
Read shared context:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Read only this source range:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
round_id: R04
|
||||
source_line_range: 2639-4013
|
||||
user_slice: 2639-2903
|
||||
gpt_slice: 2904-4013
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Extract source-faithful material units from R04 only. Preserve user/GPT distinction. Use the output structure and material unit schema from `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
Write only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R04\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, model assets, audits, or writing-workbench handoff. Do not verify external links.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,480 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R04-retry1
|
||||
supersedes_thread_id: 019eb8b1-9923-75c3-a500-0fe33db6bfd9
|
||||
round_id: R04
|
||||
source_line_range: 2639-4013
|
||||
user_slice: 2639-2903
|
||||
gpt_slice: 2904-4013
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# broad-fidelity-R04 Returned Output
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Round Scope
|
||||
|
||||
R04 只覆盖源文档第 4 轮：用户先说明深度创作与视频 / PPT 输出在其工作规划中原本属于 `writing-workbench` 与 `video-workbench` 两套不同流程，并解释自己作为软件公司企业主更负责前瞻、规划、预演和思想深度，而工程化输出已有一定自动化基础。随后用户给出《价值方舟建造蓝图》七篇文章和由此抽取出的 **HiFi Agent Studio V2.0** 原文，要求 GPT 不先考虑第 8 篇文章立意，而是判断 HiFi Agent Studio 应从哪些方面补充、已有文本有什么建议。
|
||||
|
||||
GPT 的回应把 R04 推入本轮 run 的核心后段：HiFi Agent Studio 不缺世界观、方法论和航行纪律，而是缺“运行治理层”。GPT 将前几轮 Codex / CCPE / knowledge-vault 的踩坑经验转译成一组候选补丁：Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Scope Drift Detector、Stop Rule、Fidelity Ladder、Complexity Placement、Runtime Maturity Model、Evaluation Stack、Context Compiler、Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Simulation Labeling、Expert Attention Budget、Production Boundary，以及对既有 CoT、QPI、生产工坊、双离合榨取、认知参谋部的修改建议。
|
||||
|
||||
本输出只抽取 R04 内材料单元，不创建 topic-map、routing-log、topic docs、model assets、audits 或 writing-workbench handoff。所有候选概念仅作为讨论材料或候选概念保留。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U01
|
||||
source_lines: 2641-2652
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户说明深度创作与视频/PPT输出在过去和规划中原本是不相干的两套流程，分别对应 writing-workbench 和 video-workbench。用户之所以先处理深度创作，是因为输出流程已通过 OpenClaw、Claude Code 和 Skill 做过拆文档、提炼模型、拆分镜、语音生成、图片生成等自动化，对用户而言主要是工程化工作；而用户作为软件公司企业主，更多负责前瞻、规划、预演和思想深度，承担踩坑职责，工程团队跟进。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- deep_creation_workflow
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "企业主前瞻踩坑与工程团队跟进的职责分层"
|
||||
- "writing-workbench / video-workbench 作为不同项目流程"
|
||||
- "深度创作流程作为方法论压力测试"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 video-workbench 提升为本次 topic；human confirmation 已要求不考虑 video-workbench，只保留为上下文和类比。"
|
||||
- "不要把用户角色误读为单纯内容创作者；用户明确定位为企业主和方法论前瞻者。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U02
|
||||
source_lines: 2654-2688
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户介绍《价值方舟建造蓝图》七篇 AI 开发系列文章，说明这些文章来自 AI 开发实战一线问题的总结归纳，类似前面两次流程调试。七篇文章依次覆盖认知挑战和价值锚点、AI 原生组织五体系统、专家直觉显性建模、信息化到智能化的认知跃迁、场景封装与密封舱、钢尺与皮尺的校准、复杂性守恒与人类责任。用户由这些文章抽取出 HiFi Agent Studio 方法论集合。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: discussion_material_only
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "价值方舟建造蓝图作为 HiFi Agent Studio 的前史"
|
||||
- "复杂性守恒与控制棒"
|
||||
- "认知建模 / 组织重塑 / 产品交付 / 持续演进闭环"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "外部文章链接只作为讨论材料保留，不在本次 worker 中核验或提升为正式知识资产依据。"
|
||||
- "不要把七篇文章逐篇拆成独立父主题；此处主要是 HiFi Agent Studio 的来源说明。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U03
|
||||
source_lines: 2688-2721
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户贴出 HiFi Agent Studio V2.0 的身份、使命与产品定义：HiFi Agent 的系统架构师与模具师，为复杂商业深水区构建专家视角的智能业务助理；核心能力是认知建模，建设路径是单点突破到供需连。产品定义强调园丁思维、物理反应堆与控制棒的拓扑解耦、对外专家级数字员工、对内密封舱，目标是在技术速朽和通用模型幻觉中封装可穿越周期的高保真专家能力。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Digital Workforce / 专家级数字员工"
|
||||
- "密封舱 / 物理反应堆 / 控制棒"
|
||||
- "认知建模作为核心能力"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要将这些既有方法论资产视为本轮新生成模型资产；它们是用户输入中的现有 HiFi Studio 文本。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U04
|
||||
source_lines: 2724-2824
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户贴出 HiFi Agent Studio 的架构战略与核心方法论：密封舱按熵值和秩序分为逻辑轮机与战略透镜；高风险单向门决策强制采用预设委员会拓扑，禁止无约束动态智能体路由；所有密封舱预留校准接口、自我辩护和结构化反馈槽。核心方法论包括 QPI 三元定性、思想考古、CCPE、CCPE System、相互校准协议，以及 Beta 状态的双离合榨取与摩擦蒸馏。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "QPI 三元定性"
|
||||
- "逻辑轮机 / 战略透镜"
|
||||
- "CCPE System 的 Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 分类"
|
||||
- "钢尺与皮尺 / Mutual Calibration"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要在本次 worker 中抽取 QPI、MFK、密封舱等 model card；本 run 明确禁止模型资产抽取。"
|
||||
- "不要把 Beta 理论沙盘写成已验证生产机制。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U05
|
||||
source_lines: 2827-2900
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户贴出 HiFi Agent Studio 的五体系统与航行纪律：船长、海图绘制者、航行官、轮机长分别对应价值裁判、建模者、业务/AI 翻译和工程实现，并移除认知参谋部的默认 AI 职责；航行纪律包括绿野仙踪协议、混合工程、过程即数据、实测去魅、深度优先、降噪定力、Design for Calibration、复杂性守恒防线、Minimum Fidelity Kernel。用户说明其中已有先做尝试等原则，并要求 GPT 不先考虑第 8 篇文章立意，而是为 HiFi Agent Studio 提出补充和建议。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "五体系统与企业职责分层"
|
||||
- "Wizard of Oz Protocol"
|
||||
- "Design for Calibration"
|
||||
- "Complexity Conservation Guardrail"
|
||||
- "Minimum Fidelity Kernel"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 R04 误转为第 8 篇文章立意任务；用户明确暂不考虑新文章切入。"
|
||||
- "不要忽略用户已指出部分 GPT 先前建议在 HiFi Studio 中已有。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U06
|
||||
source_lines: 2904-2948
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出总判断：HiFi Agent Studio 大方向很强，不缺原则，而是缺更硬的运行治理层。现有文本是心智模型、架构哲学和航行纪律，覆盖 AI 开发、专家系统、认知建模、组织转型、密封舱、控制棒、QPI、绿野仙踪、MFK；但最近 Codex / CCPE / knowledge-vault 的踩坑暴露了项目启动后如何选模式、限流、证明真执行、停止、分账、从实验进入产品、避免系统建设成本误记为单次任务成本等操作层问题。GPT 将缺口比喻为仪表盘、限流阀、熔断器、试车台、燃料账本和出厂分级标准。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "运行治理层"
|
||||
- "从方法论纲领到项目治理协议"
|
||||
- "系统建设成本与单次任务成本分离"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 GPT 的评价写成推翻 HiFi Agent Studio；GPT 明确说世界观是对的，需要补操作层阀门系统。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U07
|
||||
source_lines: 2951-3020
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 提出最大缺口是 Agentic Project Intake / 项目入口分诊台。QPI 只判断问题颗粒度，还需要同时判断任务是内容产出还是系统建设、一次性任务还是可复用能力建设、Lite/Standard/Full Runtime 哪个执行档位。GPT 用 3000 万 tokens 的怪味解释入口偏差：表面是 P 域蒸馏 5 万字讨论稿，实际中途滑成 I 域的可追踪、可复用、可审计知识加工 Runtime 建设，但成本却记在单次蒸馏任务账上。建议新增四重定性和硬规则：内容任务若开始设计 Agent、Skill、Runtime、Protocol、Evaluation、Invocation 标准，必须拆账，标记已经滑入系统建设任务。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Agentic Project Intake"
|
||||
- "QPI + 任务性质 + 复用级别 + 执行模式"
|
||||
- "内容任务滑入系统建设任务"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Project Intake 当成单纯表单；它承担复杂度放置门的入口分诊功能。"
|
||||
- "不要将 3000 万 tokens 只解释为浪费；GPT 的关键是成本账本归类错误。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U08
|
||||
source_lines: 3022-3108
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议补 Mode Selector：Lite / Standard / Full。Lite 用于一次性、低风险、单个高上下文模型可处理、不需多 Agent 独立判断、不需审计追踪、下游不依赖中间过程的任务；默认产物是目标输出、简短输入记录、人工确认和可选抽样检查，禁止默认完整 Runtime、多 Agent、coverage audit、厚重 handoff。Standard 用于未来复用、有明确下游消费、需要稳定上下文包/模型卡/Skill/轻量 Runtime、少量 human gate 和局部审计的任务。Full 用于多角色、多来源、高风险、可追责、长周期、生产环境、外部客户交付或后续自动化强依赖过程真实性的任务。关键规则是默认从 Lite 开始，只有证据推动才升级，不得因系统能力存在而自动启用高档位。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full Mode Selector"
|
||||
- "默认轻量，证据驱动升级"
|
||||
- "Full Runtime 的触发条件"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把三档模式直接变成本次 run 的模式判定；R04 只是保留候选补丁材料。"
|
||||
- "不要把 Standard 中提到的模型卡理解为本 run 允许创建 model card。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U09
|
||||
source_lines: 3112-3154
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议补 Cost Ledger / 成本账本协议。HiFi Agent Studio 已有 ROI 意识，但缺明确成本核算协议。GPT 将成本分为 Content Cost、System-Building Cost、Calibration Cost、Exploration Cost，并提出硬规则：禁止将系统建设成本伪装为单次内容任务成本。3000 万 tokens 如果记成 5 万字蒸馏成本就是灾难；如果记成知识加工 Runtime 原型研发、Agentic 协作边界测试和 no-simulation protocol 验证成本，就有解释空间。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Cost Ledger Protocol"
|
||||
- "内容成本 / 系统建设成本 / 校准成本 / 探索成本"
|
||||
- "ROI 怪味的账本重分配"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把成本账本写成省钱主义；GPT 明确说成本不是变低，而是账要算对。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U10
|
||||
source_lines: 3157-3214
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议补 Execution Authenticity / 执行真实性协议。绿野仙踪协议解决价值未验证前不投入开发资源，但不能证明某个 Agent 是否真的执行。第一次三国测试中文件看似完整，但主会话模拟了张辽、韩愈、认知显影、巨人认知输出；viewpoint-discussion-distillation 后来补上正式 Agent 输出必须有真实 invocation record、packet-only 或 prompt-only 不算执行、主会话不能冒充 primary source analysis/routing/topic-doc drafting/material extraction、carrier 不可用时要 blocked 的纪律。GPT 建议将其上升为通用原则：正式 Agent Output、Worker Output、Committee Review、Audit Result 必须有可追溯执行证据；主会话可 orchestration/routing/synthesis/bounded verification，但不得冒充独立 Agent/Worker/Auditor；真实调用不可用时停在 prompt-to-send/blocked，不得补写模拟报告。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity Protocol"
|
||||
- "no-simulation / blocked_waiting_for_participant_output"
|
||||
- "formal participant output 与主会话 synthesis 的边界"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把绿野仙踪与正式 Agentic 执行混同；GPT 明确要求两者分开。"
|
||||
- "不要在后续 synthesis 中把缺少真实 invocation record 的材料当正式输出。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U11
|
||||
source_lines: 3218-3385
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 连续提出 Scope Drift Detector、Stop Rule、Fidelity Ladder 和 Complexity Placement Principle。Scope Drift Detector 用于识别任务执行滑成流程建设、P 滑入 I、内容处理变成系统治理，触发信号包括创建 Agent/Skill/Runtime/Protocol、讨论 invocation/handoff/authority/state/audit、设计复用目录、为一次性任务写通用规则、派发多个 worker/committee、推迟原始产物、成本超过原任务规模 30 倍等，触发后询问是否还在做原任务、是否正式切换系统建设、是否拆分账本和产物目标。Stop Rule 要在 Runtime 启动前定义最小可用产物、optional 产物、升级后才生成的产物、sufficient 条件、人类决策等待点和禁止自动扩展条件。Fidelity Ladder 将保真拆为文字、结构、模型、风格、决策五层，并按任务设目标。Complexity Placement Principle 把复杂度从反复杂升级为放置判断：复杂环节只有在购买真实性、独立性、保真性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性、风险控制时才允许存在，否则删除、降级或延后。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Scope Drift Detector"
|
||||
- "Stop Rule / Stop Criteria Template"
|
||||
- "Fidelity Ladder"
|
||||
- "Complexity Placement Principle"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Complexity Placement 缩减成反过度工程；GPT 明确指出有些复杂度是必要的，如真实 invocation record。"
|
||||
- "不要把 Stop Rule 变成继续生成更多审计和中间物的理由；它的用途是定义停止。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U12
|
||||
source_lines: 3388-3535
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议补 Runtime Maturity Model、Evaluation Stack 和 Context Compiler。Runtime Maturity Model 区分 M0 Concept、M1 Manual、M2 Assisted、M3 Protocolized、M4 Semi-Agentic、M5 Production、M6 Governed，并禁止跳级声明成熟，M2 不能伪装 M5，M3 不能伪装 M6，模拟产物不能进入正式生产链。Evaluation Stack 从 E0 冒烟、E1 格式、E2 事实、E3 推理、E4 专家相似度、E5 决策效用、E6 可校准性、E7 治理测试分层，按场景选择评测深度。Context Compiler 来自写作流程改造和素材提炼流程中的 whole-source gestalt 经验：连贯长讨论不能一上来 chunk-first，要先判断 coherent/mixed/fragmented，再决定结构优先还是平铺发现；上下文编译器将 raw sources、expert notes、historical cases、model cards、business constraints、user intent、downstream target 转译为 source digest、task-specific context pack、role-specific dispatch pack、decision-context pack、evaluation context 和 source index；I 域或高价值 P 域任务禁止把原始材料一股脑塞给所有 Agent，但若单个高上下文模型可完整处理，应优先 whole-source gestalt + lightweight source digest，不得默认拆 worker。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- material_extraction
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Runtime Maturity Model"
|
||||
- "Evaluation Stack"
|
||||
- "Context Compiler"
|
||||
- "whole-source gestalt 与 chunk-first 风险"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Context Compiler 误解为默认重型 worker 拆分；GPT 同时要求高上下文可处理时优先轻量 digest。"
|
||||
- "不要在本轮把 Runtime Maturity Model 或 Evaluation Stack 创建为正式模型资产。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U13
|
||||
source_lines: 3539-3731
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议补 Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Simulation Labeling、Expert Attention Budget 和 Production Boundary。Authority Matrix 为 Agent/Skill/Runtime node 声明 A0 Observe、A1 Suggest、A2 Draft、A3 Modify、A4 Decide、A5 Execute、A6 Block 权限等级，用于回答谁能建议、修改、否决、执行工具、进入正式产物、只能 report-only。Artifact Contract 要求正式产物声明 artifact_type、status、authority、source_of_truth、downstream_use、invalidation_condition、cost_class，避免文件很多但不知道哪个是真的。Simulation Labeling 要求由主会话模拟、人类代填、不完整 Agent 执行、缺失 canonical prompt 的临时输出显式标记 simulation_only、formal_output、excluded_from_synthesis、reason、allowed_use。Expert Attention Budget 将真正稀缺资源定义为专家注意力，计算人工裁决节点数量、上下文长度、题型、AI 归因候选、反馈能否影响后续批处理、是否存在重复/虚假/低价值审查，并禁止把 AI 自动化节省的工作转化为专家端更重的审计疲劳。Production Boundary 用于判断内部方法进入客户交付前是否具备清楚场景、成功指标、失败代价、责任边界、校准入口、交付形态和运营成本。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Authority Matrix"
|
||||
- "Artifact Contract"
|
||||
- "Simulation Labeling"
|
||||
- "Expert Attention Budget"
|
||||
- "Production Boundary"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把权限矩阵只写成职责说明；GPT 强调的是能否建议、修改、裁决、执行、阻断的硬边界。"
|
||||
- "不要把专家注意力预算简化为 token 成本；GPT 明确说真正稀缺的是专家判断。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U14
|
||||
source_lines: 3735-3871
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 对现有 HiFi Agent Studio 提出具体修改建议：将“自我辩护必须包含 CoT 摘要”改成输出可验证的理由摘要 / decision rationale，而非完整 CoT，包含事实依据、规则或模型、不确定性、反例边界和人工确认问题；为 QPI 增加 Drift 概念，记录 Q->P、P->I 的任务漂移并重新选择 Lite/Standard/Full、拆分任务与账本；在逻辑轮机和战略透镜之间加入 Production Workshop / 生产工坊，用于 video-workbench、文档拆分、配音、图片生成、PPT 等 P 为主、少量 I 的内容/素材生产链；双离合榨取保持 Beta，但加伦理和疲劳护栏，包括高价值高风险、专家同意、退出机制、时间受限、只用于校准、记录疲劳抵触；五体系统中可恢复轻量认知参谋部作为非默认执行角色，在高风险 I 域任务中按需组建预设委员会。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- dimensional_reduction_output
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "decision rationale 取代完整 CoT"
|
||||
- "QPI Drift"
|
||||
- "Production Workshop"
|
||||
- "Dual-Clutch Extraction 疲劳护栏"
|
||||
- "Cognitive Staff 作为结构位"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Production Workshop 变成本次 video-workbench topic；本 run 已排除 video-workbench，只保留生产工坊作为分类材料。"
|
||||
- "不要要求或保存完整 CoT；GPT 建议的是可审计理由摘要。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R04-U15
|
||||
source_lines: 3875-4012
