the-mindscape-of-bro-tsong/local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/helper-outputs/lifecycle-status-guard-scan.md

Lifecycle Status Guard Scan

Summary

• Status: FAIL
• Files scanned: 178
• Blocking findings: 21
• Warnings: 0
• Evidence-present observations: 2

Blocking Findings

• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/03_VALIDATION_AND_COMMAND_LOG_03.2.md line 59: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/03_VALIDATION_AND_COMMAND_LOG_03.2a.md line 47: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• docs/DECISIONS.md line 175: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• docs/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/CASE_PREPROCESSING_WORKFLOW.md line 160: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/disappointment-emotional-isolation.cases.md line 263: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/disappointment-emotional-isolation.cases.md line 275: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/flow-redesign.cases.md line 11: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 11: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 100: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 357: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 519: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 528: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md line 618: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-development-office.cases.md line 11: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-employment-entrepreneurship.cases.md line 7: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-employment-entrepreneurship.cases.md line 698: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-international-college.cases.md line 81: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-international-college.cases.md line 618: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-research-office.cases.md line 7: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• selector/qpi_case_digests.json line 1261: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.
• selector/qpi_case_digests.json line 2187: owner-approved - Approval claim phrase lacks nearby evidence marker.

Warnings

• None

Observations

• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/lifecycle-guard-config.yaml line 14: owner-approved - evidence marker present; approval validity not decided.
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/lifecycle-guard-config.yaml line 15: ccra-approved - evidence marker present; approval validity not decided.

