the-mindscape-of-bro-tsong/reports/Round04_blind_routing_evaluation_report_2026-06-18.md

Round 04 Blind Routing Evaluation Report

Date: 2026-06-18

Blind input set: round04_blind_inputs_2026-06-18_v0.1

Expected routing labels: not included before first blind run

This report records current selector routing only. It does not score correctness, does not generate final answers, does not modify selector rules, and does not upgrade model status.

Scope

• Round 04 target: test routing stability on new inputs.
• Runtime surface: current rule-based selector plus model-level QPI / IA gates.
• QPI contract status: represented here by QPI selection and routing details; no full QPI answer generation is performed.
• IA status: represented here by selector selection / rejection only; no Intellectual Archaeology answer generation is performed.

Summary

Inputs evaluated: 38 No-call results: 20

Selected Model Distribution

• intellectual_archaeology: 3
• none: 20
• qpi: 18

Coverage Categories

• ambiguous_growth_how_to: 1
• ambiguous_low_context: 3
• capacity_resource_path: 4
• direct_execution_with_analysis_override: 1
• explicit_no_call_dictionary_judgment: 1
• explicit_no_call_direct_execution: 1
• explicit_no_call_fact_lookup: 1
• explicit_no_call_formatting: 1
• explicit_no_call_how_to: 2
• explicit_no_call_rewrite: 1
• explicit_no_call_translation: 1
• governance_responsibility_consensus: 4
• likely_intellectual_archaeology: 4
• model_extraction_or_depth_modeling: 3
• qpi_allowed_depth_limited: 2
• qpi_allowed_ia_refused: 4
• qpi_light_problem_definition: 4

Case Results

R04-BI-001

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_fact_lookup
• input_text: 查一下《原则》这本书的作者是谁，只要事实，不要分析。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 只要事实、查一下
• qpi score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 只要事实、查一下

R04-BI-002

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_translation
• input_text: 把这句话翻译成英文：这个模型还处在草稿阶段。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 模型; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 模型; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-003

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_rewrite
• input_text: 请把这段话润色得更顺一点，不要改变意思，也不要解释原因。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 润色
• qpi score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 润色

R04-BI-004

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_formatting
• input_text: 把下面这组要点整理成 Markdown 表格，直接给结果。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-005

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_direct_execution
• input_text: 把这个 JSON 压缩成单行，不用说明：{"status":"draft","level":"B"}
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-006

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_light_problem_definition
• input_text: 我们现在反复开会但没有推进，我想先判断这是缺信息、缺路径，还是缺共识。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.99 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 缺路径、缺共识; complexity signal: 反复、共识; selection_priority=9; QPI problem-definition gate matched

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 反复、共识; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: QPI-before-IA gate: 缺路径、缺共识; no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-007

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_light_problem_definition
• input_text: 这个项目卡住了，我不确定到底是问题没定义清楚，还是执行方案不够。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.59 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-008

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_light_problem_definition
• input_text: 我们有一堆材料，但不知道下一步该问什么问题，先帮我定性一下。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.59 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-009

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_light_problem_definition
• input_text: 这件事到底算一个简单问题、复杂问题，还是已经变成组织议题？
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.89 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; input type matched: 复杂问题; complexity signal: 组织、复杂; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.32 decision=rejected
  • reasons: input type matched: 复杂问题; complexity signal: 组织、复杂; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-010

• category_for_owner_review: governance_responsibility_consensus
• input_text: 每个部门都说支持这个项目，但一到分工就没人愿意承担主责。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-011

• category_for_owner_review: governance_responsibility_consensus
• input_text: 老板要创新，财务要控成本，业务要短期业绩，最后方案总是被折中到没有方向。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-012

• category_for_owner_review: governance_responsibility_consensus
• input_text: 我们不是不知道怎么做，而是每个人都在等别人先表态。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-013

• category_for_owner_review: governance_responsibility_consensus
• input_text: 这个流程改造牵涉教务、学院和信息化部门，谁都能提意见，但没人能拍板。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-014

• category_for_owner_review: capacity_resource_path
• input_text: 团队现在知道目标，也认可方向，但只有两个人能做关键模块，进度一直被产能卡住。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-015

• category_for_owner_review: capacity_resource_path
• input_text: 我们知道要做知识库，也有材料，但不知道从哪条最小路径开始。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-016

• category_for_owner_review: capacity_resource_path
• input_text: 预算不是最大问题，问题是现有系统、权限和审批流程都接不上。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.74 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 系统; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 系统; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-017

• category_for_owner_review: capacity_resource_path
• input_text: 这件事大家都觉得重要，但每周只能挤出零散时间，所以一直没有稳定产出。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-018

• category_for_owner_review: model_extraction_or_depth_modeling
• control_case_type: positive_control
• input_text: 请从这篇长文里抽取一个可复用的认知模型，重点看它的核心机制和适用边界。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 模型、机制、抽取、边界; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 模型、机制、抽取、边界; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-019

• category_for_owner_review: model_extraction_or_depth_modeling
• input_text: 这套说法背后好像有一个稳定结构，不只是观点总结，帮我判断它能不能沉淀成模型。
• selected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• rejected_models: []
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 模型、结构; selection_priority=9
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.42 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 沉淀成模型; complexity signal: 模型、结构; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