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议 HiFi Agent Studio 新增第 6 章“运行治理：从方法论到 Agentic 项目”，吸收几次 Codex 实战教训，目录包括 Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Scope Drift Detector、Stop Rule、Context Compiler、Authority Matrix、Evaluation Stack、Runtime Maturity Model。GPT 总评认为现有版本有思想密度，主要风险不是浅，而是太像宣言、运行阀门不够硬；它需要告诉团队具体项目来了第一步填什么表、什么时候开 Lite、什么时候升 Full、什么时候必须停、什么时候是假执行、什么时候老板是在踩坑而不是要求工程化量产。若只优先补五个模块，则是 Project Intake、Lite/Standard/Full Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity Protocol、Stop Rule。GPT 最后给出可直接放入 V2.1 的补丁版摘要：HiFi Agent Studio 必须是一套 Agentic 项目运行治理协议，默认最轻可用，任务滑向 Agent/Skill/Runtime/Protocol/Evaluation/Invocation 标准建设时触发 Scope Drift Review 和 Cost Ledger 拆账，正式 Agentic 输出遵守 Execution Authenticity Protocol，Runtime 启动前定义 Stop Rule，复杂度必须购买真实性、保真性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性和风险控制。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "HiFi Agent Studio V2.1 运行治理章"
|
||||
- "最值得立刻补的五个模块"
|
||||
- "方法论从方舟蓝图推进到造船厂规程"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把补丁版摘要当成已正式写入 HiFi Agent Studio；它是 R04 GPT 给出的讨论草稿。"
|
||||
- "不要把 HiFi 补丁和 Agentic Handbook 守则合并成单一输出；human confirmation 已要求作为不同任务方向处理。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 用户段主要提供既有 HiFi Agent Studio V2.0 文本、七篇文章来源、用户职责定位和提问边界：不先做第 8 篇文章立意，而是评估 HiFi Agent Studio 如何补充。
|
||||
- GPT 段主要是对既有文本的运行治理补丁建议，不是用户已确认的正式 HiFi Studio V2.1，也不是可直接提升的模型资产。
|
||||
- 用户已说明深度创作与视频/PPT输出原本属于不同项目；本 run 的 Step 0 human confirmation 又明确不考虑 `video-workbench`，所以 GPT 关于 Production Workshop 和 video-workbench 的内容只作分类材料保留。
|
||||
- GPT 多次引用前几轮 Codex / CCPE / knowledge-vault 实验作为证据来源；后续 synthesis 应保留这些作为实践案例层，而不是把案例层提升为平级父主题。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `hifi_agent_studio`: 本轮主材料是 HiFi Agent Studio V2.0 原文与 V2.1 运行治理补丁建议。
|
||||
- `agentic_handbook`: 多数补丁更像 Agentic Handbook 守则材料，包括项目入口、档位、账本、执行真实性、停止规则、权限、产物合约、评测栈。
|
||||
- `complexity_placement_gate`: 本轮最强主轴是从“不要过度工程”升级为“复杂度放置”，判断复杂度是否购买真实性、保真性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性和风险控制。
|
||||
- `deep_creation_workflow`: 作为用户踩坑和方法论压力测试背景出现，不是本轮主内容。
|
||||
- `material_extraction`: 通过 Context Compiler 和 whole-source gestalt 经验被引入，支撑上下文编译能力。
|
||||
- `dimensional_reduction_output`: 作为 video/PPT/生产工坊类比出现，但本 run 不为 video-workbench 创建 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `article_8_material`: R04 可支持第 8 篇文章中的“从踩坑到复杂度放置门”“方法论为何需要运行治理”部分，但用户明确本轮暂不做第 8 篇文章立意。
|
||||
- `hifi_patch_material`: R04 是 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁材料的核心来源，尤其是第 6 章“运行治理：从方法论到 Agentic 项目”和五个优先模块。
|
||||
- `handbook_material`: R04 大量内容更适合落入 Agentic Handbook 操作守则，包括 Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Scope Drift、Stop Rule、Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Simulation Labeling、Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- `archival_context`: 用户给出的七篇文章和 HiFi Studio V2.0 原文应作为来源背景保存，但不在本 worker 内核验链接或改写正式文档。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
以下仅为候选概念或讨论材料，不得在本 run 中创建 model card、model index entry 或正式模型资产：
|
||||
|
||||
- Agentic Project Intake / 项目入口分诊
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full Mode Selector
|
||||
- Cost Ledger Protocol / 成本账本协议
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity Protocol / 执行真实性协议
|
||||
- Scope Drift Detector / 任务漂移探测器
|
||||
- Stop Rule / 最小充分停止规则
|
||||
- Fidelity Ladder / 保真度阶梯
|
||||
- Complexity Placement Principle / 复杂度放置原则
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model / 运行时成熟度模型
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack / 分层评测栈
|
||||
- Context Compiler / 上下文编译器
|
||||
- Authority Matrix / 权力矩阵
|
||||
- Artifact Contract / 产物合约
|
||||
- Simulation Labeling / 模拟标记制度
|
||||
- Expert Attention Budget / 专家注意力预算
|
||||
- Production Boundary / 产品化边界
|
||||
- QPI Drift / 颗粒度漂移
|
||||
- Production Workshop / 生产工坊
|
||||
- Cognitive Staff / 认知参谋部作为非默认结构位
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- R01/R02/R03 的成本怪味、写作评审模拟、素材提炼 whole-source gestalt、降维输出 MVP，与 R04 的 Project Intake、Execution Authenticity、Context Compiler、Mode Selector、Stop Rule 形成直接证据链。
|
||||
- R05 的文档分层问题应与 R04 区分：R04 提出 HiFi Studio 补丁和 Handbook 守则候选项，R05 决定哪些留在纲领、哪些下放守则。
|
||||
- `CCPE System` 与 R04 的 Artifact Classification、Execution Authenticity、Simulation Labeling、Authority Matrix 有强关联，但本 worker 不创建 CCPE assets。
|
||||
- `knowledge-vault` 的 viewpoint-discussion-distillation 运行经验，是 Context Compiler、whole-source gestalt、no-simulation 和 worker invocation record 的来源案例。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
1. 不要把 R04 写成第 8 篇文章立意；用户明确要求暂不考虑新文章如何立意和切入。
|
||||
2. 不要把 GPT 的补丁清单全部塞回 HiFi Agent Studio 纲领；后续 R05 会处理纲领与 Handbook 的分层。
|
||||
3. 不要把候选概念提升为 model assets；本 run 明确禁止模型资产抽取。
|
||||
4. 不要把 video-workbench 单独建 topic；本轮只保留它作为生产工坊分类和用户既有项目规划的上下文。
|
||||
5. 不要把“复杂度放置门”缩成“反过度工程”；R04 的关键是有些复杂度必要，前提是它购买具体治理价值。
|
||||
6. 不要把主会话 orchestration 和正式 worker/agent 输出混同；R04 的 Execution Authenticity 恰好要求保持边界。
|
||||
7. 不要把 Stop Rule 当成多做审计、handoff、topic doc、model card 的许可；它的功能是定义 sufficient 和停止点。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
|
||||
- R04 中哪些项目应进入 HiFi Agent Studio 纲领层，哪些应下放到 Agentic Handbook 守则层，应与 R05 一起裁决。
|
||||
- “Complexity Placement Principle” 是否应作为根主题“复杂度放置门”的核心表述，还是作为其下的操作原则，需要 synthesis 阶段决定。
|
||||
- “Context Compiler” 在 HiFi Studio、Agentic Handbook、CCPE System、Knowledge Vault runbook 之间应如何分层承接，仍需后续 routing。
|
||||
- “Production Workshop” 虽然有用，但本 run 已排除 video-workbench；后续是否仅作为 HiFi/Handbook 分类材料保留，需要防止误升 topic。
|
||||
- R04 的五个优先补丁模块与 R05 的文档分层建议应合并成一个 HiFi V2.1 补丁包，还是拆成 HiFi patch 与 Handbook seed 两个下游材料包。
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: broad-fidelity-R05
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: broad_fidelity_round_worker
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R05
|
||||
round_id: R05
|
||||
source_line_range: 4014-5079
|
||||
user_slice: 4014-4026
|
||||
gpt_slice: 4027-5079
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb8b1-f796-7af1-a2d7-0564617dd257
|
||||
execution_status: sent_in_progress
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Prompt:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R05\prompt-to-send.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Output only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R05\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Forbidden: no source edits, no out-of-range source reading, no topic map, no routing log, no topic docs, no model assets, no external-link verification.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: broad-fidelity-R05
|
||||
|
||||
You are `broad-fidelity-R05`, a formal worker participant in the Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run `2026-06-12-复杂度放置门`.
|
||||
|
||||
Read shared context:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\human-confirmation.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Read only this source range:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
round_id: R05
|
||||
source_line_range: 4014-5079
|
||||
user_slice: 4014-4026
|
||||
gpt_slice: 4027-5079
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Extract source-faithful material units from R05 only. Preserve user/GPT distinction. Use the output structure and material unit schema from `04-segmentation-worker-design.md`.
|
||||
|
||||
Write only:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\broad-fidelity-workers\R05\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not create `01-topic-map.md`, `02-material-routing-log.md`, topic docs, model assets, audits, or writing-workbench handoff. Do not verify external links.
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,484 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
participant_id: broad-fidelity-R05
|
||||
round_id: R05
|
||||
source_line_range: 4014-5079
|
||||
user_slice: 4014-4026
|
||||
gpt_slice: 4027-5079
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_participant_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# broad-fidelity-R05 Returned Output
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Round Scope
|
||||
|
||||
R05 只覆盖源文档第 5 轮：用户询问 HiFi Agent Studio 是否应保持方法论纲领层，把 Agentic 工程细则拆成手册 / 守则；GPT 回答支持分拆，并提出四层文档体系、纲领保留内容、Agentic Handbook 下放内容，以及最应进入 HiFi Agent Studio 的五条新增原则。
|
||||
|
||||
本轮材料属于 Step 0 已确认主轴“复杂度放置门”的后段：它不再主要复盘深度创作流程，而是把前几轮的复杂度放置、执行真实性、成本分账、任务漂移、停止规则落实到文档分层与团队协作治理。
|
||||
|
||||
本输出不创建 topic-map、routing-log、topic docs、audit、model card、model index entry 或 writing-workbench handoff。所有候选概念仅作为讨论材料或候选概念保留。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source-Faithful Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U01
|
||||
source_lines: 4016-4022
|
||||
speaker_layer: user_input
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "用户提出文档分层问题：HiFi Agent Studio 作为方法论应只约定原则性和核心内容；AI 工程化尤其 Agentic 方面可另补使用手册或守则。用户要求 GPT 判断这种分拆是否合理，并区分哪些内容应进入纲领、哪些应进入 Agentic 守则。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Step 0 确认的三任务方向：第 8 篇文章 / HiFi Agent Studio 补丁 / Agentic Handbook 守则"
|
||||
- "R04 关于 HiFi Agent Studio 运行治理补丁的延续"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把用户的问题误读为只是在做文档目录管理；它是在划分方法论纲领与 Agentic 工程守则的复杂度放置边界。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U02
|
||||
source_lines: 4029-4054
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 明确支持分拆，提出四层文档体系：HiFi Agent Studio 是纲领 / 心智模型 / 方法论宪法；HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook 是 Agentic 使用手册 / 工程守则 / 开工规程；CCPE System 是 Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊；各项目 Runbook 是 writing-workbench、video-workbench、knowledge-vault 等具体项目操作规程。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "CCPE System 的 Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊定位"
|
||||
- "项目 runbook 与知识库 / 写作工作台 / 视频工作台的本地执行规程"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "本轮确认记录已排除 video-workbench 作为本次 topic 方向；这里的 video-workbench 只能保留为 GPT 举例或上下文，不应单独建 topic。"
|
||||
- "不要把四层文档体系直接提升为最终信息架构；它是 R05 内的候选分层材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U03
|
||||
source_lines: 4058-4092
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 支持分拆的理由是方法论不能被平台细节污染。HiFi Agent Studio 经历提示词工程、上下文工程到 Agent 工程，未来还可能进入 Runtime 工程、Multi-agent Governance、Agentic OS 等阶段；若每次技术范式变化都把执行规则塞进纲领，方法论会臃肿。纲领价值在稳定，守则价值在可变。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "模型演化线：Prompt 工程 -> Context 工程 -> Agent 工程"
|
||||
- "R04 的 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁与运行治理层"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把‘守则可变’理解为守则低价值；此处强调的是稳定层与可变层的不同更新节奏。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U04
|
||||
source_lines: 4096-4127
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 说明不分拆的三个后果：方法论会变成操作手册；技术变化会反复冲击纲领；团队不好执行。若把 invocation packet、prompt-to-send、thread_id、simulation-only、coverage audit、Lite/Standard/Full 等细则塞入 HiFi Agent Studio，会削弱它作为心智模型的穿透力。老板 / 建模者需要北极星文档，工程师需要开工检查表、模板、阻断条件、验收标准、目录规范。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity 细则与 no-simulation 规则"
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full mode selector"
|
||||
- "团队协作中的老板前瞻与工程交付边界"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把工程细则从体系中删除；R05 的意思是下放到 Handbook 或 CCPE System，而不是取消。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U05
|
||||
source_lines: 4130-4160
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 提出分拆后的继承关系，避免守则变成无灵魂 checklist：Agentic Handbook 服从 HiFi Agent Studio，CCPE System 实现 Agentic Handbook，Project Runbook 继承 CCPE System 和 Agentic Handbook。也可表达为 Constitution / Operating Law / Forge / Local Procedure。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "文档层级：方法论宪法、开工守则、建造工坊、本地流程规程"
|
||||
- "CCPE System 与 project runbook 的边界"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Handbook 简单降为 Studio 的唯一执行承接子层；human-confirmation 已要求把 HiFi 补丁和 Handbook 守则作为不同任务方向处理。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U06
|
||||
source_lines: 4164-4219
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 开始区分哪些内容应留在 HiFi Agent Studio 纲领：身份与使命必须保留，包括 High-Fidelity Agent、Digital Workforce、认知建模、专家视角、控制棒、抗压防护服、密封舱；QPI 三元定性也必须保留并放在更靠前位置。纲领只保留 Q/P/I 定义、禁止暴力降维、禁止认知重工业化、I 域人类责任与反馈控制、Q/P 域不能乱上委员会，具体表格和账本下放 Handbook。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "QPI 作为项目入口罗盘"
|
||||
- "I 域人类责任与反馈控制"
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full 细则下放 Handbook"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 QPI 细则全部塞进纲领；R05 区分原则句与操作表格。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U07
|
||||
source_lines: 4222-4289
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议纲领保留密封舱理论，并补充中间类型‘生产工坊’：逻辑轮机对应 Q/P、低熵、高标准化；生产工坊对应 P 为主、内容 / 素材生产链、模板 + 抽检 + 人工裁决；战略透镜对应 I、高熵、高责任。随后保留控制棒 / 反应堆拓扑解耦，以及 Separate Role from Model：Agent 是岗位 / 权限 / 交互方式，Model 是可迁移认知结构，Skill 是可执行方法模块，Runtime 是多步骤协作协议。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "逻辑轮机 / 生产工坊 / 战略透镜"
|
||||
- "控制棒与反应堆"
|
||||
- "Separate Role from Model"
|
||||
- "CCPE Artifact Classification"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "本次确认排除 video-workbench；生产工坊可作为产品形态分类材料，但不得为 video-workbench 单独开 topic。"
|
||||
- "不要把 Agent / Model / Skill / Runtime 的字段模板作为纲领内容；GPT 明确说具体模板放 CCPE System 或 Handbook。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U08
|
||||
source_lines: 4292-4416
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 继续列出纲领保留项：人类主权与责任边界、Wizard of Oz Protocol / 绿野仙踪协议、Process is Data、Design for Calibration、Complexity Conservation、MFK / 最小保真内核。原则层保留价值观和核心句，细节如下放守则：Wizard of Oz 记录与通过标准、过程数据采集、structured feedback slot、decision rationale、stop rule、cost ledger、audit fatigue guard、migration audit、A/B 等。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "人类责任不可外包"
|
||||
- "绿野仙踪：价值未经人工跑通，不投入重工程"
|
||||
- "过程即数据"
|
||||
- "不仅做对，还要好改"
|
||||
- "复杂性守恒"
|
||||
- "Minimum Fidelity Kernel"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要将 MFK、Evaluation、Cost Ledger 等作为本轮模型资产抽取；只能保留为候选概念或守则材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U09
|
||||
source_lines: 4419-4469
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议三条新增原则进入纲领：Default Light, Escalate by Evidence，即默认采用最轻结构，只有风险、复用、追踪、协作或下游依赖提供证据时才升级重 Runtime；Execution Authenticity，即正式 Agentic 产物必须来自真实执行，主会话不得冒充独立 Agent / Worker / Auditor；Cost Separation，即内容产出、系统建设、校准、探索成本必须分账。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "复杂度放置门"
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity / no-simulation"
|
||||
- "Cost Ledger"
|
||||
- "Lite / Standard / Full 升级条件"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把‘默认轻量’误读为反复杂度；它是证据驱动升级，而非禁止重 Runtime。"
|
||||
- "执行真实性的具体 invocation 字段应下放守则，不要塞入纲领。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U10
|
||||
source_lines: 4472-4719
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 系统列出应下放 Agentic Handbook 的内容：Project Intake 表、Lite / Standard / Full 详细判定表、Execution Authenticity 细则、Scope Drift Detector、Stop Rule 模板、Cost Ledger 模板、Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Evaluation Stack、Runtime Maturity Model、Context Compiler 细则和平台适配规则。这些内容重要但过于操作化，不适合进入 HiFi Agent Studio 纲领。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Project Intake"
