the-mindscape-of-bro-tsong/sources/evidence_coverage.matrix.json

93 lines
13 KiB
JSON

{
"matrix_version": "0.2",
"last_updated": "2026-06-16",
"support_type_values": [
"direct_source",
"derived_from_source",
"product_decision",
"red_team_inference",
"owner_decision"
],
"coverage_status_values": [
"supported",
"partially_supported",
"derived",
"unsupported",
"needs_owner_review"
],
"models": [
{
"model_id": "qpi",
"field_coverage": [
{"field": "model_id", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Machine ID chosen for local registry."},
{"field": "model_name", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "QPI name and Q/P/I taxonomy are source-backed."},
{"field": "model_type", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_cognitive_os_application_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Routing role is productized from problem-definition placement."},
{"field": "pipeline_position", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_cognitive_os_application_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Pre-analysis position follows cognitive OS application rule."},
{"field": "one_sentence_definition", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Core scarcity and Q/P/I distinction are direct source claims."},
{"field": "core_question", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_question_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_problem_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_issue_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Question is derived from the scarcity scan."},
{"field": "core_mechanism", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_question_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_problem_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_issue_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Scarcity scan and classification are directly supported."},
{"field": "status", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Current draft state is a review decision, not a source claim."},
{"field": "source_articles", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Article records exist in source_articles.json."},
{"field": "source_evidence", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Excerpt records exist in source_excerpts.json."},
{"field": "input_types", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001", "excerpt_qpi_cognitive_os_application_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Input classes are productized from source scenarios."},
{"field": "output_types", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Structured output fields are product contract additions."},
{"field": "call_when", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001", "excerpt_qpi_cognitive_os_application_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Call rules are derived from classification use."},
{"field": "do_not_call_when", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_question_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "No-call rules protect simple retrieval and direct execution."},
{"field": "trigger_keywords", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Selector keywords are local routing rules."},
{"field": "negative_triggers", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Negative triggers are selector false-positive protections."},
{"field": "related_models", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Relationship to IA is a local pipeline decision."},
{"field": "conflicting_models", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "No explicit conflict model is in scope."},
{"field": "disciplinary_anchors", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001"], "coverage_status": "partially_supported", "notes": "Anchors are inferred from the article's conceptual domain."},
{"field": "common_misuses", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_pathology_reduction_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_pathology_inflation_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Violent reduction and malicious inflation have source support."},
{"field": "failure_modes", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_pathology_reduction_001", "excerpt_qpi_primary_pathology_inflation_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Failure modes are operationalized from pathology claims."},
{"field": "selection_priority", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Priority is a selector tuning choice."},
{"field": "confidence_level", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Current medium confidence is review judgment."},
{"field": "stability_profile", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "B-level stability remains a review judgment."},
{"field": "regression_status", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Pending status is deliberate until stronger regression review."},
{"field": "example_inputs", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Examples are synthetic but aligned with source taxonomy."},
{"field": "example_outputs", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Examples are synthetic structured outputs."},
{"field": "output_contract", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_primary_spectrum_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Output contract turns source mechanism into callable form."},
{"field": "productization_notes", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_qpi_cognitive_os_application_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Product notes are local integration decisions."},
{"field": "version", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Local asset version."},
{"field": "last_updated", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Local asset date."}
]
},
{
"model_id": "intellectual_archaeology",
"field_coverage": [
{"field": "model_id", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Machine ID chosen for local registry."},
{"field": "model_name", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_definition_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Name appears in source."},
{"field": "model_type", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Deep modeling type is a product classification."},
{"field": "pipeline_position", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Deep-analysis placement follows cognitive OS rule."},
{"field": "one_sentence_definition", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_definition_001", "excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Definition and downward excavation are source-backed."},
{"field": "core_question", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_definition_001", "excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Core question derives from the layer-excavation mechanism."},
{"field": "core_mechanism", "support_type": "direct_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Seven-layer mechanism has direct source support."},
{"field": "status", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Current draft state is a review decision."},
{"field": "source_articles", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Article records exist."},
{"field": "source_evidence", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Excerpt records exist."},
{"field": "input_types", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_definition_001", "excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Input classes are productized from modeling-workshop use."},
{"field": "output_types", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Structured output fields are callable contract additions."},
{"field": "call_when", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_resilience_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Call rules follow dynamic resilience and model-depth need."},
{"field": "do_not_call_when", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Minimum-depth rule directly supports no-call boundaries."},
{"field": "trigger_keywords", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Selector keywords are local routing rules."},
{"field": "negative_triggers", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Negative triggers prevent over-deepening."},
{"field": "related_models", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "QPI-before-IA is a local pipeline gate."},
{"field": "conflicting_models", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Fast execution conflict is a local boundary concept."},
{"field": "disciplinary_anchors", "support_type": "derived_from_source", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_definition_001"], "coverage_status": "partially_supported", "notes": "Anchors are inferred from philosophical and modeling language."},
{"field": "common_misuses", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001", "excerpt_ia_primary_validation_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Over-excavation and validation risks are source-backed."},
{"field": "failure_modes", "support_type": "red_team_inference", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001", "excerpt_ia_primary_validation_001"], "coverage_status": "supported", "notes": "Failure signals are operationalized from source warnings."},
{"field": "selection_priority", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Priority is a selector tuning choice."},
{"field": "confidence_level", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Medium confidence is review judgment."},
{"field": "stability_profile", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_resilience_001"], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "B-level stability requires human review despite source support."},
{"field": "regression_status", "support_type": "owner_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "needs_owner_review", "notes": "Pending until regression expansion is reviewed."},
{"field": "example_inputs", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Examples are synthetic."},
{"field": "example_outputs", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Examples are synthetic structured outputs."},
{"field": "output_contract", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_primary_layers_001", "excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Contract turns layer mechanism into bounded callable form."},
{"field": "productization_notes", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": ["excerpt_ia_cognitive_os_minimum_depth_001"], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Product notes are integration decisions."},
{"field": "version", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Local asset version."},
{"field": "last_updated", "support_type": "product_decision", "excerpt_ids": [], "coverage_status": "derived", "notes": "Local asset date."}
]
}
]
}