Rejected model details:

• none

R04-BI-020

• category_for_owner_review: model_extraction_or_depth_modeling
• input_text: 我想把这段讨论拆成原始判断、隐含假设、适用条件和误用边界。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 边界; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 边界; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-021

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_ia_refused
• control_case_type: model_name_exposed
• input_text: 先不要思想考古，只判断这是不是一个 QPI 意义上的问题。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.59 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 思想考古; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 思想考古
  • penalties: negative trigger: 不要思想考古、先不要思想考古; model hard exclusion signal: 不要思想考古、先不要思想考古

R04-BI-022

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_ia_refused
• input_text: 不要展开到底层假设，只帮我看主导稀缺是什么。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开
• qpi score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开

R04-BI-023

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_ia_refused
• input_text: 这次先不做深度建模，只做问题定性，看它是缺数据、缺路径还是缺共识。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.99 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题、缺数据、缺路径、缺共识; complexity signal: 共识; selection_priority=9; QPI problem-definition gate matched

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 共识; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: QPI-before-IA gate: 缺数据、缺路径、缺共识; no IA heavy-depth gate; model hard exclusion signal: 只做问题定性

R04-BI-024

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_ia_refused
• input_text: 不要进入思想考古，我只要一个轻量判断：现在应该先问问题、找路径，还是处理责任边界？
• selected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• rejected_models: []
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.97 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 思想考古; complexity signal: 边界、责任; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 思想考古
• qpi score=0.74 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 边界、责任; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• none

R04-BI-025

• category_for_owner_review: likely_intellectual_archaeology
• control_case_type: model_name_exposed
• input_text: QPI 已经判断这是中重型课题，现在请继续分析它背后的底层假设、生成机制和长期稳定结构。
• selected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• rejected_models: []
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.97 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 底层假设; complexity signal: 长期、底层、结构、机制; selection_priority=7; IA heavy-depth signal: 底层假设
• qpi score=0.74 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 课题; complexity signal: 长期、底层、结构、机制; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• none

R04-BI-026

• category_for_owner_review: likely_intellectual_archaeology
• input_text: 这个现象反复出现在不同项目里，我想知道它背后的思想结构是什么，而不是只做问题分类。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.74 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; complexity signal: 反复、结构; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 反复、结构; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-027

• category_for_owner_review: likely_intellectual_archaeology
• input_text: 请分析这套判断为什么会长期成立，它依赖哪些世界观、因果假设和行动边界。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 长期、边界; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 长期、边界; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-028

• category_for_owner_review: ambiguous_low_context
• input_text: 这个不太对。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-029

• category_for_owner_review: ambiguous_low_context
• input_text: 怎么又卡住了？
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-030

• category_for_owner_review: ambiguous_low_context
• input_text: 还是那个老问题。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.59 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-031

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_how_to
• input_text: 如何在 Excel 里冻结首行？
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-032

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_how_to
• input_text: 怎么把 Markdown 文件转成 PDF？
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-033

• category_for_owner_review: explicit_no_call_dictionary_judgment
• input_text: 判断一下“alignment”在这句话里是什么意思。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-034

• category_for_owner_review: direct_execution_with_analysis_override
• input_text: 请把下面内容总结成三点，但不要只执行，先判断它背后的问题定义。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.59 decision=selected
  • reasons: trigger keyword matched: 问题; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-035

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_depth_limited
• input_text: 不要深入分析，只判断这件事的主导稀缺是什么。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要深入分析
• qpi score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要深入分析

R04-BI-036

• category_for_owner_review: qpi_allowed_depth_limited
• input_text: 不要展开到底层理论，只判断现在是缺信息、缺路径还是缺共识。
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology', 'qpi']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: hard no-call gate matched; explicit analysis override was not present.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开
• qpi score=0.0 decision=rejected
  • penalties: hard no-call signal: 不要展开

R04-BI-037

• category_for_owner_review: ambiguous_growth_how_to
• input_text: 如何提高这个账号的流量？
• selected_models: []
• rejected_models: ['qpi', 'intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: True
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• none

Rejected model details:

• qpi score=0.09 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=9
  • penalties: QPI positive signal missing
• intellectual_archaeology score=0.02 decision=rejected
  • reasons: selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

R04-BI-038

• category_for_owner_review: likely_intellectual_archaeology
• input_text: 这类失败在不同项目里反复出现，我想抽出它背后稳定的生成机制和可迁移框架。
• selected_models: ['qpi']
• rejected_models: ['intellectual_archaeology']
• no_call: False
• routing_notes: selector is rule-based and driven by selector/selector_rules.json; no LLM, no vector search, no answer generation.

Selected model details:

• qpi score=0.49 decision=selected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 反复、机制; selection_priority=9

Rejected model details:

• intellectual_archaeology score=0.17 decision=rejected
  • reasons: complexity signal: 反复、机制; selection_priority=7
  • penalties: no IA heavy-depth gate

Review Reminder

This is the first blind routing output. Failure labels, expected routing, and rule changes should be added only after owner / GPT / CCRA review of these observed results.