|
||||
- "Mode Selector"
|
||||
- "Scope Drift Detector"
|
||||
- "Stop Rule"
|
||||
- "Authority Matrix"
|
||||
- "Artifact Contract"
|
||||
- "Evaluation Stack"
|
||||
- "Runtime Maturity Model"
|
||||
- "Context Compiler"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要因为列举了 Handbook 章节就创建 Handbook 正文或项目 handoff；本 worker 只抽取材料。"
|
||||
- "不要把这些候选协议当作 model assets；本 run 禁止模型资产抽取。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U11
|
||||
source_lines: 4722-4753
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 给出最终文档体系目录建议：hifi-agent-studio.md、hifi-agentic-engineering-handbook.md、project-intake、runtime-guardrails、evaluation-guide、artifact-contracts、platform-adapters、project-playbooks 等。但同时指出不必一开始做全，可以先做 HiFi Agent Studio 与 HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook 两个文档。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "文档最小起步：Studio + Handbook"
|
||||
- "project-playbooks 与具体 workbench 的关系"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "目录树是 GPT 建议，不是本轮创建指令；不得创建这些文件或平台适配文档。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U12
|
||||
source_lines: 4757-4845
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议 HiFi Agent Studio 精简为 6 大章：身份与使命、世界观、产品形态、核心方法、组织视角、航行纪律。航行纪律中只写原则，不写表格，包括绿野仙踪、默认轻量、过程即数据、实测去魅、深度优先、降噪定力、不仅做对还要好改、复杂性守恒、MFK、执行真实性、成本分账、人类责任不可外包。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "HiFi Agent Studio 纲领补丁"
|
||||
- "航行纪律"
|
||||
- "Default Light / Execution Authenticity / Cost Separation / Human Liability"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 6 大章视为最终改稿；这是 R05 的候选重组材料。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U13
|
||||
source_lines: 4848-4955
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 建议 Agentic Handbook 应是开工守则，而不是哲学文档。建议章节包括：Handbook 地位、Project Intake、QPI + Mode Selector、Artifact Classification、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Context Engineering、Human Gate Design、Authority Matrix、Evaluation Stack、Stop Rule and Scope Drift、Runtime Maturity Model、Platform Adapters。并给出优先级：用户 / 客户明确约束、HiFi Agent Studio 核心原则、Agentic Handbook、CCPE System、项目 Runbook、平台适配细则。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- archival_context
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "Handbook 服从 Studio 但不替代 Studio"
|
||||
- "CCPE 分类：Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card / Model Index / Evaluation / Tool / Workflow / Hybrid"
|
||||
- "Stop Rule and Scope Drift"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把 Handbook 写成泛泛哲学；R05 明确它是开工守则。"
|
||||
- "不要把 CCPE System 与 Handbook 合并；二者层级不同。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U14
|
||||
source_lines: 4958-5009
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 收束为最重要的五条应进入 HiFi Agent Studio 的新增原则：默认轻量、证据驱动升级；正式产物必须来自真实执行；内容成本与系统建设成本必须分账；任务漂移必须重定性；系统必须拥有停止权。其他细节进入守则。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: candidate_concept
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "复杂度放置门的五条纲领化原则"
|
||||
- "Scope Drift"
|
||||
- "Stop Rule"
|
||||
- "Cost Ledger"
|
||||
- "Execution Authenticity"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "这五条是进入纲领的候选补丁，不是已完成的 HiFi Agent Studio 正文修订。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U15
|
||||
source_lines: 5013-5039
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 将分拆与用户的企业主身份、团队协作方式连接起来：用户负责前瞻、规划、预演和思想深度，工程化主要由工程师做，因此文档体系必须区分思想沙盘、绿野仙踪验证、Agentic 运行时边界测试、方法论原则定义、工程需求提出、产品化交付。建议在 Handbook 中写明 HiFi Agent Studio 的前瞻实验不等于工程交付指令。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "老板 / 建模者与工程团队的协作边界"
|
||||
- "Runtime Maturity 标记"
|
||||
- "Project Intake / Mode Selector / Cost Ledger"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要把用户前瞻实验直接解释为工程交付命令；R05 明确这是需要 Handbook 防误读的协作风险。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
unit_id: R05-U16
|
||||
source_lines: 5043-5078
|
||||
speaker_layer: gpt_response
|
||||
fidelity_summary: "GPT 最终建议再次确认分拆：HiFi Agent Studio 是原则、世界观、核心纪律、不可变底线；HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook 负责 Agentic 项目怎么开、怎么跑、怎么停、怎么验、怎么追踪、怎么防伪执行；CCPE System 是制造 Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 的工坊；Project Runbook 是具体流程执行说明。最适合进入 Studio 的新增内容是五条原则，其他放 Handbook。"
|
||||
case_layer_tags:
|
||||
- hifi_agent_studio
|
||||
- agentic_handbook
|
||||
- complexity_placement_gate
|
||||
downstream_task_tags:
|
||||
- article_8_material
|
||||
- hifi_patch_material
|
||||
- handbook_material
|
||||
concept_status: discussion_material
|
||||
model_asset_status: prohibited_in_this_run
|
||||
external_link_status: none
|
||||
cross_link_candidates:
|
||||
- "R05 总结句：Studio 是宪法，Handbook 是施工规范与安全生产手册"
|
||||
- "四层文档体系与五条纲领原则"
|
||||
distortion_risks:
|
||||
- "不要按 GPT 比喻直接扩写成法律体系；保留其层级含义即可。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. User / GPT Distinction Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 用户输入只占 4016-4022，核心是提出分拆判断请求：HiFi Agent Studio 是否只保留原则性核心内容，Agentic 工程细则是否另写手册 / 守则。
|
||||
- GPT 响应是结构化建议，不是用户已确认的最终文档方案。它支持分拆，并详细给出分层、保留 / 下放清单、候选目录、纲领六章和 Handbook 章节。
|
||||
- 本轮中“企业主 / 老板负责前瞻、工程化由工程师做”的身份信息出自 GPT 对用户背景的归纳和承接，需在后续 synthesis 中谨慎标注为 GPT 解释层，除非其他轮次有用户原话支撑。
|
||||
- R05 的用户意图与 Gate 0 human-confirmation 一致：后续要支撑第 8 篇文章、HiFi Agent Studio 补丁、Agentic Handbook 守则三个连续任务。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Case Layer Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `hifi_agent_studio`: R05 的主材料层，围绕 Studio 保持纲领 / 宪法定位、保留原则项、避免被 Agentic 操作细节污染。
|
||||
- `agentic_handbook`: R05 的另一个主材料层，承接 Project Intake、Mode Selector、Execution Authenticity 细则、Cost Ledger、Stop Rule、Authority Matrix、Evaluation Stack 等操作守则。
|
||||
- `complexity_placement_gate`: 本轮通过“纲领 vs 守则 vs 工坊 vs runbook”的文档分层，把复杂度放置到适当层级；五条新增原则是前几轮经验的纲领化候选。
|
||||
- `deep_creation_workflow`: 本轮不是直接复盘深度创作流程，但“默认轻量”“执行真实性”“成本分账”“任务漂移”“停止权”均来自前几轮深度创作 / 素材提炼实践的教训。
|
||||
- `material_extraction`: 仅作为前文实践来源的间接背景，本轮不展开材料提炼流程本身。
|
||||
- `dimensional_reduction_output`: 仅在“生产工坊”分类与项目 runbook 举例中间接出现；本次确认已排除 video-workbench 作为单独 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Task Tags
|
||||
|
||||
- `article_8_material`: 可支撑第 8 篇文章中关于“复杂度不应消失，而应被放到正确层级”“纲领稳定、守则可变”“默认轻量、证据驱动升级”的论证。
|
||||
- `hifi_patch_material`: 可支撑 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁，尤其是五条新增原则、纲领六章重组、QPI 前置、生产工坊、执行真实性、成本分账、停止权、人类责任等。
|
||||
- `handbook_material`: 可直接支撑 Agentic Handbook 的目录和守则项，包括 Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Stop Rule、Scope Drift、Authority Matrix、Evaluation Stack、Runtime Maturity、Context Compiler。
|
||||
- `archival_context`: 四层文档体系、目录树建议、CCPE System 与 Project Runbook 边界适合保留为归档上下文，供后续 synthesis 判断粒度。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Candidate Concepts, Not Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
以下只作为候选概念或讨论材料保留，不得在本 run 中生成 model card、model index entry 或 canonical model asset：
|
||||
|
||||
- 复杂度放置门在文档体系中的表现：纲领 / 守则 / 工坊 / runbook 分层。
|
||||
- Default Light, Escalate by Evidence。
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity / 正式产物必须真实执行。
|
||||
- Cost Separation / 内容成本与系统建设成本分账。
|
||||
- Scope Drift / 任务漂移必须重定性。
|
||||
- Stop Rule / 系统必须拥有停止权。
|
||||
- Agentic Handbook 作为 Operating Law / 开工守则。
|
||||
- CCPE System 作为 Forge / 建造工坊。
|
||||
- Project Runbook 作为 Local Procedure。
|
||||
- 生产工坊作为逻辑轮机与战略透镜之间的产品形态分类。
|
||||
- Handbook 的优先级链：用户 / 客户约束、HiFi Studio 核心原则、Agentic Handbook、CCPE System、项目 Runbook、平台适配细则。
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Cross-Link Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- R05-U01 -> Gate 0 human-confirmation：三任务方向和“不做模型资产”的约束。
|
||||
- R05-U02 / U05 / U16 -> Step 0 的文档体系层：HiFi Agent Studio、Agentic Handbook、CCPE System、Project Runbook。
|
||||
- R05-U04 / U09 / U10 / U14 -> R01-R04 的执行真实性、Full Runtime 成本、scope drift 和 stop rule 实践教训。
|
||||
- R05-U06 / U07 / U08 / U12 -> HiFi Agent Studio 补丁方向：哪些原则留在纲领。
|
||||
- R05-U10 / U13 -> Agentic Handbook 守则方向：哪些操作细则下放。
|
||||
- R05-U15 -> 团队协作与工程交付边界：前瞻实验不等于工程指令。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
1. 不要把 R05 误读为“要创建一整套 hifi-agent-studio 目录”。源文只是 GPT 给出候选文档体系和最小起步建议。
|
||||
2. 不要把 `video-workbench` 从目录举例提升为本次 topic；Gate 0 已确认本次不考虑 video-workbench。
|
||||
3. 不要把五条新增原则直接当作已发布的 HiFi Agent Studio 正文；它们是本轮候选补丁材料。
|
||||
4. 不要把 Handbook 操作项抽成模型资产；本 run 明确禁止模型资产抽取。
|
||||
5. 不要把“默认轻量”简化为反工程化或反复杂度；它是证据驱动升级。
|
||||
6. 不要把 Studio 和 Handbook 合并为一个超级文档；R05 的主判断正是稳定纲领与可变守则应分层。
|
||||
7. 不要把 CCPE System 降为项目 runbook；R05 中它是 Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 的建造工坊。
|
||||
8. 不要把 GPT 对用户团队身份的归纳当成无条件事实；后续应结合其他轮次用户原话验证。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Open Questions For Synthesis
|
||||
|
||||
1. 后续 topic graph 中，“四层文档体系”应作为 `复杂度放置门` 的文档治理子节点，还是作为 `HiFi Agent Studio 补丁` 与 `Agentic Handbook 守则` 的连接节点？
|
||||
2. “生产工坊”是否进入 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁方向，还是只作为产品形态分类的候选说明材料保留？
|
||||
3. 第 8 篇文章是否需要重点使用“纲领稳定、守则可变”的组织协作论证，还是只抽取五条复杂度放置原则？
|
||||
4. Handbook 目录中哪些项属于第一版必须写，哪些仅保留为后续扩展？R05 给出的目录很全，但也提示不必一开始做全。
|
||||
5. “HiFi Agent Studio 的前瞻实验不等于工程交付指令”是否需要作为 Handbook 的显性原则，还是作为团队协作注释保留？
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,104 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: synthesis-prep-human-confirmation
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
artifact_type: human_confirmation_record
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
confirmed_artifact: invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md
|
||||
confirmation_status: confirmed_with_constraints
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: true
|
||||
may_create_material_routing_log: true
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
may_create_model_assets: false
|
||||
may_create_writing_workbench_handoff: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Synthesis-Prep Human Confirmation
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Confirmation Summary
|
||||
|
||||
用户已确认 `invocations/synthesis-prep/returned-output.md` 第 10 节提出的 topic-map promotion 问题，允许继续创建 canonical：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
01-topic-map.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本确认授权 topic-map promotion，并允许在不新增用户级结构问题的前提下继续创建 material routing。它不授权 topic docs、model-mining、writing-workbench handoff 或 downstream execution。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Confirmed Topic-Map Decisions
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.1 Root Theme
|
||||
|
||||
确认以：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
复杂度放置门
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
作为 `01-topic-map.md` 根主题。
|
||||
|
||||
同时确认将：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
专家型 Agentic 运行治理
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
放在 `复杂度放置门` 下展开，而不是作为独立平级根主题。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.2 HiFi Agent Studio Patch Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
确认 HiFi patch 最小补丁先限定为五条原则：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. 默认轻量
|
||||
2. 真实执行
|
||||
3. 成本分账
|
||||
4. 任务漂移
|
||||
5. 停止权
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
这些是 HiFi Agent Studio 纲领补丁的最小集合，不等于已完成正式正文修订。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.3 Agentic Handbook First-Pass Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
确认 Agentic Handbook 第一版素材先按六组守则组织：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Project Intake
|
||||
2. Mode Selector
|
||||
3. Cost Ledger
|
||||
4. Execution Authenticity
|
||||
5. Scope Drift
|
||||
6. Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
同时记录用户补充：这些只是撰写 Agentic Handbook 时的原始素材组织方式，不是唯一素材，也不代表 Handbook 最终只包含这六组。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.4 Candidate / Cross-Link Materials
|
||||
|
||||
确认以下内容只作为候选 / cross-link 材料保留，暂不升为核心 topic：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Context Compiler
|
||||
Production Workshop
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
其中 `Production Workshop` 不得被扩展为 `video-workbench` topic。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.5 Article 8 Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
确认第 8 篇文章材料在 topic map 中只保留素材方向，不进入正式文章提纲。
|
||||
|
||||
不得创建 writing-workbench handoff、文章 outline、正文草稿或文章项目结构。
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Permission Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
may_create_01_topic_map: true
|
||||
may_create_02_material_routing_log: true
|
||||
may_start_material_routing: true
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
may_create_model_assets: false
|
||||
may_create_writing_workbench_handoff: false
|
||||
requires_user_confirmation_before_material_routing: false
|
||||
pause_before_material_routing_only_if_new_user_level_decisions_appear: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,344 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
participant_id: synthesis-prep
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: synthesis-prep
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
formal_output: true
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
canonical_topic_map: false
|
||||
material_routing_log: false
|
||||
topic_docs: false
|
||||
model_assets: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Synthesis Prep Returned Output
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Scope And Inputs
|
||||
|
||||
本文件只做 `synthesis-prep`：把 Step 0 和五个 broad-fidelity worker 的 file-backed 输出整理成后续 topic-graph synthesis 的输入。它不是 `01-topic-map.md`，不做 material routing，不创建 topic docs，不创建 model assets，也不向 writing-workbench 交接。
|
||||
|
||||
已读取输入：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/human-confirmation.md
|
||||
04-segmentation-worker-design.md
|
||||
05-broad-fidelity-worker-status.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
执行边界：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: false
|
||||
may_create_material_routing_log: false
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
may_create_model_assets: false
|
||||
may_create_writing_workbench_handoff: false
|
||||
external_links: discussion_material_only
|
||||
video_workbench: excluded_as_topic
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Confirmed Lens To Preserve
|
||||
|
||||
后续 synthesis 必须保留已经确认的 lens：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
本源材料的主轴是“复杂度放置门”：用户通过深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出和 HiFi Agent Studio 的实践复盘，推导出专家型 Agentic 系统需要在项目入口、执行真实性、成本分账、停止规则、任务漂移和文档分层上建立运行治理。深度创作流程是该 AI 开发方法论的实践样本，不是与方法论并列的宏主题。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
