# Round 04 Blind Routing Evaluation Report Date: 2026-06-18 Blind input set: `round04_blind_inputs_2026-06-18_v0.1` Expected routing labels: `not included before first blind run` This report records current selector routing only. It does not score correctness, does not generate final answers, does not modify selector rules, and does not upgrade model status. ## Scope - Round 04 target: test routing stability on new inputs. - Runtime surface: current rule-based selector plus model-level QPI / IA gates. - QPI contract status: represented here by QPI selection and routing details; no full QPI answer generation is performed. - IA status: represented here by selector selection / rejection only; no Intellectual Archaeology answer generation is performed. ## Summary Inputs evaluated: 38 No-call results: 20 ### Selected Model Distribution - `intellectual_archaeology`: 3 - `none`: 20 - `qpi`: 18 ### Coverage Categories - `ambiguous_growth_how_to`: 1 - `ambiguous_low_context`: 3 - `capacity_resource_path`: 4 - `direct_execution_with_analysis_override`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_dictionary_judgment`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_direct_execution`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_fact_lookup`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_formatting`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_how_to`: 2 - `explicit_no_call_rewrite`: 1 - `explicit_no_call_translation`: 1 - `governance_responsibility_consensus`: 4 - `likely_intellectual_archaeology`: 4 - `model_extraction_or_depth_modeling`: 3 - `qpi_allowed_depth_limited`: 2 - `qpi_allowed_ia_refused`: 4 - `qpi_light_problem_definition`: 4 ## Case Results ### R04-BI-001 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_fact_lookup` - input_text: `查一下《原则》这本书的作者是谁，只要事实，不要分析。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 只要事实、查一下 - `qpi` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 只要事实、查一下 ### R04-BI-002 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_translation` - input_text: `把这句话翻译成英文：这个模型还处在草稿阶段。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 模型; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 模型; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-003 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_rewrite` - input_text: `请把这段话润色得更顺一点，不要改变意思，也不要解释原因。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 润色 - `qpi` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 润色 ### R04-BI-004 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_formatting` - input_text: `把下面这组要点整理成 Markdown 表格，直接给结果。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-005 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_direct_execution` - input_text: `把这个 JSON 压缩成单行，不用说明：{"status":"draft","level":"B"}` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-006 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_light_problem_definition` - input_text: `我们现在反复开会但没有推进，我想先判断这是缺信息、缺路径，还是缺共识。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.99 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 缺路径、缺共识; complexity signal: 反复、共识; selection_priority=9; QPI problem-definition gate matched Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 反复、共识; selection_priority=7 - penalties: QPI-before-IA gate: 缺路径、缺共识; no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-007 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_light_problem_definition` - input_text: `这个项目卡住了，我不确定到底是问题没定义清楚，还是执行方案不够。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.59 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-008 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_light_problem_definition` - input_text: `我们有一堆材料，但不知道下一步该问什么问题，先帮我定性一下。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.59 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-009 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_light_problem_definition` - input_text: `这件事到底算一个简单问题、复杂问题，还是已经变成组织议题？` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.89 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; input type matched: 复杂问题; complexity signal: 组织、复杂; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.32 decision=rejected - reasons: input type matched: 复杂问题; complexity signal: 组织、复杂; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-010 - category_for_owner_review: `governance_responsibility_consensus` - input_text: `每个部门都说支持这个项目，但一到分工就没人愿意承担主责。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-011 - category_for_owner_review: `governance_responsibility_consensus` - input_text: `老板要创新，财务要控成本，业务要短期业绩，最后方案总是被折中到没有方向。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-012 - category_for_owner_review: `governance_responsibility_consensus` - input_text: `我们不是不知道怎么做，而是每个人都在等别人先表态。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-013 - category_for_owner_review: `governance_responsibility_consensus` - input_text: `这个流程改造牵涉教务、学院和信息化部门，谁都能提意见，但没人能拍板。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-014 - category_for_owner_review: `capacity_resource_path` - input_text: `团队现在知道目标，也认可方向，但只有两个人能做关键模块，进度一直被产能卡住。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-015 - category_for_owner_review: `capacity_resource_path` - input_text: `我们知道要做知识库，也有材料，但不知道从哪条最小路径开始。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-016 - category_for_owner_review: `capacity_resource_path` - input_text: `预算不是最大问题，问题是现有系统、权限和审批流程都接不上。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.74 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 系统; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 系统; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-017 - category_for_owner_review: `capacity_resource_path` - input_text: `这件事大家都觉得重要，但每周只能挤出零散时间，所以一直没有稳定产出。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-018 - category_for_owner_review: `model_extraction_or_depth_modeling` - control_case_type: `positive_control` - input_text: `请从这篇长文里抽取一个可复用的认知模型，重点看它的核心机制和适用边界。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 模型、机制、抽取、边界; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 模型、机制、抽取、边界; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-019 - category_for_owner_review: `model_extraction_or_depth_modeling` - input_text: `这套说法背后好像有一个稳定结构，不只是观点总结，帮我判断它能不能沉淀成模型。