# S-05 Slide Review V1

## Status

- Slide: `s05`
- Version: `v1`
- Review status: local review complete
- Decision: usable for task-level review
- Main-session reconciliation: the slide-agent return was later corrected because an interrupt caused its original return text to claim generation was blocked even though this image and review had already been written.

## Generation Trace

- Prompt file: `projects/2026-06-23-在路上/slides/s05/s05-v1-prompt.md`
- Required character reference loaded: yes
- Loaded role: `Image 1: identity reference for walking-back traveler`
- Loaded reference path: `projects/2026-06-23-在路上/visual-system/characters/character-anchor-v2-walk-back-reference-crop-tight.png`
- Generation path: host built-in reference-by-visible-context
- Generated host source copied from: `C:\Users\wangq\.codex\generated_images\019ef781-1ff1-7073-80b0-3cf688104cdb\ig_087687f122f488ef016a3b446bd4fc8198bf390912b8aeb494.png`
- Project image path: `projects/2026-06-23-在路上/slides/s05/s05-v1-image.png`
- Project image hash matches the generated host source.
- External review tools: not used

## Local File Check

- `s05-v1-prompt.md`: present
- `s05-v1-image.png`: present
- `s05-v1-review.md`: present

## Local Visual Check

- Back view only: pass.
- Face / turn-back / camera look: pass; no face is visible.
- Backpack continuity: pass; old practical backpack shape, worn texture, and shoulder placement are close to `Image 1`.
- Coat continuity: pass; dark long coat, length, hem, and back silhouette are consistent with the reference.
- Walking-back posture: pass; upright, tired but capable, not collapsed.
- Road/world dominance: pass; muddy road, frost, ruts, and cold wilderness remain a major part of the frame.
- Style module A: pass; cold muddy morning road, low saturation, documentary road-film texture.
- Text / logo / UI / watermark: pass; none visible.

## Acceptance Checklist

- The back/walking-back silhouette plausibly matches the active character reference.
- Old backpack, coat length, shoulder/back posture, and boots are reusable for later shots.
- Traveler looks road-worn but still able to keep walking.
- Environment remains part of the MV language; the image is not a backpack product shot.
- Generation trace records that the actual character reference was visibly loaded as `Image 1`.

## Issues

- Minor watch point: the horizon has a pale warm band. It remains restrained and does not read as postcard sunrise, but later A-module shots should keep warmth similarly limited.
- Minor watch point: the traveler is visually clear and slightly prominent, which is appropriate for this prop-anchor shot but should not become the default scale for wider road shots.

## Decision / Next Action

- Decision: keep as `s05-v1-image.png` for parent task review.
- Next action: parent session can compare this against the other character-consistency slides and decide whether `s05` should be accepted or sampled again.