并且必须保留三条连续但不同的下游任务方向：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
article_direction: 写第 8 篇文章
|
||||
hifi_patch_direction: 为 HiFi Agent Studio 打补丁
|
||||
handbook_direction: 补充 Agentic Handbook 守则内容
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Cross-Round Evidence Spine
|
||||
|
||||
### R01: ROI 异常与混账触发
|
||||
|
||||
R01 提供根问题的触发材料：5 万字讨论稿蒸馏消耗约 3000 万 tokens，用户直觉为“大炮打蚊子”。关键 synthesis 输入不是“SuperPowers 导致浪费”，而是内容产出、系统研发、校准和探索被记入同一个 ROI 账本。
|
||||
|
||||
可用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 内容任务 vs 生产内容的机器。
|
||||
- Scope / ROI Gate 与 Token Budget Guardrail。
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full 的初始档位。
|
||||
- 流程重力：系统擅长治理，但不擅长判断是否值得治理。
|
||||
|
||||
### R02: 两个流程实验暴露复杂度价值差异
|
||||
|
||||
R02 是核心证据轮。第一次写作评审流程“像真的但不是真的”，证明少文件不等于轻量，缺真实 invocation record 会制造流程幻觉。第二次素材提炼流程“真的但太贵”，证明 Full Runtime 真实有效但不应默认启用。
|
||||
|
||||
可用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity / no-simulation 是值得购买的真实性复杂度。
|
||||
- Whole-source gestalt 是值得购买的结构保真复杂度。
|
||||
- Coverage audit、厚 topic docs、完整 handoff 不一定值得每次购买。
|
||||
- P 入口会滑入 I 域治理，QPI 需要 drift 判断。
|
||||
|
||||
### R03: 专家生产系统外推与实验室 / 生产线分工
|
||||
|
||||
R03 把个人写作和降维输出实践外推为专家型 Agentic 系统。核心不是“文章生产普遍化”，而是专家如何把隐性判断、材料处理、角色协作、产物转换和人工裁决交给 AI 系统部分接管。
|
||||
|
||||
可用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 深度创作像专家诊断室 / 实验室，先协议化、轻量化和真实性边界。
|
||||
- 降维输出像生产线，更适合先 Agentic 化，但本 run 不创建 video-workbench topic。
|
||||
- 低判断高摩擦 MVP：先自动化人烦、AI 可做、验收清楚、错了易改的环节。
|
||||
- Human gate、Authority Matrix、Trace、Context Compiler、Stop Rule 是专家系统的治理接口。
|
||||
|
||||
### R04: HiFi Agent Studio 缺运行治理层
|
||||
|
||||
R04 是 HiFi patch 的主要来源。用户提供 HiFi Agent Studio V2.0，GPT 诊断不是世界观缺失，而是项目启动后如何选模式、限流、证明真执行、停止、分账、避免系统建设成本误记为单次任务成本的运行治理层不足。
|
||||
|
||||
可用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- Agentic Project Intake。
|
||||
- Mode Selector。
|
||||
- Cost Ledger。
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity。
|
||||
- Scope Drift Detector。
|
||||
- Stop Rule。
|
||||
- Fidelity Ladder、Runtime Maturity Model、Evaluation Stack、Context Compiler。
|
||||
- Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Simulation Labeling、Expert Attention Budget、Production Boundary。
|
||||
|
||||
### R05: 文档分层裁决
|
||||
|
||||
R05 把 R04 的补丁清单放入文档体系。HiFi Agent Studio 应保持纲领 / 方法论宪法，Agentic Handbook 承接开工守则和操作细则，CCPE System 是建造工坊，Project Runbook 是本地流程规程。
|
||||
|
||||
可用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- Studio 保留原则，Handbook 承接表格、模板、阻断条件和验收标准。
|
||||
- 五条最适合进入 Studio 的新增原则：默认轻量、真实执行、成本分账、任务漂移重定性、停止权。
|
||||
- Handbook 承接 Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity 细则、Scope Drift、Stop Rule、Authority Matrix、Artifact Contract、Evaluation Stack、Runtime Maturity、Context Compiler。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Candidate Graph Backbone
|
||||
|
||||
以下是后续 `01-topic-map.md` 的候选骨架输入，不是 canonical map。
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
复杂度放置门
|
||||
1. 触发问题：ROI 异常、流程重力与成本混账
|
||||
2. 实践案例层
|
||||
2.1 写作评审流程：流程幻觉与执行真实性
|
||||
2.2 素材提炼流程：whole-source gestalt 与治理过载
|
||||
2.3 降维输出流程：生产线型 MVP 与低判断高摩擦自动化
|
||||
3. 诊断模型层
|
||||
3.1 QPI drift：P 入口滑入 I 域治理
|
||||
3.2 复杂度购买价值：真实性、独立性、保真性、追溯性、复盘性、复用性、风险控制
|
||||
3.3 成本账本：内容产出、系统建设、校准、探索
|
||||
4. Agentic 专家系统运行治理层
|
||||
4.1 Project Intake / Mode Selector
|
||||
4.2 Execution Authenticity / no-simulation
|
||||
4.3 Scope Drift Detector / Stop Rule
|
||||
4.4 Human Gate / Authority Matrix / Trace
|
||||
4.5 Context Compiler / Fidelity Ladder / Evaluation Stack / Runtime Maturity
|
||||
5. 文档承接层
|
||||
5.1 HiFi Agent Studio：稳定纲领和五条原则补丁
|
||||
5.2 Agentic Handbook：开工守则和操作模板
|
||||
5.3 CCPE System：Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊
|
||||
5.4 Project Runbook：具体项目本地执行规程
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
该骨架应保持 tree-backed mixed graph：主干用树状层级保证可读性，但允许跨链接，例如 `Execution Authenticity` 同时连接写作评审、Handbook、HiFi patch；`Context Compiler` 同时连接素材提炼、深度创作和 Handbook；`Cost Ledger` 同时连接 R01 ROI 异常、R04 HiFi 补丁和 R05 文档分层。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Three Downstream Task Separation
|
||||
|
||||
### Article 8 Material
|
||||
|
||||
文章方向应优先保留叙事张力和经验线：
|
||||
|
||||
- 我以为在蒸馏材料，结果在测试一台知识加工机器。
|
||||
- 第一次“像真的但不是真的”，第二次“真的但太贵”。
|
||||
- 深度创作是实验室，降维输出是生产线。
|
||||
- Agentic 时代的过度工程不是 Agent 太多，而是没有判断复杂度放在哪里。
|
||||
- 好流程不是轻流程，而是重环节都能说清楚买到了什么。
|
||||
|
||||
文章方向不应提前生成正式文章提纲，也不应创建 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
|
||||
### HiFi Patch Material
|
||||
|
||||
HiFi Agent Studio 方向应优先保留纲领层补丁：
|
||||
|
||||
- Default Light, Escalate by Evidence。
|
||||
- Formal Agentic Output Must Be Real。
|
||||
- Separate Content Cost From System-Building Cost。
|
||||
- Reclassify Scope Drift。
|
||||
- Every Runtime Needs A Stop Rule。
|
||||
|
||||
可作为补充但需谨慎分层的概念：
|
||||
|
||||
- QPI Drift。
|
||||
- Production Workshop，作为逻辑轮机与战略透镜之间的产品形态分类；不得扩展成 video-workbench topic。
|
||||
- Separate Role from Model / Agent / Skill / Runtime。
|
||||
- Human Responsibility / Control Stick / Complexity Conservation 与既有 HiFi 资产的连接。
|
||||
|
||||
### Handbook Material
|
||||
|
||||
Agentic Handbook 方向应优先保留可执行守则：
|
||||
|
||||
- Project Intake 表。
|
||||
- QPI + Mode Selector 判定。
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full 升降级条件。
|
||||
- Cost Ledger 模板。
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity 细则。
|
||||
- Simulation Labeling。
|
||||
- Scope Drift Detector。
|
||||
- Stop Rule 模板。
|
||||
- Human Gate Design。
|
||||
- Authority Matrix。
|
||||
- Artifact Contract。
|
||||
- Context Compiler。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
- Platform Adapter 规则。
|
||||
|
||||
Handbook 应是开工守则，不是另一个哲学纲领。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Merge / Split Guidance
|
||||
|
||||
建议合并为同一主轴的材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- `Anti-Overengineering Gate`、`Minimum Sufficient Process`、`Complexity Placement Principle` 应并入 `复杂度放置门`，不要拆成多个平级父主题。
|
||||
- `Cost Ledger`、`Cost Separation`、`内容任务 vs 系统建设任务` 应合并为成本分账组。
|
||||
- `Execution Authenticity`、`no-simulation`、`Agent Invocation Packet`、`prompt-to-send`、`invocation record`、`Simulation Labeling` 应合并为真实性组；其中 packet / prompt / record 是机制，不是父主题。
|
||||
- `Mode Selector`、`Lite / Standard / Full`、`Project Intake`、`QPI drift` 应合并为入口分诊组。
|
||||
- `Stop Rule`、`Kill Criteria`、`Scope Drift Detector` 应合并为停止与漂移治理组。
|
||||
|
||||
建议保持分开的材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 第 8 篇文章、HiFi patch、Handbook 三个下游方向必须分开。
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 与 Agentic Handbook 必须分层，不要合成一个超级文档。
|
||||
- Deep creation workflow、material extraction、dimensional reduction output 是实践案例层，不是三个独立父主题。
|
||||
- CCPE System 是建造工坊，不是本次 HiFi patch 或 Handbook 的同义词。
|
||||
- Project Runbook 是具体项目规程，不应上升为方法论纲领。
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Conflicts And Overlaps To Resolve Before Topic Map
|
||||
|
||||
1. `复杂度放置门` 是根主题，还是 `专家型 Agentic 系统运行治理` 的入口原则？
|
||||
- Step 0 和 human confirmation 已允许根主题采用 `复杂度放置门`。
|
||||
- Synthesis 建议：以 `复杂度放置门` 为根主题，将专家型 Agentic 运行治理作为其展开对象。
|
||||
|
||||
2. `Production Workshop` 是否进入核心 topic？
|
||||
- R04/R05 提到它有助于 HiFi 产品形态分类。
|
||||
- Gate 0 排除 video-workbench。
|
||||
- Synthesis 建议：只作为 HiFi patch 中的分类候选，不单独开 video-workbench 或降维输出 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
3. `Context Compiler` 是 HiFi patch、Handbook 还是 CCPE 资产？
|
||||
- R03/R04 多次出现，横跨深度创作、素材提炼和专家系统。
|
||||
- 本 run 禁止 model assets。
|
||||
- Synthesis 建议：在 topic map 中作为 Handbook / runtime governance 子节点，并 cross-link 到 CCPE System，不创建模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
4. `QPI` 是否需要重写？
|
||||
- R02/R04/R05 的新增点是 drift，而不是重复 Q/P/I 定义。
|
||||
- Synthesis 建议：topic map 保留 `QPI drift`，不要抽取 QPI model card。
|
||||
|
||||
5. `Execution Authenticity` 进入 Studio 还是 Handbook？
|
||||
- R05 建议原则进入 Studio，具体 invocation 字段下放 Handbook。
|
||||
- Synthesis 建议：Studio 只保留“正式产物必须真实执行”的原则，Handbook 承接 packet / prompt / record / simulation labeling。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Coverage Gaps
|
||||
|
||||
当前五个 worker 覆盖了源文五轮，主要缺口不是 source coverage，而是 synthesis 粒度裁决：
|
||||
|
||||
- 第 8 篇文章方向尚未确定主叙事：R02 的真假工程化、R03 的预测偏差、R05 的文档分层都可成为主线。
|
||||
- HiFi patch 需要决定五条原则是否足够作为 V2.1 最小补丁，还是还要加入 QPI Drift / Production Workshop / Separate Role from Model。
|
||||
- Handbook 第一版范围需要收敛：R05 的章节清单过全，第一版必须项和扩展项需要分层。
|
||||
- `Context Compiler` 的承接边界需要后续人工确认：Handbook 操作项、CCPE 建造项、还是仅作为文章材料。
|
||||
- `Production Workshop` 容易误触 video-workbench 边界，topic map 必须显式标注为分类材料而非本 run 下游项目。
|
||||
- GPT 外链全程未核验，只能作为 discussion material，不得成为正式知识依据。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Candidate Topic-Map Drafting Inputs
|
||||
|
||||
后续起草 `01-topic-map.md` 时建议使用以下节点标签：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
root_candidate:
|
||||
id: complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
title: 复杂度放置门
|
||||
role: root
|
||||
|
||||
primary_children:
|
||||
- id: trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
title: ROI 异常与成本账本
|
||||
- id: practice-cases
|
||||
title: 实践案例层
|
||||
- id: diagnostic-models
|
||||
title: 诊断模型层
|
||||
- id: agentic-governance
|
||||
title: 专家型 Agentic 运行治理
|
||||
- id: document-layering
|
||||
title: 文档与工程承接层
|
||||
|
||||
practice_case_children:
|
||||
- writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
- material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
- dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
|
||||
governance_children:
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
- context-compiler-fidelity-evaluation
|
||||
|
||||
document_layer_children:
|
||||
- hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
- agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
- ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
- project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
建议 cross-links：
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
cross_links:
|
||||
- from: writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
to: execution-authenticity
|
||||
- from: material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
to: context-compiler-fidelity-evaluation
|
||||
- from: trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
to: cost-ledger
|
||||
- from: dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
to: project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- from: hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
to: agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
- from: ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
to: execution-authenticity
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 10. Human Decisions Needed Before Promotion
|
||||
|
||||
用户确认前不要创建 `01-topic-map.md`。建议下一次确认只问 topic-map promotion 所需的关键问题：
|
||||
|
||||
1. 是否接受以 `复杂度放置门` 作为 `01-topic-map.md` 根主题，并把 `专家型 Agentic 运行治理` 放在其下展开？
|
||||
2. HiFi patch 最小补丁是否先限定为五条原则：默认轻量、真实执行、成本分账、任务漂移、停止权？
|
||||
3. Agentic Handbook 第一版是否先限定为 Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Scope Drift、Stop Rule 六组守则？
|
||||
4. `Context Compiler` 和 `Production Workshop` 是否只作为候选 / cross-link 材料保留，暂不升为核心 topic？
|
||||
5. 第 8 篇文章材料在 topic map 中是否只保留素材方向，不进入正式文章提纲？
|
||||
|
||||
## 11. Forbidden Artifact Check
|
||||
|
||||
本 synthesis-prep 输出没有创建以下产物：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
01-topic-map.md
|
||||
02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
topics/*.md
|
||||
audits/*.md
|
||||
model-mining/*
|
||||
model cards
|
||||
model index entries
|
||||
writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,178 @@
|
|||
# Agent Invocation Packet: whole-source-gestalt-reviewer
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Invocation Identity
|
||||
|
||||
- project_id: knowledge-vault
|
||||
- workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
- stage: Step 0 whole-source gestalt alignment
|
||||
- run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
- participant_id: whole-source-gestalt-reviewer
|
||||
- target_participant_name: Whole-Source Gestalt Reviewer
|
||||
- participant_type: high_context_participant
|
||||
- canonical_artifact_path: `C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\ccpe-system\agents\agent-specs\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer.agent.md`
|
||||
- canonical_artifact_version: unknown_current
|
||||
- invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
- packet_type: formal_runtime_participant_invocation
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Canonical Artifact Handling
|
||||
|
||||
- should_paste_full_prompt_or_spec: no; canonical artifact path is provided and the task contract is summarized in prompt-to-send
|
||||
- prompt_to_send_path: `C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\prompt-to-send.md`
|
||||
- role_integrity_requirement: preserve Step 0 whole-source gestalt reviewer role
|
||||
- allowed_wrapper_instructions: repository path, output path, boundary rule, user structural prior, forbidden actions, return contract
|
||||
- forbidden_role_changes: do not become topic router, topic doc writer, segmentation worker, product designer, article writer, or implementation planner
|
||||
- no_simulation_requirement: true
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Invocation Carrier
|
||||
|
||||
- carrier_type: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
- thread_id: 019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1
|
||||
- agent_id:
|
||||
- persistent_required: true
|
||||
- resume_or_followup_method: send follow-up prompt to the same Codex child thread
|
||||
- execution_status: returned_output_available_pending_human_confirmation
|
||||
- strict_invocation_required: true
|
||||
- simulation_only: false
|
||||
|
||||
Language policy status:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
human_confirmation_artifact: true
|
||||
gate_id_if_applicable: Gate 0 / Step 0 human review
|
||||
language_policy_status: pending
|
||||
repair_required: unknown_until_return
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Returned output status:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
returned_output_path: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
returned_output_available: true
|
||||
human_confirmation_status: pending
|
||||
accepted_as_worker_lens: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Current Task
|
||||
|
||||
Read the full source document as a whole and return a Step 0 structural alignment report.
