# S-51 Shot Review V1

## Status

- Document status: user accepted generated candidate.
- Execution status: S-51 image generated once.
- Project: `在路上`.
- Unit: `s51`.
- Source shot: `S-51`.
- Segment / time: Outro / `4:16-4:54`.
- Style anchor: D｜夜路小火 / 远方火点.
- Candidate image: `shot-image-v1.png`.
- Review result: accepted by user.

## Generation Trace

Skill mode check command:

```powershell
node C:\Users\wangq\.agents\skills\gpt-image-2\scripts\check-mode.js --json
```

Skill mode check result:

```json
{
  "mode": "B-or-C",
  "recommendation": "host-or-advisor",
  "garden_mode_enabled": false,
  "has_api_key": false,
  "base_url": "https://api.openai.com/v1",
  "model": "gpt-image-2",
  "env_flag_value": "(unset)",
  "summary": "MODE B / C · 未启用 Garden。若宿主 Agent 自带图像工具（image_generation / dalle / mcp__*image* 等）→ MODE B：把 prompt 交给宿主出图。若宿主无图像工具 → MODE C：仅产出高质量 prompt 给用户。"
}
```

Interpretation:

- Garden local generation was not enabled.
- The host image-generation path was available.
- This generation used `gpt-image-2` Skill Mode B: render prompt through the Skill workflow, then pass the prompt to the host image tool.
- No Garden generation script was called.

Prompt/spec used:

```text
slides/s51/shot-prompt-v1.md
```

Host default output:

```text
C:\Users\wangq\.codex\generated_images\019ef2f7-e630-7303-a0e8-e5e7a86912fc\ig_0f4f5d34b9230f8d016a3a5bfa40b88191a5737a2fb84a499f.png
```

Project copy:

```text
slides/s51/shot-image-v1.png
```

The original host output was left in place.

## Image File Check

Project image path:

```text
C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\video-workbench\projects\2026-06-23-在路上\slides\s51\shot-image-v1.png
```

File size:

```text
1909982 bytes
```

Dimensions:

```text
1672x941
```

Pixel format:

```text
Format24bppRgb
```

Aspect note:

- The image is horizontal and close to 16:9.
- It is not mathematically exact 16:9 because `1672 / 941 = 1.7768`, while exact 16:9 is `1.7777`.
- No crop or resize was applied in this review step.

## Source Alignment

Primary sources checked:

- `slides/s51/shot-brief-v1.md`
- `slides/s51/shot-prompt-v1.md`
- `slides/s47/shot-review-v1.md`
- `intake/阶段五-镜头清单骨架.md`
- `intake/阶段五-核心单镜.md`
- `visual-system/visual-system.md`
- `visual-system/characters/character-identity-lock.md`
- `visual-system/style/style-anchor-board-review-v1.md`
- `slides/five-shot-trial-plan-v1.md`

Reference asset handling:

- Character and style references were read / viewed locally for prompt construction.
- The host image tool was used as a standalone prompt path; explicit image-reference attachment was not available in this run.

## Local Inspection

Local visual inspection:

- The first read is a vast night wilderness road, dark sky, muddy ground, and distant orange fire points.
- The traveler is very small, back-facing, and walking away along the road.
- The near fire is small and low; distant fires are weak signals in the dark.
- Road, sky, and wilderness are visually more important than the traveler.
- No tent, chairs, cookware, picnic setup, visible group, reunion, UI, text, logo, sci-fi, or neon is visible.
- The image keeps the "still on the road" feeling; it does not show arrival or victory.
- Warmth is present but limited to small fire points and local ground reflection.

Watch points:

- The star field is clear and visually attractive. User review should judge whether it stays documentary enough or becomes too pretty.
- The traveler is small enough for the final wide; user review should judge whether he is still readable enough as the accepted road-worn figure.

External vision analysis:

- Not used for this review.
- This review relies on local visual inspection and local file metadata only.

## Acceptance Criteria Review

| Criterion | Assessment | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| First read is road, night, sky, and wilderness | pass for review | Environment dominates. |
| Traveler about 1/20 to 1/12 of frame | pass for review | The figure is very small and not portrait-like. |
| Road remains more important than person | pass for review | The road leads through the frame and carries the image. |
| Far fires suggest others without group | pass for review | Fire points are visible; no people or gathering shown. |
| Warmth real but restrained | pass for review | Firelight stays small and local. |
| No reunion, victory, camping, final destination | pass for review | None visible. |
| Ending feels unfinished but less alone | pass for review | The road continues, with weak distant fires ahead. |

## Decision

User accepted:

```text
slides/s51/shot-image-v1.png
```

The five-shot visual trial can be marked as image-generated and user-accepted.