` - selected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - rejected_models: `[]` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 模型、结构; selection_priority=9 - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.42 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 沉淀成模型; complexity signal: 模型、结构; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate Rejected model details: - none ### R04-BI-020 - category_for_owner_review: `model_extraction_or_depth_modeling` - input_text: `我想把这段讨论拆成原始判断、隐含假设、适用条件和误用边界。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 边界; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 边界; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-021 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_ia_refused` - control_case_type: `model_name_exposed` - input_text: `先不要思想考古，只判断这是不是一个 QPI 意义上的问题。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.59 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 思想考古; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 思想考古 - penalties: negative trigger: 不要思想考古、先不要思想考古; model hard exclusion signal: 不要思想考古、先不要思想考古 ### R04-BI-022 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_ia_refused` - input_text: `不要展开到底层假设，只帮我看主导稀缺是什么。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开 - `qpi` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开 ### R04-BI-023 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_ia_refused` - input_text: `这次先不做深度建模，只做问题定性，看它是缺数据、缺路径还是缺共识。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.99 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题、缺数据、缺路径、缺共识; complexity signal: 共识; selection_priority=9; QPI problem-definition gate matched Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 共识; selection_priority=7 - penalties: QPI-before-IA gate: 缺数据、缺路径、缺共识; no IA heavy-depth gate; model hard exclusion signal: 只做问题定性 ### R04-BI-024 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_ia_refused` - input_text: `不要进入思想考古，我只要一个轻量判断：现在应该先问问题、找路径，还是处理责任边界？` - selected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - rejected_models: `[]` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.97 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 思想考古; complexity signal: 边界、责任; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 思想考古 - `qpi` score=0.74 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 边界、责任; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - none ### R04-BI-025 - category_for_owner_review: `likely_intellectual_archaeology` - control_case_type: `model_name_exposed` - input_text: `QPI 已经判断这是中重型课题，现在请继续分析它背后的底层假设、生成机制和长期稳定结构。` - selected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - rejected_models: `[]` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.97 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 底层假设; complexity signal: 长期、底层、结构、机制; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 底层假设 - `qpi` score=0.74 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 课题; complexity signal: 长期、底层、结构、机制; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - none ### R04-BI-026 - category_for_owner_review: `likely_intellectual_archaeology` - input_text: `这个现象反复出现在不同项目里，我想知道它背后的思想结构是什么，而不是只做问题分类。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.74 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 反复、结构; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 反复、结构; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-027 - category_for_owner_review: `likely_intellectual_archaeology` - input_text: `请分析这套判断为什么会长期成立，它依赖哪些世界观、因果假设和行动边界。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 长期、边界; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 长期、边界; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-028 - category_for_owner_review: `ambiguous_low_context` - input_text: `这个不太对。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-029 - category_for_owner_review: `ambiguous_low_context` - input_text: `怎么又卡住了？` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-030 - category_for_owner_review: `ambiguous_low_context` - input_text: `还是那个老问题。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.59 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-031 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_how_to` - input_text: `如何在 Excel 里冻结首行？` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-032 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_how_to` - input_text: `怎么把 Markdown 文件转成 PDF？` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-033 - category_for_owner_review: `explicit_no_call_dictionary_judgment` - input_text: `判断一下“alignment”在这句话里是什么意思。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-034 - category_for_owner_review: `direct_execution_with_analysis_override` - input_text: `请把下面内容总结成三点，但不要只执行，先判断它背后的问题定义。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.59 decision=selected - reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-035 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_depth_limited` - input_text: `不要深入分析，只判断这件事的主导稀缺是什么。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要深入分析 - `qpi` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要深入分析 ### R04-BI-036 - category_for_owner_review: `qpi_allowed_depth_limited` - input_text: `不要展开到底层理论，只判断现在是缺信息、缺路径还是缺共识。` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开 - `qpi` score=0.0 decision=rejected - penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开 ### R04-BI-037 - category_for_owner_review: `ambiguous_growth_how_to` - input_text: `如何提高这个账号的流量？` - selected_models: `[]` - rejected_models: `['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `True` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - none Rejected model details: - `qpi` score=0.09 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=9 - penalties: QPI positive signal missing - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.02 decision=rejected - reasons: selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ### R04-BI-038 - category_for_owner_review: `likely_intellectual_archaeology` - input_text: `这类失败在不同项目里反复出现，我想抽出它背后稳定的生成机制和可迁移框架。` - selected_models: `['qpi']` - rejected_models: `['intellectual_archaeology']` - no_call: `False` - routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation. Selected model details: - `qpi` score=0.49 decision=selected - reasons: complexity signal: 反复、机制; selection_priority=9 Rejected model details: - `intellectual_archaeology` score=0.17 decision=rejected - reasons: complexity signal: 反复、机制; selection_priority=7 - penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate ## Review Reminder This is the first blind routing output. Failure labels, expected routing, and rule changes should be added only after owner / GPT / CCRA review of these observed results.