|
||||
|
||||
The report must help the user decide:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- whether the source is coherent, mixed, or fragmented
|
||||
- whether the five rounds should be treated as one unified development arc or split into macro-topics
|
||||
- how to interpret the relation between deep creative workflow and AI development methodology
|
||||
- whether downstream mode should be structure-first, macro-topic split, or flat-discovery
|
||||
- whether later topics should be organized as a tree, a flat list, or a mixed graph
|
||||
- what worker lenses and distortion guardrails should be carried into segmentation and extraction
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Input Files
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Context Files
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\skills\knowledge-processing\viewpoint-discussion-distillation\README.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\skills\knowledge-processing\viewpoint-discussion-distillation\runbook.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\skills\knowledge-processing\viewpoint-discussion-distillation\context-strategy.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\skills\knowledge-processing\viewpoint-discussion-distillation\invocation-contract.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\skills\knowledge-processing\viewpoint-discussion-distillation\participant-registry.md
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\00-source-map.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Embedded Inputs
|
||||
|
||||
Round boundary rule:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Use only numeric Markdown H1 headings matching ^#\s+\d+\s*$ as discussion round boundaries.
|
||||
Ignore non-numeric H1 headings inside a numeric round.
|
||||
Inside each numeric round, ## GPT marks the start of the GPT response.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Source size:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
196795 bytes, 5079 lines, 5 numeric H1 rounds.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
User structural prior:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程就是我在践行我的 AI 开发方法论。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Output Contract
|
||||
|
||||
Write the returned output to:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
The output must include:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- participant identity and invocation metadata
|
||||
- source document path and source version note
|
||||
- source primary language and output language policy
|
||||
- coherence judgment: coherent / mixed / fragmented
|
||||
- judgment on unified-main-axis versus macro-topic split
|
||||
- explicit treatment of the user's structural prior
|
||||
- recommended downstream mode: structure-first / macro-topic split / flat-discovery
|
||||
- recommendation on topic organization: tree / flat / mixed graph, with rationale
|
||||
- global topic portrait
|
||||
- main structure or candidate layers
|
||||
- core tensions and governing questions
|
||||
- model-evolution line
|
||||
- parent/child/tool/case/action-layer distinctions
|
||||
- chunk-first distortion risks
|
||||
- segmentation guidance for downstream workers
|
||||
- worker lens recommendation: required / partial / omitted
|
||||
- confidence notes and unresolved structure questions
|
||||
- human confirmation status: pending
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Continuity Policy
|
||||
|
||||
The same child thread must be used for user corrections or follow-up alignment before the Step 0 output becomes a worker lens.
|
||||
|
||||
## 10. Session Logging
|
||||
|
||||
The main session will record:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- child thread id
|
||||
- send status
|
||||
- return status
|
||||
- returned-output path
|
||||
- follow-up correction prompts, if any
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 11. Forbidden Actions
|
||||
|
||||
The participant must not:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- modify the source file
|
||||
- create final 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- create 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- write topic documents
|
||||
- perform evidence routing
|
||||
- perform material-unit extraction
|
||||
- claim coverage audit completion
|
||||
- create writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
- treat the Step 0 report as final topic authority
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 12. Runtime Acceptance Rule
|
||||
|
||||
This output is accepted only if it is produced by the recorded Codex child thread or another real persistent participant and saved to the return path with participant metadata.
|
||||
|
||||
Human confirmation is required before downstream segmentation or worker extraction.
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,134 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
artifact_id: gate-0-step-0-human-confirmation
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
artifact_type: human_confirmation_record
|
||||
created: 2026-06-12
|
||||
confirmed_artifact: invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
confirmation_status: confirmed_with_constraints
|
||||
may_use_as_worker_lens: true
|
||||
may_dispatch_broad_fidelity_workers: true
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: false
|
||||
may_create_material_routing_log: false
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
model_mining_allowed: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Gate 0 / Step 0 Human Confirmation
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Confirmation Summary
|
||||
|
||||
用户已阅读并确认：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
invocations/whole-source-gestalt-reviewer/returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
用户对 Step 0 的观点矫正没有异议，允许继续后续 file-backed worker 处理。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Confirmed Structural Decisions
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.1 Root Theme
|
||||
|
||||
根主题可采用：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
复杂度放置门
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
确认理由：
|
||||
|
||||
- 本次讨论的最初触发是预测偏差和用户感受到的认知失调。
|
||||
- 讨论前后的最大收获已经落在“复杂度放置门”。
|
||||
- 后续工作是归档性处理，目标是支撑三个连续任务。
|
||||
|
||||
下游 worker 应把“复杂度放置门”理解为本次材料的最大方法论收获，而不是简单的“反过度工程”或“Agentic 方法论补丁”。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.2 Three Downstream Tasks
|
||||
|
||||
本次分拆材料需要支撑三个连续任务：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. 写第 8 篇文章
|
||||
2. 为 HiFi Agent Studio 打补丁
|
||||
3. 补充 Agentic Handbook 守则内容
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
这三个任务互有关联，但在后续 topic graph / task routing 中应作为三个 topic/task 方向处理。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.3 Practice Case Layer
|
||||
|
||||
用户确认：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程 / 素材提炼 / 降维输出
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
在本次 topic graph 中主要作为实践案例层，不作为三个独立父主题。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.4 HiFi Studio And Agentic Handbook Relationship
|
||||
|
||||
`HiFi Agent Studio 纲领补丁` 与 `Agentic Handbook 守则内容` 后续对应不同任务。
|
||||
|
||||
因此下游暂按三个任务方向处理：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- article_direction: 第 8 篇文章
|
||||
- system_patch_direction: HiFi Agent Studio
|
||||
- handbook_direction: Agentic Handbook
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
不要把 Handbook 简单降为 Studio 的唯一执行承接子层。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.5 No Model Asset Extraction In This Run
|
||||
|
||||
本次不做模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
用户规则：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
所有模型资产都需要用户产生正文后，再从正文中蒸馏出来。
|
||||
正文会经历讨论 / 正交过程。
|
||||
直接基于某一个 GPT 提议抽取模型资产会产生偏差。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
下游 worker 可以标注 `candidate_concept`、`article_material`、`system_patch_material`、`handbook_material`，但不得创建 model card、model index entry、canonical model asset，或宣称完成 model-mining。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.6 Exclude Video Workbench
|
||||
|
||||
本次不需要考虑 `video-workbench`。
|
||||
|
||||
`生产工坊` 如果出现，只作为讨论中的类比、案例或 HiFi 密封舱三分法的上下文证据，不单独为 video-workbench 保留 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
### 2.7 External Links
|
||||
|
||||
源材料中 GPT 引用的外部资料链接只作为讨论材料的一部分保留。
|
||||
|
||||
本次蒸馏不进行外部来源核验，也不把未核验外链提升为正式知识资产依据。
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Worker Lens
|
||||
|
||||
下游 worker 可使用 Step 0 的 worker lens，并叠加本确认记录：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
本源材料的主轴是“复杂度放置门”：用户通过深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出和 HiFi Agent Studio 的实践复盘，推导出专家型 Agentic 系统需要在项目入口、执行真实性、成本分账、停止规则、任务漂移和文档分层上建立运行治理。深度创作流程是该 AI 开发方法论的实践样本，不是与方法论并列的宏主题。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
同时必须保留本次确认新增的下游任务约束：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
第 8 篇文章 / HiFi Agent Studio 补丁 / Agentic Handbook 守则
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Permission Boundary
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
step_0_output_accepted_as_worker_lens: true
|
||||
may_dispatch_broad_fidelity_workers: true
|
||||
may_create_segmentation_worker_design: true
|
||||
may_create_topic_map: false
|
||||
may_create_material_routing_log: false
|
||||
may_create_topic_docs: false
|
||||
may_create_model_assets: false
|
||||
may_create_writing_workbench_handoff: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,161 @@
|
|||
# Prompt To Send: whole-source-gestalt-reviewer
|
||||
|
||||
You are the `whole-source-gestalt-reviewer` participant for a Knowledge Vault `viewpoint-discussion-distillation` run.
|
||||
|
||||
This is a formal Step 0 participant invocation. Do not simulate another agent. Do not write as the main session.
|
||||
|
||||
## Canonical Role
|
||||
|
||||
Canonical artifact:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\ccpe-system\agents\agent-specs\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer.agent.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
If readable, use it as the binding role specification. If not readable, follow the contract below and explicitly record the artifact access limitation in the returned output.
|
||||
|
||||
## Source
|
||||
|
||||
Read this full source document:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Source metadata:
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_type: five-round ChatGPT discussion draft
|
||||
source_size_bytes: 196795
|
||||
source_line_count: 5079
|
||||
source_sha256: 1ECF344824AF1D5DA3F1AB19C092460D41F6726D764ABD0345D7CF8AB66E53F3
|
||||
source_version_note: file last modified 2026-06-12 04:59:16 local time
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Boundary Rule
|
||||
|
||||
Use only numeric Markdown H1 headings matching `^#\s+\d+\s*$` as discussion round boundaries.
|
||||
|
||||
Inside each numeric round:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
# N -> before ## GPT: user input / source material for round N
|
||||
## GPT -> before next numeric # N+1: GPT response for round N
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Ignore non-numeric H1 headings as round boundaries. They are intra-round content. Known intra-round H1 headings include:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
# 评审环节改造：信息材料抽取初稿
|
||||
# 素材提炼改造：信息材料抽取初稿
|
||||
# 降维输出的工作流
|
||||
# **HiFi Agent Studio**
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Registered round ranges:
|
||||
|
||||
| range_id | start_line | gpt_start_line | end_line |
|
||||
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
|
||||
| R01 | 1 | 843 | 1020 |
|
||||
| R02 | 1021 | 1192 | 1909 |
|
||||
| R03 | 1910 | 1962 | 2638 |
|
||||
| R04 | 2639 | 2904 | 4013 |
|
||||
| R05 | 4014 | 4027 | 5079 |
|
||||
|
||||
## User Structural Prior
|
||||
|
||||
The user supplied this interpretation before Step 0:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程就是我在践行我的 AI 开发方法论。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not prematurely split the source into two peer macro-topics named "deep creative workflow" and "AI development methodology." First test the unified hypothesis:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
The deep creative workflow is a practical enactment / lived case / operating sample of the user's AI development methodology.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
You may still recommend a macro split if the source evidence requires it, but you must explicitly explain why the unified hypothesis is insufficient.
|
||||
|
||||
## Task
|
||||
|
||||
Read the full source as a whole and produce a Step 0 gestalt alignment report before any segmentation, topic routing, topic docs, material extraction, or downstream handoff.
|
||||
|
||||
The report should help the user decide:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- whether the source is coherent, mixed, or fragmented
|
||||
- whether the five rounds should stay under one unified main axis or split into macro-topics
|
||||
- how deep creative workflow relates to AI development methodology
|
||||
- whether downstream mode should be structure-first, macro-topic split, or flat-discovery
|
||||
- whether later topic organization should be tree-shaped, flat, or a mixed graph
|
||||
- what worker lens and distortion guardrails should be carried into downstream segmentation and extraction
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Required Output File
|
||||
|
||||
Write your returned output to:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\discussions\viewpoint-development\2026-06-12-复杂度放置门\invocations\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer\returned-output.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Required Output Structure
|
||||
|
||||
Your `returned-output.md` must include:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Participant identity and invocation metadata
|
||||
2. Source document path and source version note
|
||||
3. Source primary language and output language policy
|
||||
4. Coherence judgment: coherent / mixed / fragmented
|
||||
5. Unified-main-axis versus macro-topic split judgment
|
||||
6. Treatment of the user's structural prior
|
||||
7. Recommended downstream mode: structure-first / macro-topic split / flat-discovery
|
||||
8. Topic organization recommendation: tree / flat / mixed graph
|
||||
9. Global topic portrait
|
||||
10. Main structure or candidate layers
|
||||
11. Core tensions and governing questions
|
||||
12. Model-evolution line
|
||||
13. Parent / child / tool / case / action-layer distinctions
|
||||
14. Chunk-first distortion risks
|
||||
15. Segmentation guidance for downstream workers
|
||||
16. Worker lens recommendation: required / partial / omitted
|
||||
17. Confidence notes and unresolved structure questions
|
||||
18. Human confirmation status: pending
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Write the explanatory content primarily in Chinese. Technical identifiers, file paths, and protocol field names may remain English.
