the-mindscape-of-bro-tsong/docs/CONTENT_STABILIZATION_PROTOCOL.md

Content Stabilization Protocol

Principle

Engineering contract PASS is not content stability.

The validation scripts prove that the model library can be parsed, indexed, and checked. They do not prove that a model is semantically correct, sufficiently evidenced, regression-stable, or safe for broad product use.

Stabilization Gates

A model cannot move beyond draft without these review gates:

1. Evidence review.
2. Content review.
3. Regression review.
4. Selector review.
5. Owner / CCRA review.

Each gate must leave a file-backed result under reports/ or a structured status entry.

Current Model Rule

For this round:

Model ID	Status	Stability	Regression Status
qpi	draft	B	pending
intellectual_archaeology	draft	B	pending

Do not upgrade either model to stable.

Current Non-Goals

This round must not:

• Add a third model.
• Connect a full question-answering system.
• Introduce an LLM selector.
• Introduce a vector database.
• Build frontend or backend product surfaces.
• Change stability_level from B to A.
• Change regression_status from pending to passed.
• Change status from draft to stable.

Draft-Callable Meaning

draft-callable is a review conclusion, not a model JSON status value in v0.2.

It means:

• The model remains status: draft.
• The model has enough structure for controlled review calls.
• Evidence coverage, regression coverage, selector false-positive protection, and content risks are visible.
• The model still requires Owner / CCRA judgment before any stronger state.

Required v0.2 Evidence Types

Field support must be classified as:

• direct_source: directly supported by source text.
• derived_from_source: reasonably inferred from source text.
• product_decision: product or selector rule.
• red_team_inference: misuse, boundary, or failure inference.
• owner_decision: Owner / CCRA judgment.

Required v0.2 Coverage Status

Each required model field must be marked as:

• supported
• partially_supported
• derived
• unsupported
• needs_owner_review

Required Review Status Fields

Content review reports should track:

• engineering_contract_status
• content_review_status
• evidence_review_status
• regression_review_status
• selector_review_status