Files Scanned

• AGENTS.md
• cards/card_index.md
• cards/intellectual_archaeology.md
• cards/qpi.md
• cards/README.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-02_2026-06-16_second-audit/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-02_2026-06-16_second-audit/01_GUIDANCE_PACK_AND_COMPLIANCE_MATRIX.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-02_2026-06-16_second-audit/02_CURRENT_ASSET_PACK.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-02_2026-06-16_second-audit/03_REPORTS_DIFF_AND_COMMAND_LOG.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-02_2026-06-16_second-audit/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/01_PATCH_MATRIX_03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/02_CURRENT_ASSET_PACK03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/03_VALIDATION_AND_COMMAND_LOG03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/04_REVIEW_QUESTIONS_FOR_GPT03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.1_2026-06-17_selector-no-call-regression-patch/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST03.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/01_PATCH_MATRIX_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/02_CURRENT_ASSET_PACK_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/03_VALIDATION_AND_COMMAND_LOG_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/04_REVIEW_QUESTIONS_FOR_GPT_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2_2026-06-17_selector-negative-gate-patch/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST_03.2.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/01_PATCH_MATRIX_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/02_CURRENT_ASSET_PACK_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/03_VALIDATION_AND_COMMAND_LOG_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/04_REVIEW_QUESTIONS_FOR_GPT_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03.2a_2026-06-17_depth-limiting-qpi-override-patch/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST_03.2a.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/01_GUIDANCE_PACK_AND_COMPLIANCE_MATRIX.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/02_CURRENT_ASSET_PACK.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/03_REPORTS_DIFF_AND_COMMAND_LOG.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/04_QPI_CASE_PROMOTION_SUMMARY_AND_REVIEW_GUIDE.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/05_REVIEW_QUESTIONS_FOR_GPT.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-03_2026-06-17_contract-hardening-selector-calibration/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/01_RULE_PATCH_SUMMARY_AND_DIFF_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/02_EXPECTED_ROUTING_LABELS_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/03_POST_PATCH_ROUTING_VERIFICATION_REPORT_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/04_REGRESSION_AND_COMMAND_LOG_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST_04.1.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04.1_2026-06-18_selector-rule-patch/optional_raw_changed_files_04.1.zip.validation.json
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/00_OPEN_THIS_FIRST_CCRA_REVIEW_BRIEF_04.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/01_ROUND03_CLOSURE_AND_ROUND04_SCOPE_04.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/02_BLIND_INPUT_SET_04.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/03_ROUTING_EVALUATION_REPORT_04.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/04_REVIEW_QUESTIONS_FOR_GPT_04.md
• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST_04.md
• docs/CHATGPT_HANDOFF_RULES.md
• docs/CONTENT_STABILIZATION_PROTOCOL.md
• docs/DATA_CONTRACT.md
• docs/DECISIONS.md
• docs/FILE_TAXONOMY.md
• docs/GPT_PLAN_LOCALIZATION_PROTOCOL.md
• docs/HANDOFF_TEMPLATE.md
• docs/INDEX_MAINTENANCE_PROTOCOL.md
• docs/INTELLECTUAL_ARCHAEOLOGY_DEPTH_GATE.md
• docs/KNOWLEDGE_ASSET_RULES.md
• docs/MODEL_CARD_CONTRACT.md
• docs/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/CASE_PREPROCESSING_WORKFLOW.md
• docs/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/README.md
• docs/model_case_preprocessing/README.md
• docs/MODEL_EXTRACTION_RULES.md
• docs/MODEL_EXTRACTION_WORKFLOW.md
• docs/NON_GOALS.md
• docs/PROJECT_BRIEF.md
• docs/QPI_CONTEXTUAL_ROUTING_RULES.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-16-model-extraction-contract-and-workflow.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-16-project-initialization.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-17-contract-hardening-selector-calibration.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-18-round04-1-selector-rule-patch.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-06-18-round04-blind-routing-evaluation.md
• docs/WORKFLOW.md
• knowledge_assets/00_用户背景与产品上下文.md
• knowledge_assets/01_核心模型地图.md
• knowledge_assets/02_模型卡结构规范.md
• knowledge_assets/03_核心模型抽取样板.md
• knowledge_assets/06_模型稳固性评级规则.md
• knowledge_assets/07_产品规划过程记录.md
• knowledge_assets/08_CCRA模型库MVP质量门与交接协议.md
• knowledge_assets/09_数据治理与模型调用机制说明.md
• knowledge_assets/10_本地CCRA评审机制说明.md
• knowledge_assets/README.md
• local_ccra_reviews/README.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/agent-invocation-packet.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/gate-manifest.yaml
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/helper-outputs/bundle-audit.json
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/helper-outputs/bundle-audit.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/helper-outputs/gate-run-report.json
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/helper-outputs/gate-run-report.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/lifecycle-guard-config.yaml
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/owner-decision.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/prompt-to-send.md
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/review-metadata.json
• local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/run-notes.md
• models/intellectual_archaeology.model.json
• models/model_index.json
• models/qpi.model.json
• models/README.md
• PROJECTS.md
• README.md
• reports/baseline_before_content_stabilization_v0.2.md
• reports/changed_files_manifest.md
• reports/ChatGPT交接文档_模型库MVP_2026-06-16.md
• reports/ChatGPT交接文档_模型库MVP_第二轮内容稳定化_2026-06-16.md
• reports/Codex_工程产物摘要_v0.1.md
• reports/Codex_本地CCRA规划落地_2026-06-19.md
• reports/Codex_模型资产链路摘要_v0.1.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_CCRA评审后处理_2026-06-16.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_QPI案例草稿审阅与第三轮后续_2026-06-17.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_Round03.1评审后续_2026-06-17.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_Round03.2a评审准备_2026-06-17.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_Round03.2评审准备_2026-06-17.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_Round04.1关闭与Round05准备_2026-06-18.md
• reports/Codex新会话交接文档_模型库MVP_2026-06-16.md
• reports/command_log.md
• reports/content_review_report.md
• reports/content_review_report_v0.2.md
• reports/evidence_coverage_matrix.md
• reports/evidence_coverage_report_v0.2.md
• reports/GPT规划落地差异检查_v0.1.md
• reports/GPT讨论上下文_QPI草稿案例审阅_2026-06-17.md
• reports/index_check_report.md
• reports/index_rebuild_report.md
• reports/model_card_sync_report_v0.2.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/disappointment-emotional-isolation.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/flow-redesign.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/README.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-academic-affairs.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-development-office.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-employment-entrepreneurship.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-engineering-center.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-international-college.cases.md
• reports/model_case_preprocessing/qpi/round-01/year-end-review-research-office.cases.md
• reports/model_review_status.json
• reports/next_action_register_v0.2.md
• reports/open_questions_for_CCRA.md
• reports/README.md
• reports/Round04_1_post_patch_routing_verification_report_2026-06-18.md
• reports/Round04_blind_input_candidates_2026-06-18.md
• reports/Round04_blind_routing_evaluation_report_2026-06-18.md
• reports/schema_change_notes.md
• reports/selector_calibration_smoke_report.md
• reports/selector_regression_report.md
• reports/selector_regression_report_v0.2.md
• reports/selector_score_breakdown.md
• reports/validation_report.md
• reports/内容修复检查摘要_v0.1.md
• reports/内容修复检查摘要_v0.2.md
• reports/规则Schema工作流检查摘要_v0.1.md
• requirements/ccpe/2026-06-19-ccra-local-reviewer-runtime.md
• requirements/ccpe/README.md
• requirements/skills-vault/2026-06-18-review-bundle-zip-packager.md
• requirements/skills-vault/README.md
• schemas/card_index.schema.json
• schemas/model_card.schema.json
• schemas/model_index.schema.json
• schemas/model_spec.schema.json
• schemas/README.md
• schemas/regression_case.schema.json
• schemas/source_article.schema.json
• schemas/source_excerpt.schema.json
• scripts/README.md
• selector/qpi_case_digests.json
• selector/README.md
• selector/round04_blind_inputs.json
• selector/selector_calibration_inputs.json
• selector/selector_examples.json
• selector/selector_rules.json
• sources/evidence_coverage.matrix.json
• sources/README.md
• sources/source_articles.json
• sources/source_excerpts.json
• tests/intellectual_archaeology.regression.json
• tests/qpi.regression.json
• tests/README.md
• tests/regression_cases.json
• tests/regression_index.json