|
||||
|
||||
## Forbidden Actions
|
||||
|
||||
Do not:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- modify the source
|
||||
- create or finalize 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- create 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- write topic documents
|
||||
- perform evidence routing
|
||||
- extract material units
|
||||
- claim coverage audit completion
|
||||
- create writing-workbench handoff
|
||||
- treat this Step 0 report as final topic authority
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## Return Message
|
||||
|
||||
After writing the file, reply briefly with:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
- output path
|
||||
- coherence judgment
|
||||
- unified-main-axis versus macro-topic split recommendation
|
||||
- recommended downstream mode
|
||||
- topic organization recommendation
|
||||
- unresolved questions requiring user confirmation
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,455 @@
|
|||
# Whole-Source Gestalt Alignment
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Participant Identity And Invocation Metadata
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
workflow: viewpoint-discussion-distillation
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
stage: Step 0 whole-source gestalt alignment
|
||||
participant_id: whole-source-gestalt-reviewer
|
||||
participant_type: high_context_participant
|
||||
invocation_mode: codex_thread_participant
|
||||
thread_id: 019eb88c-4bab-7b21-9ab1-f14e07db46a1
|
||||
packet_type: formal_runtime_participant_invocation
|
||||
simulation_only: false
|
||||
formal_output: true
|
||||
human_confirmation_artifact: true
|
||||
human_confirmation_status: pending
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本输出由 `whole-source-gestalt-reviewer` 参与者按调用包执行。已读取调用提示、调用包、角色规约、运行上下文文件、source map，并按注册的五个数字 H1 轮次读取源材料。本文只做 Step 0 全文结构校准，不执行分段、路由、材料抽取、topic doc 生成、覆盖审计或 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
|
||||
角色规约已读取：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\ccpe-system\agents\agent-specs\whole-source-gestalt-reviewer.agent.md
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Document Path And Source Version Note
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_document_path: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\diary\2026\2026-06\2026-06-12.md
|
||||
source_type: five-round ChatGPT discussion draft
|
||||
source_version_note: file last modified 2026-06-12 04:59:16 local time
|
||||
source_size_bytes: 196795
|
||||
source_line_count: 5079
|
||||
source_sha256: 1ECF344824AF1D5DA3F1AB19C092460D41F6726D764ABD0345D7CF8AB66E53F3
|
||||
round_count: 5
|
||||
round_boundary_rule: numeric Markdown H1 only, matching ^#\s+\d+\s*$
|
||||
gpt_response_boundary_rule: "## GPT marks the GPT response start inside the current numeric round"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
已核对本地文件行数与 SHA-256，和调用提示及 `00-source-map.md` 一致。非数字 H1 标题被视为轮次内部内容，而不是新轮次边界。
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Source Primary Language And Output Language Policy
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
source_primary_language: zh-CN
|
||||
output_language_policy: mirror_source_primary_language
|
||||
language_policy_result: satisfied
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
说明性内容主要使用中文。技术字段、协议字段、文件路径和少量英文术语保留原形。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Coherence Judgment
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
coherence_judgment: coherent
|
||||
confidence: high
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
该源材料应判定为 **coherent**，不是 fragmented，也不需要先按两个或多个平级宏主题拆开再各自 Step 0。
|
||||
|
||||
理由是五轮讨论虽然表面上经过了多个对象：`viewpoint-discussion-distillation`、写作评审流程、素材提炼流程、降维输出流程、HiFi Agent Studio、Agentic Handbook，但它们共同推进的是同一个问题：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
在专家型 Agentic 系统中，如何判断复杂度应该放在哪里，何时该轻量执行，何时必须进入真实调用、可追溯、可治理的重流程。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
R01 从 5 万字蒸馏却消耗约 3000 万 tokens 的 ROI 异常切入，提出“大炮打蚊子”的直觉。R02 把异常拆成两个真实案例：写作评审流程的假执行问题，以及素材提炼 Runtime 的治理级过载问题。R03 把案例外推到专家型 Agentic 系统和真实生产环境，区分深度创作“实验室”和降维输出“生产线”。R04 将这些经验回灌到 HiFi Agent Studio，提出缺的不是更多哲学，而是运行治理层。R05 进一步裁定文档层级：HiFi Agent Studio 保持纲领，Agentic Handbook 承接操作守则，CCPE System 作为建造工坊，项目 runbook 负责本地流程。
|
||||
|
||||
因此，材料有清晰的递进路径：异常感 -> 案例复盘 -> QPI/复杂度再定性 -> 专家 Agentic 普遍化 -> HiFi 方法论补丁 -> 文档分层。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Unified-Main-Axis Versus Macro-Topic Split Judgment
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
recommendation: unified_main_axis
|
||||
macro_topic_split_required_before_downstream: false
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
建议保持一个统一主轴，不建议把“深度创作流程”和“AI 开发方法论”拆成两个平级宏主题。
|
||||
|
||||
更准确的结构是：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程 / 素材提炼流程 / 降维输出流程
|
||||
= 用户 AI 开发方法论的实践样本、压力测试场和案例证据。
|
||||
|
||||
HiFi Agent Studio / CCPE System / Agentic Handbook
|
||||
= 对这些实践经验进行抽象、治理化和工程化承接的上层方法体系。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
也就是说，前者不是和后者并列的另一个主题，而是后者在真实工作流中的 lived case / operating sample / stress test。只有在后续要分别写两类交付物时，才可在执行层拆分为不同材料包：一组面向“深度创作流程改造案例”，一组面向“HiFi Agentic 方法论补丁”。但在 Step 0 结构上，它们应挂在同一棵主轴下。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Treatment Of The User's Structural Prior
|
||||
|
||||
用户结构先验为：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程就是我在践行我的 AI 开发方法论。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本次全文阅读支持该先验，但建议稍作精确化：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程不是整个 AI 开发方法论本身，而是该方法论在高密度专家知识工作中的实践原型、验证场和反例生成器。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
这个修正很重要。若直接说“深度创作流程就是方法论”，可能会把具体案例和上层原则粘死；若拆成两个平级宏主题，又会丢掉源材料真正的演化关系。较稳的表达是：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程是 HiFi / CCPE / Agentic 方法论的实战源头之一；
|
||||
它通过失败、过载和迁移摩擦，把方法论缺失的运行治理层逼出来。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Recommended Downstream Mode
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
recommended_downstream_mode: structure-first
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
建议下游采用 **structure-first**，不采用 macro-topic split，也不采用 flat-discovery。
|
||||
|
||||
原因：
|
||||
|
||||
- 源材料本身是连贯的模型演化讨论，先平铺发现会把“案例、工具、方法论补丁、文档层级”误判为同级 topic。
|
||||
- 材料中的关键价值不是某个局部事实，而是多个案例如何共同逼出“复杂度放置门 / 运行治理层”。
|
||||
- 后续 worker 应在统一主轴下补充、挑战和细化，而不是重新从局部切片中发明一套平级主题。
|
||||
|
||||
## 8. Topic Organization Recommendation
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
topic_organization_recommendation: mixed_graph
|
||||
tree_backbone_required: true
|
||||
cross_links_required: true
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
建议采用 **tree-backed mixed graph**：主干应是树状，但必须允许跨链接。
|
||||
|
||||
主干需要树状，是因为本材料有明显的层级：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
根问题：复杂度应该放在哪里
|
||||
-> 实践案例层
|
||||
-> 诊断模型层
|
||||
-> HiFi/CCPE 方法论补丁层
|
||||
-> 文档与工程承接层
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
但不能做成纯树，因为源材料中有多个横向复用关系：
|
||||
|
||||
- QPI 同时用于任务分诊、密封舱分类、P/I 漂移识别、Runtime 档位选择。
|
||||
- no-simulation 同时连接写作评审、Knowledge Vault 蒸馏、Agentic 生产环境。
|
||||
- whole-source gestalt 同时是知识蒸馏的结构守卫，也是 Context Compiler 的一种高上下文策略。
|
||||
- Cost Ledger 同时服务 ROI 解释、团队协作、产品化边界。
|
||||
- Stop Rule 同时限制素材蒸馏、topic docs、audit、handoff、Agentic Handbook。
|
||||
|
||||
因此，后续 topic graph 应以树状主轴保证可读性，以 cross-link 保留模型复用和概念迁移。
|
||||
|
||||
## 9. Global Topic Portrait
|
||||
|
||||
全局画像可以概括为：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
这是一轮围绕“复杂度放置门”的方法论生成讨论。
|
||||
|
||||
用户从一次高成本知识蒸馏和两次流程改造的异常体验出发，逐步意识到：问题不只是工具不熟或 SuperPowers 放大流程，而是个人成熟专家流程迁移到 Agentic 环境时，隐性判断、真实调用、上下文裁剪、成本分账、停止条件、角色权力、工程成熟度都会被迫显性化。
|
||||
|
||||
讨论最终把这些经验沉淀为 HiFi Agent Studio 的运行治理补丁，并进一步提出文档分层：HiFi Agent Studio 保持方法论宪法，Agentic Engineering Handbook 承接项目分诊、执行真实性、成本账本、停止规则、评测栈和平台适配。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
这不是单纯的“写作流程自动化反思”，也不是单纯的“AI 开发方法论整理”。它的核心是：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
专家型 Agentic 系统如何在真实性、保真性、成本、复用、治理和人类责任之间放置复杂度。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 10. Main Structure Or Candidate Layers
|
||||
|
||||
建议的候选层级如下，供后续 topic graph synthesizer 检查，不作为最终 topic map：
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 0: 触发层 - ROI 异常与怪异感
|
||||
|
||||
- 5 万字讨论稿被 Full Runtime 式蒸馏，消耗约 3000 万 tokens。
|
||||
- 用户提出“大炮打蚊子”、SuperPowers 是否导致过重、ROI 是否失控。
|
||||
- GPT 初步诊断：内容任务、系统建设和流程测试被混在同一账本。
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 1: 实践案例层 - 两次流程改造和一次输出流程对照
|
||||
|
||||
- 写作评审流程：核心不是多 Agent 文件，而是真实 invocation 边界。
|
||||
- 素材提炼流程：核心不是 topic 多寡，而是 chunk-first 误判与 whole-source gestalt 修复。
|
||||
- 降维输出流程：比深度创作更适合先 Agentic 化，因为边界更清楚、验收更明确、低判断高摩擦环节更多。
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 2: 诊断模型层 - QPI 漂移与复杂度放置
|
||||
|
||||
- 表层 P 任务可能滑入 I 域治理。
|
||||
- Issue 不只来自多人组织，也来自多目标、多状态、多权衡。
|
||||
- 复杂度不应被简单反对，而应问它购买了什么：真实性、独立性、保真性、可追溯性、可复盘性、可复用性、风险控制。
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 3: Agentic 专家系统层 - 隐性专家流程显性化
|
||||
|
||||
- Web 单智能体环境是人类主导的软 Runtime。
|
||||
- Codex / Agentic 环境会把角色、文件、状态、调用、权限、证据和 trace 物理化。
|
||||
- 专家赋能型系统的关键不是更多 Agent，而是专家判断位置被正确建模。
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 4: HiFi Agent Studio 补丁层 - 从纲领到运行治理
|
||||
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 已有世界观、控制棒、密封舱、QPI、绿野仙踪、MFK、复杂性守恒。
|
||||
- 缺的是运行治理层：Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity、Scope Drift Detector、Stop Rule、Evaluation Stack、Runtime Maturity Model 等。
|
||||
- 这些不宜全部塞进纲领，应分拆到 Agentic Handbook。
|
||||
|
||||
### Layer 5: 文档体系层 - 宪法、守则、工坊、项目规程
|
||||
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio = 纲领 / 方法论宪法。
|
||||
- HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook = Agentic 开工守则 / 运行治理。
|
||||
- CCPE System = Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊。
|
||||
- Project Runbook = writing-workbench、video-workbench、knowledge-vault 等具体流程规程。
|
||||
|
||||
## 11. Core Tensions And Governing Questions
|
||||
|
||||
核心张力如下：
|
||||
|
||||
1. **内容产出 vs 系统建设**
|
||||
- 现在是在完成一次材料整理，还是在建造未来反复运行的机器？
|
||||
- 成本应该记入内容账本，还是系统研发账本？
|
||||
|
||||
2. **真实执行 vs 流程幻觉**
|
||||
- 文件看似完整时，是否真的发生了独立 Agent 调用？
|
||||
- 缺少 invocation record 的 report 能否进入正式 synthesis？
|
||||
|
||||
3. **保真性 vs ROI**
|
||||
- 哪些保真环节值得付出成本？
|
||||
- 单篇 5 万字材料是否需要 full coverage audit、厚 topic docs 和完整 worker routing？
|
||||
|
||||
4. **整体结构 vs 局部切块**
|
||||
- coherent long discussion 是否必须先 whole-source gestalt？
|
||||
- 什么时候 chunk-first 会让局部真实冒充整体结构？
|
||||
|
||||
5. **P 域求解 vs I 域治理**
|
||||
- 流程改造为什么从“明确产物”滑入“权衡、责任、真实性、成本、复用”的治理题？
|
||||
- QPI 是否需要加入 drift / 任务漂移机制？
|
||||
|
||||
6. **方法论纲领 vs 工程守则**
|
||||
- 哪些原则应进入 HiFi Agent Studio？
|
||||
- 哪些细节应下放到 Agentic Handbook、CCPE System 或项目 runbook？
|
||||
|
||||
7. **专家主权 vs 自动化诱惑**
|
||||
- AI 应替专家做哪些低判断高摩擦工作？
|
||||
- 哪些高风险判断必须保留 human gate、decision rationale 和责任边界？
|
||||
|
||||
## 12. Model-Evolution Line
|
||||
|
||||
源材料中的模型演化线可概括为：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Web 单智能体专家流程
|
||||
-> Prompt 工程 / 多角色软协作
|
||||
-> 上下文工程 / premise-context-pack / role-specific context
|
||||
-> Agent Invocation Packet / no-simulation
|
||||
-> Knowledge Vault whole-source gestalt / structure-first distillation
|
||||
-> Complexity Placement Gate
|
||||
-> HiFi Agent Studio 运行治理补丁
|
||||
-> HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
其中最关键的演化节点是：
|
||||
|
||||
- 从“会写 prompt”到“区分 Prompt / Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model”。
|
||||
- 从“角色扮演可用”到“正式 Agent 输出必须真实执行”。
|
||||
- 从“长材料先分块”到“coherent source 先整体画像”。
|
||||
- 从“反过度工程”到“复杂度放置：复杂度必须购买具体价值”。
|
||||
- 从“QPI 定性”到“QPI drift + Project Intake + Lite/Standard/Full mode selector”。
|
||||
- 从“HiFi 方法论宣言”到“HiFi 纲领 + Agentic Handbook 的文档分层”。
|
||||
|
||||
## 13. Parent / Child / Tool / Case / Action-Layer Distinctions
|
||||
|
||||
后续 worker 必须保留以下层级差异，避免把它们压平成同级主题：
|
||||
|
||||
### Parent Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
- 复杂度放置门 / Complexity Placement Gate
|
||||
- 专家型 Agentic 系统运行治理
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio 从纲领到运行观的补丁
|
||||
|
||||
### Child Topics
|
||||
|
||||
- no-simulation / Execution Authenticity
|
||||
- Mode Selector / Lite-Standard-Full
|
||||
- Cost Ledger / 成本分账
|
||||
- Stop Rule / 停止规则
|
||||
- Scope Drift / QPI Drift
|
||||
- Context Compiler / whole-source gestalt
|
||||
- Authority Matrix
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model
|
||||
|
||||
### Tools Or Mechanisms
|
||||
|
||||
- Agent Invocation Packet
|
||||
- prompt-to-send
|
||||
- returned-output
|
||||
- source-map
|
||||
- topic-map
|
||||
- material-routing-log
|
||||
- coverage audit
|
||||
- decision record
|
||||
- structured feedback slot
|
||||
|
||||
这些是机制或产物，不应自动升格为父主题。
|
||||
|
||||
### Cases
|
||||
|
||||
- 写作评审流程 / 三国测试：真实调用边界的反例。
|
||||
- 素材提炼流程 / 失望性情感隔离三轮：chunk-first、whole-source gestalt、Full Runtime 成本的案例。
|
||||
- 降维输出流程：更适合先 Agentic 化的生产工坊样本。
|
||||
- HiFi Agent Studio：方法论承接案例。
|
||||
|
||||
### Action Layers
|
||||
|
||||
- 纲领应补的五条：默认轻量、执行真实性、成本分账、任务漂移重定性、停止权。
|
||||
- 守则应承接的细则：Project Intake、Mode Selector 表格、Invocation 字段、Simulation Labeling、Authority Matrix、Evaluation Stack、平台适配。
|
||||
- CCPE System 承接构建：Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card。
|
||||
- 项目 runbook 承接本地执行。
|
||||
|
||||
### Model Assets
|
||||
|
||||
- QPI Spectrum
|
||||
- Complexity Placement Gate
|
||||
- Fidelity Ladder
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack
|
||||
- Context Compiler
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity Protocol
|
||||
|
||||
这些更像可沉淀模型或协议，但是否升为 Model Card 应等待后续 model-mining 或用户确认。
|
||||
|
||||
## 14. Chunk-First Distortion Risks
|
||||
|
||||
如果下游直接按 R01-R05 或更小 chunk 做 flat topic discovery，主要风险如下：
|
||||
|
||||
1. **把案例误判为平级主轴**
|
||||
- R02 的写作评审流程、素材提炼流程可能被分成两个宏主题，遮蔽它们共同服务“复杂度放置门”的关系。
|
||||
|
||||
2. **把深度创作流程和 AI 开发方法论拆成并列主题**
|
||||
- 这会违反用户结构先验，也会丢掉“实践样本 -> 方法论补丁”的生成关系。
|
||||
|
||||
3. **把工具产物升成父主题**
|
||||
- invocation packet、topic docs、coverage audit、prompt-to-send 可能被错误视为主题本体，而不是真实性、保真性、追溯性的工具。
|
||||
|
||||
4. **把 QPI 当成孤立理论**
|
||||
- 源材料中 QPI 的关键不是复述 Q/P/I，而是加入 drift、mode selector、P 任务滑入 I 治理的判断。
|
||||
|
||||
5. **把 HiFi Agent Studio 补丁写成泛泛建议清单**
|
||||
- R04/R05 的重点不是“补很多模块”，而是裁定哪些进纲领，哪些下放 Agentic Handbook。
|
||||
|
||||
6. **把 ROI 问题缩成 SuperPowers 插件问题**
|
||||
- SuperPowers 只是放大工程化惯性的因素之一，不是主轴。主轴是任务分层、执行模式和成本账本。
|
||||
|
||||
7. **把降维输出流程纳入深度创作同一生产线**
|
||||
- 源材料明确说两者是不同项目：`writing-workbench` 和 `video-workbench`，关系是同一方法论下的不同场景，不是同一 runbook 的连续阶段。
|
||||
|
||||
## 15. Segmentation Guidance For Downstream Workers
|
||||
|
||||
建议按轮次保留原始边界，但给 worker 一个结构镜头：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
R01: 触发问题与初始诊断
|
||||
- ROI 怪异感
|
||||
- SuperPowers / runbook / Full Runtime 归因
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full 的初步分档
|
||||
|
||||
R02: 两个实践案例和 QPI 修正
|
||||
- 写作评审流程的真实调用边界
|
||||
- 素材提炼流程的 chunk-first 失败与 whole-source gestalt 修复
|
||||
- 调流程从 P 滑入 I 的判断
|
||||
- 复杂度放置门雏形
|
||||
|
||||
R03: 专家型 Agentic 系统外推
|
||||
- 深度创作流程作为专家系统缩影
|
||||
- 降维输出流程作为更适合先自动化的生产工坊
|
||||
- 专家隐性经验、human gate、context compiler、trace、stop rule 等原则
|
||||
|
||||
R04: HiFi Agent Studio 的运行治理补丁
|
||||
- HiFi 现有体系评估
|
||||
- Project Intake、Mode Selector、Cost Ledger、Execution Authenticity 等候选补丁
|
||||
- 对现有文本的具体修正建议
|
||||
|
||||
R05: 文档分层裁决
|
||||
- 支持将 HiFi Agent Studio 和 Agentic Handbook 分拆
|
||||
- 明确纲领保留项和守则下放项
|
||||
- 提出五条应进入纲领的核心新增原则
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
worker 应在每个范围内分别标注：
|
||||
|
||||
- 源材料事实；
|
||||
- 用户自我判断；
|
||||
- GPT 给出的结构诊断；
|
||||
- 可沉淀原则；
|
||||
- 可沉淀工具/协议；
|
||||
- 案例证据；
|
||||
- 后续仍需用户确认的结构判断。
|
||||
|
||||
worker 不应把本报告当成最终 topic map；它应作为结构 lens，用来避免局部误分和层级错置。
|
||||
|
||||
## 16. Worker Lens Recommendation
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
worker_lens_recommendation: required
|
||||
binding_status: pending_human_confirmation
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
建议在用户确认后，将本 Step 0 输出作为下游 segmentation 和 topic discovery 的 required lens。
|
||||
|
||||
在确认前，本输出只能作为 provisional alignment artifact。若用户修正主轴或层级，应回到同一 Step 0 参与者进行 follow-up alignment，或记录明确 human-correction record。
|
||||
|
||||
推荐 worker lens 核心句：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
本源材料的主轴是“复杂度放置门”：用户通过深度创作、素材提炼、降维输出和 HiFi Agent Studio 的实践复盘，推导出专家型 Agentic 系统需要在项目入口、执行真实性、成本分账、停止规则、任务漂移和文档分层上建立运行治理。深度创作流程是该 AI 开发方法论的实践样本，不是与方法论并列的宏主题。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 17. Confidence Notes And Unresolved Structure Questions
|
||||
|
||||
### Confidence Notes
|
||||
|
||||
- 对 `coherent` 判断置信度高。
|
||||
- 对统一主轴判断置信度高。
|
||||
- 对 `structure-first` downstream mode 判断置信度高。
|
||||
- 对 `mixed graph` 组织建议置信度中高，因为最终 topic graph 的跨链密度需要 worker 补充证据后再裁定。
|
||||
- 对“深度创作流程是方法论实践样本，而非平级宏主题”的判断置信度高，且符合用户结构先验。
|
||||
|
||||
### Unresolved Structure Questions Requiring User Confirmation
|
||||
|
||||
1. 用户是否接受将根主题命名为 **复杂度放置门**，而不是“反过度工程”“Agentic 方法论补丁”或“专家型 Agentic 运行治理”？
|
||||
|
||||
2. 用户是否确认“深度创作流程 / 素材提炼 / 降维输出”在本次 topic graph 中主要作为实践案例层，而不是三个独立父主题？
|
||||
|
||||
3. 用户是否希望后续 topic graph 把 **HiFi Agent Studio 纲领补丁** 和 **Agentic Handbook 守则内容** 分成两个 sibling child topics，还是让 Handbook 作为 Studio 的执行承接子层？
|
||||
|
||||
4. `Complexity Placement Gate`、`Project Intake`、`Mode Selector`、`Cost Ledger`、`Execution Authenticity`、`Stop Rule` 等是否应在本次知识蒸馏中作为候选模型资产标记，还是只作为文章/手册素材保留？
|
||||
|
||||
5. 后续是否需要为 `video-workbench` 的“生产工坊”分类单独保留一个 topic，还是只作为 HiFi 密封舱三分法的案例证据？
|
||||
|
||||
6. 本源材料中 GPT 引用了一些外部资料链接。后续蒸馏是否只保留其作为讨论材料的一部分，还是需要另行核验外部来源后再进入正式知识资产？
|
||||
|
||||
## 18. Human Confirmation Status
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
human_confirmation_status: pending
|
||||
gate: Gate 0 / Step 0 human review
|
||||
accepted_as_worker_lens: false
|
||||
requires_user_action: confirm / revise / reject
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
在用户确认前，不得将本输出视为最终 topic authority，不得据此创建 `01-topic-map.md`、`02-material-routing-log.md`、`topics/`、`audits/` 或 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,160 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 01-complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- complexity-placement-gate
|
||||
- trigger-roi-ledger
|
||||
- complexity-buys-value
|
||||
- cost-ledger
|
||||
- qpi-drift
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
article_outline: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# 复杂度放置门
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
`复杂度放置门` 是本 run 的根主题。它不是“反复杂度”，而是一个入口判断：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
当 Agentic 系统足以把任何任务治理化时，先判断任务到底需要购买哪一种复杂度，再决定是否启用 Agent、Skill、Runtime、真实 invocation、审计、topic docs、handoff、模型沉淀或工程化生产线。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
trigger-roi-ledger:
|
||||
- R01-U08
|
||||
- R01-U11
|
||||
- R01-U12
|
||||
cost-ledger:
|
||||
- R01-U09
|
||||
- R04-U09
|
||||
complexity-buys-value:
|
||||
- R01-U16
|
||||
- R02-U11
|
||||
- R02-U12
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
- R04-U11
|
||||
qpi-drift:
|
||||
- R02-U06
|
||||
- R02-U10
|
||||
- R03-U17
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### High-Value Cross-Linked Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
roi_and_ledger:
|
||||
- R01-U01
|
||||
- R01-U10
|
||||
- R01-U14
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R04-U06
|
||||
- R04-U07
|
||||
- R05-U09
|
||||
- R05-U14
|
||||
practice_evidence:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
document_layering:
|
||||
- R05-U03
|
||||
- R05-U04
|
||||
- R05-U08
|
||||
- R05-U12
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Reusable Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 ROI 异常不是成本结论，而是分账失败
|
||||
|
||||
R01 的 3000 万 tokens 怪异感应保留为触发素材。它的作用不是证明系统浪费，而是暴露内容产出、系统建设、校准和探索被混进同一个账本。
|
||||
|
||||
可复用表述：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
如果把这笔成本记成“5 万字蒸馏成本”，它极不合理；如果记成“知识加工 Runtime 原型研发、Agentic 协作边界测试和 no-simulation protocol 验证成本”，它至少有解释空间。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 复杂度必须说明购买价值
|
||||
|
||||
R02/R04 的核心不是删复杂度，而是要求每一层复杂度说明它购买了什么：
|
||||
|
||||
- 真实性
|
||||
- 独立性
|
||||
- 保真性
|
||||
- 结构性
|
||||
- 可追溯性
|
||||
- 可复盘性
|
||||
- 可复用性
|
||||
- 风险控制
|
||||
- 下游依赖稳定性
|
||||
|
||||
`Agent Invocation Packet` 买真实性，`whole-source gestalt` 买结构保真；但每次都做 full coverage audit、厚 topic docs、完整 handoff 未必值得。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 QPI Drift 是本轮对 QPI 的新增点
|
||||
|
||||
本 run 不需要重写 QPI。真正新增的是 drift：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
一项任务表层可能是 P：明确产物、明确路径、局部自动化。但当它开始涉及真实性边界、角色权力、状态污染、成本分账、复用要求、审计追踪、停止规则和长期治理时，已经滑入 I 域。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.4 默认轻量不是反工程化
|
||||
|
||||
R05 确认的 HiFi patch 五原则中，“默认轻量”必须和“证据驱动升级”绑定。否则会被误读为反 Agent、反 Runtime、反治理。
|
||||
|
||||
可复用表述：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
默认轻量不是拒绝重流程，而是拒绝没有证据的重流程。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要把本 topic 写成：
|
||||
|
||||
- SuperPowers 插件复盘。
|
||||
- 省 token 技巧。
|
||||
- 反多 Agent。
|
||||
- 反 topic docs / audit。
|
||||
- QPI 全体系重写。
|
||||
- model asset 草稿。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
- ROI 怪异感
|
||||
- 第一次像真的但不是真的
|
||||
- 第二次真的但太贵
|
||||
- 复杂度不是越少越好，而是要放对位置
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
- 默认轻量
|
||||
- 成本分账
|
||||
- 任务漂移
|
||||
- 停止权
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
- Project Intake
|
||||
- Mode Selector
|
||||
- Cost Ledger
|
||||
- Scope Drift
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,140 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 02-practice-cases
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- practice-cases
|
||||
- writing-review-execution-authenticity
|
||||
- material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload
|
||||
- dimensional-reduction-production-line
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
article_outline: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# 实践案例层
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
实践案例层提供 `复杂度放置门` 的证据，不是三个平级父主题。
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作流程 / 素材提炼 / 降维输出
|
||||
= 用户 AI 开发方法论的实践样本、压力测试场和案例证据。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
writing-review-execution-authenticity:
|
||||
- R02-U01
|
||||
- R02-U07
|
||||
material-extraction-gestalt-and-overload:
|
||||
- R01-U02
|
||||
- R01-U04
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R02-U09
|
||||
dimensional-reduction-production-line:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U07
|
||||
- R03-U14
|
||||
- R03-U16
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### Cross-Linked Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
execution_authenticity:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
context_compiler:
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
scope_and_stop:
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R03-U15
|
||||
article_material:
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U04
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Reusable Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 写作评审流程：像真的但不是真的
|
||||
|
||||
关键问题不是目录、Agent 或协议太多，而是文件结构完整但关键执行边界是假的。主会话模拟多名 canonical reviewer，会破坏独立视角、调用证据和 synthesis 可信度。
|
||||
|
||||
可复用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- `dispatch-pack.md` 只是任务说明，不等于 canonical prompt。
|
||||
- 没有 prompt-to-send / invocation record / returned-output 的 report 不能进入正式 synthesis。
|
||||
- `simulation-only` 和 `excluded-from-synthesis` 不是繁文缛节，而是防止伪执行污染正式材料。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 素材提炼流程：真的但太贵
|
||||
|
||||
Chunk-first 的风险是让局部真实冒充整体结构。Whole-source gestalt 修复了结构保真问题，但完整 Full Runtime 如果默认用于单篇材料，会带来治理过载。
|
||||
|
||||
可复用材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- Coherent long source 需要先整体画像，再分段。
|
||||
- `source-map`、`topic-map`、`routing-log`、topic docs、coverage audit 都有价值，但不应自动全开。
|
||||
- Stop Rule 要防止流程继续生产中间物，而不是继续证明自己有多完整。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 降维输出流程：生产线型 MVP
|
||||
|
||||
降维输出不是本 run 的独立 topic，也不创建 video-workbench。它在本材料中作为生产线型 MVP 案例：
|
||||
|
||||
- 阶段边界清楚。
|
||||
- 产物更容易验收。
|
||||
- 低判断高摩擦环节多。
|
||||
- 核心判断仍由人类保留。
|
||||
|
||||
可复用表述：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
深度创作像实验室，降维输出像生产线。先让生产线吃掉机械、格式、素材和试错成本，再保守协议化最深判断流程。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要：
|
||||
|
||||
- 把三个实践案例升为独立父主题。
|
||||
- 把写作评审失败写成“多 Agent 太复杂”。
|
||||
- 把素材提炼流程写成“whole-source gestalt 不值得”。
|
||||
- 为降维输出创建 video-workbench topic。
|
||||
- 创建文章提纲或视频 runbook。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
- 第一次像真的但不是真的
|
||||
- 第二次真的但太贵
|
||||
- 实验室 vs 生产线
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
- 执行真实性
|
||||
- 默认轻量
|
||||
- 证据驱动升级
|
||||
- 停止权
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
- Invocation Packet
|
||||
- Simulation Labeling
|
||||
- Mode Selector
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,172 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 03-agentic-governance
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- agentic-governance
|
||||
- project-intake-mode-selector
|
||||
- execution-authenticity
|
||||
- scope-drift-stop-rule
|
||||
- human-gate-authority-trace
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R02/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
article_outline: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# 专家型 Agentic 运行治理
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
`专家型 Agentic 运行治理` 是 `复杂度放置门` 的核心展开对象。它回答：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
当专家工作被 Agentic 化时，如何建模入口、角色、上下文、真实执行、成本、漂移、停止和文档承接。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
project-intake-mode-selector:
|
||||
- R01-U10
|
||||
- R01-U13
|
||||
- R01-U14
|
||||
- R01-U15
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R04-U07
|
||||
- R04-U08
|
||||
execution-authenticity:
|
||||
- R01-U03
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U04
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R03-U08
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
- R04-U10
|
||||
scope-drift-stop-rule:
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R03-U10
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R04-U11
|
||||
human-gate-authority-trace:
|
||||
- R04-U13
|
||||
context-compiler-crosslink:
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R04-U12
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Reusable Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 Project Intake / Mode Selector
|
||||
|
||||
入口分诊同时判断：
|
||||
|
||||
- Q / P / I。
|
||||
- 内容产出 / 可复用流程 / 治理级系统 / 校准实验 / 探索预演。
|
||||
- 一次性任务 / 可复用能力建设 / 生产环境交付。
|
||||
- Lite / Standard / Full。
|
||||
|
||||
默认策略：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Default Light, Escalate by Evidence.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 Execution Authenticity
|
||||
|
||||
正式 Agentic 输出必须有可追溯执行证据：
|
||||
|
||||
- 谁被调用。
|
||||
- 使用哪个 canonical prompt。
|
||||
- 读取哪些输入。
|
||||
- 输出什么 returned-output。
|
||||
- 主会话如何整合。
|
||||
- 哪些进入正式 synthesis。
|
||||
- 哪些只是 simulation-only。
|
||||
|
||||
主会话可以 orchestration / routing / synthesis / bounded verification，不得冒充独立 Agent、Worker、Auditor。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 Scope Drift / Stop Rule
|
||||
|
||||
Scope Drift 信号：
|
||||
|
||||
- 内容任务开始设计 Agent / Skill / Runtime / Protocol。
|
||||
- 一次性任务开始设计复用目录和通用标准。
|
||||
- 开始讨论 invocation、handoff、authority、state、audit。
|
||||
- 原始产物被中间流程持续推迟。
|
||||
|
||||
Stop Rule 必须在 Runtime 启动前定义：
|
||||
|
||||
- 最小可用产物。
|
||||
- optional 产物。
|
||||
- 升级后才生成的产物。
|
||||
- sufficient 条件。
|
||||
- 人类决策等待点。
|
||||
- 禁止自动扩展条件。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.4 Human Gate / Authority / Trace
|
||||
|
||||
Human gate 不是自动化失败，而是专家系统接口。适合后续 Handbook 扩展：
|
||||
|
||||
- decision_id
|
||||
- owner
|
||||
- 输入和选项
|
||||
- 采纳 / 拒绝
|
||||
- 理由
|
||||
- 下游影响
|
||||
- 回滚条件
|
||||
|
||||
Authority Matrix 应回答谁能观察、建议、起草、修改、决定、执行、阻断。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.5 Context Compiler Cross-Link
|
||||
|
||||
Context Compiler 暂不升核心 topic，只作 cross-link。它连接：
|
||||
|
||||
- whole-source gestalt。
|
||||
- premise-context-pack。
|
||||
- role-specific dispatch pack。
|
||||
- source digest。
|
||||
- Fidelity Ladder。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要：
|
||||
|
||||
- 把 governance 写成多 Agent 越多越好。
|
||||
- 把 `Agent Invocation Packet` 等机制升成父主题。
|
||||
- 把 Context Compiler 抽成模型资产。
|
||||
- 直接写 Handbook 正文章节。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
- 默认轻量
|
||||
- 真实执行
|
||||
- 任务漂移
|
||||
- 停止权
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
- Project Intake
|
||||
- Mode Selector
|
||||
- Execution Authenticity
|
||||
- Scope Drift
|
||||
- Stop Rule
|
||||
- later: Human Gate / Authority Matrix / Context Compiler
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
- 专家工作被 Agentic 化时，隐性判断被迫显性化
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,144 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 04-hifi-studio-patch
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- hifi-agent-studio-principles
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
formal_hifi_patch: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# HiFi Agent Studio：纲领补丁素材
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
本 topic doc 只整理 HiFi Agent Studio 的纲领补丁素材，不改写正式 HiFi Agent Studio 文档。
|
||||
|
||||
用户已确认最小补丁先限定为五条原则：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. 默认轻量
|
||||
2. 真实执行
|
||||
3. 成本分账
|
||||
4. 任务漂移
|
||||
5. 停止权
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
hifi-agent-studio-principles:
|
||||
- R03-U03
|
||||
- R03-U09
|
||||
- R04-U02
|
||||
- R04-U03
|
||||
- R04-U04
|
||||
- R04-U05
|
||||
- R04-U06
|
||||
- R04-U15
|
||||
- R05-U03
|
||||
- R05-U06
|
||||
- R05-U07
|
||||
- R05-U08
|
||||
- R05-U09
|
||||
- R05-U12
|
||||
- R05-U14
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### High-Value Cross-Linked Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
project_intake_and_mode:
|
||||
- R04-U07
|
||||
- R04-U08
|
||||
cost_and_execution:
|
||||
- R04-U09
|
||||
- R04-U10
|
||||
scope_and_stop:
|
||||
- R04-U11
|
||||
documentation_layering:
|
||||
- R05-U02
|
||||
- R05-U05
|
||||
- R05-U16
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Reusable Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 默认轻量，证据驱动升级
|
||||
|
||||
纲领层应保留原则句，不保留完整表格：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
默认采用最轻可用结构；只有风险、复用、追踪、协作或下游依赖提供证据时，才升级到更重 Runtime。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 正式产物必须真实执行
|
||||
|
||||
纲领层保留底线：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Formal Agentic Output Must Be Real.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
具体 invocation 字段、simulation-only 标记和 excluded-from-synthesis 规则下放 Handbook。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 内容成本与系统建设成本必须分账
|
||||
|
||||
纲领层保留：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
禁止将系统建设成本伪装为单次内容任务成本。
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.4 任务漂移必须重定性
|
||||
|
||||
当内容任务开始设计 Agent、Skill、Runtime、Protocol、Evaluation、Invocation 标准时，必须触发 drift review。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.5 系统必须拥有停止权
|
||||
|
||||
系统启动前必须定义 sufficient 条件，不因为还能生成 audit、handoff、topic docs、review、prompt、protocol 就继续运行。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Related But Not Core For First Patch
|
||||
|
||||
这些可保留为后续补丁或 cross-link：
|
||||
|
||||
- QPI Drift。
|
||||
- Production Workshop。
|
||||
- Separate Role from Model / Agent / Skill / Runtime。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Context Compiler。
|
||||
- Expert Attention Budget。
|
||||
- Production Boundary。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要：
|
||||
|
||||
- 把 R04/R05 的 GPT 补丁清单全部塞回 Studio 纲领。
|
||||
- 写正式 HiFi Agent Studio V2.1 正文。
|
||||
- 创建模型资产。
|
||||
- 把 Production Workshop 扩展为 video-workbench topic。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
status: primary
|
||||
use: "作为后续正式补丁讨论和改写的素材层。"
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
status: secondary
|
||||
use: "将操作表格、模板、字段和阻断条件下放。"
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
status: secondary
|
||||
use: "用于说明纲领稳定、守则可变。"
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,172 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 05-agentic-handbook-materials
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- agentic-handbook-operating-law
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
formal_handbook: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# Agentic Handbook：第一版守则素材
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
本 topic doc 只整理 Agentic Handbook 的原始素材，不撰写正式 Handbook。
|
||||
|
||||
用户已确认第一版先按六组组织：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Project Intake
|
||||
2. Mode Selector
|
||||
3. Cost Ledger
|
||||
4. Execution Authenticity
|
||||
5. Scope Drift
|
||||
6. Stop Rule
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
同时保留边界：这六组只是原始素材组织方式，不是唯一素材，也不代表 Handbook 最终只包含这六组。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
agentic-handbook-operating-law:
|
||||
- R05-U10
|
||||
- R05-U13
|
||||
- R05-U15
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### High-Value Cross-Linked Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
project_intake_mode_selector:
|
||||
- R01-U13
|
||||
- R01-U14
|
||||
- R02-U13
|
||||
- R02-U14
|
||||
- R04-U07
|
||||
- R04-U08
|
||||
cost_ledger:
|
||||
- R01-U09
|
||||
- R02-U15
|
||||
- R04-U09
|
||||
- R05-U09
|
||||
execution_authenticity:
|
||||
- R02-U03
|
||||
- R02-U08
|
||||
- R03-U11
|
||||
- R04-U10
|
||||
scope_drift_stop_rule:
|
||||
- R03-U12
|
||||
- R04-U11
|
||||
- R05-U14
|
||||
expansion_material:
|
||||
- R04-U12
|
||||
- R04-U13
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. First-Pass Handbook Groups
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 Project Intake
|
||||
|
||||
开工前判断：
|
||||
|
||||
- Q / P / I。
|
||||
- 内容产出 / 系统建设 / 校准 / 探索。
|
||||
- 一次性产物 / 可复用流程 / 治理级系统。
|
||||
- 下游是否依赖过程真实性。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 Mode Selector
|
||||
|
||||
默认从 Lite 开始。
|
||||
|
||||
升级 Standard / Full 需要证据：
|
||||
|
||||
- 多来源 / 异构源。
|
||||
- 高风险或发布关键。
|
||||
- 多角色独立判断。
|
||||
- 下游自动化依赖 routing。
|
||||
- 用户明确要求构建可复用 workflow。
|
||||
- Lite / Standard 已失败。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 Cost Ledger
|
||||
|
||||
模板至少要区分：
|
||||
|
||||
- Content Cost。
|
||||
- System-Building Cost。
|
||||
- Calibration Cost。
|
||||
- Exploration Cost。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.4 Execution Authenticity
|
||||
|
||||
正式产物必须记录：
|
||||
|
||||
- canonical prompt。
|
||||
- input context。
|
||||
- carrier / thread_id。
|
||||
- returned-output。
|
||||
- main-session integration boundary。
|
||||
- simulation-only / excluded-from-synthesis 状态。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.5 Scope Drift
|
||||
|
||||
触发 drift review 的信号：
|
||||
|
||||
- 原任务开始创建通用 protocol。
|
||||
- 开始派发多个 worker / committee。
|
||||
- 一次性任务开始设计复用目录。
|
||||
- 原始产物被中间流程推迟。
|
||||
- 成本超过原任务规模且未拆账。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.6 Stop Rule
|
||||
|
||||
启动前定义：
|
||||
|
||||
- 最小可用产物。
|
||||
- optional 产物。
|
||||
- sufficient 条件。
|
||||
- 不自动扩展条件。
|
||||
- 人类等待点。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Expansion Materials, Not First-Pass Core
|
||||
|
||||
以下材料可作为后续扩展项：
|
||||
|
||||
- Authority Matrix。
|
||||
- Artifact Contract。
|
||||
- Simulation Labeling。
|
||||
- Human Gate Design。
|
||||
- Context Compiler。
|
||||
- Evaluation Stack。
|
||||
- Runtime Maturity Model。
|
||||
- Platform Adapters。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要：
|
||||
|
||||
- 把 Handbook 写成哲学纲领。
|
||||
- 把六组守则当作最终唯一目录。
|
||||
- 创建正式 Handbook 文件。
|
||||
- 创建 CCPE assets 或 model assets。
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
status: primary
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
status: secondary
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
status: supporting
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -0,0 +1,178 @@
|
|||
---
|
||||
topic_doc_id: 06-document-layering-and-carryover
|
||||
run_id: 2026-06-12-复杂度放置门
|
||||
topic_ids:
|
||||
- document-layering
|
||||
- ccpe-system-forge
|
||||
- project-runbook-local-procedure
|
||||
- context-compiler-crosslink
|
||||
- production-workshop-crosslink
|
||||
- article-8-material-direction
|
||||
- archival-context
|
||||
source_basis:
|
||||
- 01-topic-map.md
|
||||
- 02-material-routing-log.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R01/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R03/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R04/returned-output.md
|
||||
- invocations/broad-fidelity-workers/R05/returned-output.md
|
||||
integration_mode: main_session_integration_from_worker_outputs
|
||||
primary_source_re_read: false
|
||||
model_asset: false
|
||||
article_outline: false
|
||||
downstream_handoff: false
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
# 文档承接层与候选材料
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Topic Role
|
||||
|
||||
本 topic doc 保留文档分层、工程承接、候选 cross-link 和第 8 篇文章素材方向。它不创建下游文档、不创建文章提纲、不创建 handoff。
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Source Material Layer
|
||||
|
||||
### Primary Routed Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
document-layering:
|
||||
- R05-U01
|
||||
- R05-U02
|
||||
- R05-U04
|
||||
- R05-U05
|
||||
- R05-U11
|
||||
- R05-U16
|
||||
ccpe-system-forge:
|
||||
- R01-U05
|
||||
- R01-U06
|
||||
- R01-U07
|
||||
article-8-material-direction:
|
||||
- R02-U16
|
||||
- R03-U02
|
||||
- R03-U04
|
||||
- R03-U05
|
||||
- R03-U18
|
||||
- R04-U01
|
||||
context-compiler-crosslink:
|
||||
- R02-U02
|
||||
- R03-U13
|
||||
- R04-U12
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
### Cross-Link / Context Units
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
project_runbook_context:
|
||||
- R01-U02
|
||||
- R01-U03
|
||||
- R01-U04
|
||||
- R02-U05
|
||||
- R05-U02
|
||||
- R05-U05
|
||||
- R05-U11
|
||||
- R05-U13
|
||||
- R05-U16
|
||||
production_workshop:
|
||||
- R03-U01
|
||||
- R03-U06
|
||||
- R03-U14
|
||||
- R04-U01
|
||||
- R04-U14
|
||||
- R05-U07
|
||||
archival_context:
|
||||
- R04-U02
|
||||
- R04-U03
|
||||
- R04-U04
|
||||
- R04-U05
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Reusable Material Units
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.1 Four-Layer Document System
|
||||
|
||||
R05 的分层建议：
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
HiFi Agent Studio = 纲领 / 心智模型 / 方法论宪法
|
||||
HiFi Agentic Engineering Handbook = Agentic 使用手册 / 工程守则 / 开工规程
|
||||
CCPE System = Agent / Skill / Runtime / Model Card 建造工坊
|
||||
Project Runbook = writing-workbench、knowledge-vault 等具体项目规程
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
本 run 只把它作为承接结构，不创建这些下游文档。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.2 CCPE System As Forge
|
||||
|
||||
CCPE System 在本材料中的角色是建造工坊：
|
||||
|
||||
- Prompt
|
||||
- Agent
|
||||
- Skill
|
||||
- Runtime
|
||||
- Model Card
|
||||
- Model Index
|
||||
- Evaluation
|
||||
- Tool / Workflow / Hybrid
|
||||
|
||||
本 run 不创建 CCPE assets 或 model cards。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.3 Context Compiler Cross-Link
|
||||
|
||||
Context Compiler 连接多个实践：
|
||||
|
||||
- whole-source gestalt。
|
||||
- premise-context-pack。
|
||||
- role-specific dispatch pack。
|
||||
- article model digest。
|
||||
- public-topic framing pack。
|
||||
|
||||
它暂不升为核心 topic，也不创建模型资产。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.4 Production Workshop Cross-Link
|
||||
|
||||
Production Workshop 只作为分类材料：
|
||||
|
||||
- 位于逻辑轮机与战略透镜之间。
|
||||
- 对应 P 为主、少量 I 的内容 / 素材生产链。
|
||||
- 可解释降维输出流程为什么适合先做 Agentic MVP。
|
||||
|
||||
不创建 `video-workbench` topic。
|
||||
|
||||
### 3.5 Article 8 Material Direction
|
||||
|
||||
第 8 篇文章只保留素材方向：
|
||||
|
||||
- ROI 怪异感。
|
||||
- 像真的但不是真的。
|
||||
- 真的但太贵。
|
||||
- 实验室 vs 生产线。
|
||||
- 纲领稳定、守则可变。
|
||||
|
||||
不创建正式文章提纲。
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Anti-Scope
|
||||
|
||||
不要：
|
||||
|
||||
- 创建 HiFi 正文补丁。
|
||||
- 创建 Agentic Handbook 正文。
|
||||
- 创建 CCPE asset。
|
||||
- 创建 writing-workbench handoff。
|
||||
- 创建 article outline。
|
||||
- 创建 video-workbench topic。
|
||||
- 把 Context Compiler 或 Production Workshop 升为核心 topic。
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Downstream Use
|
||||
|
||||
```yaml
|
||||
hifi_patch_material:
|
||||
- four-layer document system
|
||||
- Studio as principles layer
|
||||
handbook_material:
|
||||
- Handbook as operating law
|
||||
- project runbook inheritance
|
||||
article_8_material:
|
||||
- document layering as complexity placement
|
||||
archival_context:
|
||||
- existing HiFi V2.0 and article-series background
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
|
|
@ -56,16 +56,18 @@ Human confirmation artifacts must primarily use the source primary language unle
|
|||
## 5. Human Gates
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
Gate 1: Confirm workspace path.
|
||||
Gate 2: Confirm source block convention.
|
||||
Gate 3: Confirm Step 0 gestalt alignment, macro-topic split, or recorded exception.
|
||||
Gate 4: Confirm candidate topic-map / topic hierarchy.
|
||||
Gate 5: Confirm material routing.
|
||||
Gate 6: Confirm topic docs / extracted material usefulness.
|
||||
Gate 7: Confirm audit repair strategy.
|
||||
Gate 8: Confirm downstream routing.
|
||||
Setup checks: workspace path, source block convention, source-primary language, and invocation carrier.
|
||||
|
||||
Gate 1: Confirm Step 0 gestalt alignment, macro-topic split, or recorded exception.
|
||||
Gate 2: Confirm candidate topic-map / topic hierarchy before topic expansion.
|
||||
Gate 3: Confirm topic docs / extracted material usefulness before downstream handoff, source-disposable claims, or repair decisions.
|
||||
Gate 4: Confirm downstream routing only when the downstream target, scope, or receiving workbench is not already covered by prior user instruction.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not add a human gate merely to ask whether the workflow may enter the next mechanical stage. A human gate is required only when the user must answer substantive questions: hierarchy, scope, downstream boundary, usefulness, repair strategy, source-disposable status, or handoff target.
|
||||
|
||||
After Gate 2 confirms the topic hierarchy and expansion boundary, material routing may proceed as the mechanical implementation of that confirmed structure. Create `02-material-routing-log.md` without a separate "start material routing?" prompt unless new unresolved decisions appear.
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Acceptance Criteria
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -55,6 +55,25 @@ If the source is too large for one gestalt pass, record the exception and use a
|
|||
3. source block batches when a section is too large
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 3.1 Default ChatGPT Discussion Boundary Rule
|
||||
|
||||
When a source is a copied ChatGPT discussion draft and the user says the top-level numeric headings represent conversation rounds, use numeric Markdown H1 headings as the default round boundary:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
round_heading_pattern: ^#\s+\d+\s*$
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Do not treat non-numeric H1 headings inside a round as new conversation rounds. They may be user-authored material headings or GPT-authored document headings.
|
||||
|
||||
When `## GPT` appears inside a numeric round, treat it as the start of the GPT response for that round:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
# N -> before ## GPT: user input / source material for round N
|
||||
## GPT -> before next numeric # N+1: GPT response for round N
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
If a numeric round contains additional H1 headings such as article titles, draft section titles, product names, or method names, keep them as intra-round content. Record the distinction in `00-source-map.md` before Step 0 or segmentation.
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Worker Input
|
||||
|
||||
Each worker gets:
|
||||
|
|
@ -106,6 +125,36 @@ The main session must also verify language readiness before presenting a human c
|
|||
|
||||
The main session must not be the primary extractor for topic-doc material units when the workflow requires a CCPE Skill / worker participant. Main-session extraction, routing, or topic-doc drafting may be kept only as simulation-only or reference material, and must be excluded from formal synthesis.
|
||||
|
||||
## 6.1 Model Extraction Prerequisite
|
||||
|
||||
Do not promote discussion-draft concepts into formal model assets merely because a participant proposed a useful model name, gate, framework, or operating rule.
|
||||
|
||||
For user-authored model assets, the default prerequisite is:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
discussion material -> user-authored article/body draft -> discussion/orthogonal review -> model extraction
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
Before that prerequisite is satisfied, workers may mark items as:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
article_material
|
||||
handbook_material
|
||||
system_patch_material
|
||||
candidate_concept
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
They must not create or imply:
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
model_card
|
||||
canonical_model_asset
|
||||
model_index_entry
|
||||
model_mining_completion
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
This rule prevents bias from extracting directly from one GPT proposal before the user's正文, argument structure, and orthogonal review have stabilized the concept.
|
||||
|
||||
## 7. Continuation Rule
|
||||
|
||||
Create a continuation handoff after each major pass or before any expected context pressure.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -21,7 +21,6 @@ main_session_primary_extraction_allowed: false
|
|||
human_confirmation_required_before:
|
||||
- accepting_whole_source_gestalt_as_worker_lens
|
||||
- final_topic_map
|
||||
- material_routing
|
||||
- accepting_topic_docs_for_downstream_use
|
||||
- source_disposable_claim
|
||||
- writing_workbench_handoff
|
||||
|
|
@ -121,6 +120,8 @@ It must be backed by one of:
|
|||
|
||||
The main session may format and index the graph, but it must not invent hierarchy that is not present in Step 0, worker returns, or user corrections.
|
||||
|
||||
After the user confirms the candidate topic hierarchy and any unresolved expansion boundaries, material routing is not a separate human-confirmation gate. It is the mechanical implementation of the confirmed topic graph. Pause again only if routing exposes new user-level decisions, such as merge/split conflicts, downstream scope changes, source-disposable claims, or handoff targets.
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Topic Docs Human Confirmation Contract
|
||||
|
||||
After worker-backed topic docs and material extraction are generated, record:
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
|
|
@ -97,8 +97,8 @@ Local Skill execution is valid only when the canonical Skill artifact is read an
|
|||
4. Prepare prompt-to-send.md if the participant is external.
|
||||
5. Stop if real invocation is unavailable.
|
||||
6. Save returned output with metadata.
|
||||
7. Draft 01-topic-map.md from accepted returned output.
|
||||
8. Pause for user confirmation.
|
||||
7. Draft a candidate topic hierarchy or `01-topic-map.md` from accepted returned output.
|
||||
8. Pause only when substantive hierarchy, scope, merge/split, or downstream-boundary questions need user judgment before topic expansion.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Topic Graph Synthesis And Human Confirmation
|
||||
|
|
@ -107,8 +107,8 @@ Local Skill execution is valid only when the canonical Skill artifact is read an
|
|||
1. Dispatch `topic-graph-synthesizer`, or write a synthesis-record that only integrates file-backed worker outputs.
|
||||
2. Preserve distinctions among parent topic, subtopic, tool, layer, case, action track, and model upgrade.
|
||||
3. Compare the synthesized hierarchy against the whole-source gestalt output.
|
||||
4. Record unresolved hierarchy risks before routing.
|
||||
5. Pause for user confirmation before material routing.
|
||||
4. Record unresolved hierarchy risks before topic expansion.
|
||||
5. If the candidate hierarchy contains unresolved user-level decisions, pause with the specific questions to answer. Do not pause merely to ask whether material routing may start.
|
||||
```
|
||||
|
||||
For coherent sources, the synthesizer receives the user-confirmed Step 0 lens and worker exceptions. It should not rediscover the structure from zero. Gate 3 human-review output must primarily use `source_primary_language`.
|
||||
|
|
@ -116,14 +116,14 @@ For coherent sources, the synthesizer receives the user-confirmed Step 0 lens an
|
|||
## 7. Evidence Routing And Topic Docs
|
||||
|
||||
```text
|
||||
1. Confirm topic-map.
|
||||
1. Use the confirmed topic hierarchy as the routing structure.
|
||||
2. Assign each topic or topic group to an evidence-routing-and-topic-doc-builder worker/sub-session.
|
||||
3. Give each worker the confirmed topic graph, assigned source ranges or source block IDs, required output schema, and Step 0 distortion guardrails.
|
||||
4. Collect returned outputs or skill-execution records.
|
||||
5. Write 02-material-routing-log.md from returned outputs.
|
||||
6. Generate topic docs with source material layer, source index, and reusable material units from returned outputs.
|
||||
7. The main session may integrate returned outputs, update indexes, and perform bounded verification; it should not do the primary extraction over source material when worker/sub-session execution is available.
|
||||
8. Ask the user to inspect the topic docs / material extraction layer before downstream handoff.
|
||||
8. Ask the user to inspect the topic docs / material extraction layer before downstream handoff, source-disposable claims, or repair decisions.
|
||||
9. If the user accepts the topic docs, record a Topic Docs Human Confirmation.
|
||||
10. If the user corrects extraction or topic contents, run a repair pass or write an explicit human-correction record.
|
||||
11. Do not declare completion until coverage audit is accepted.
|
||||
|
|
|
|||
Loading…
Reference in New Issue