the-mindscape-of-bro-tsong/local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/run-notes.md

Local CCRA Run Notes

Run Identity

• review_round: round-04
• local_pass: pilot-02
• review_run_dir: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02
• runtime_id: ccra-local-review
• runtime_version: 0.1.1
• agent_id: ccra-local-reviewer
• agent_version: 0.1.1
• pilot_status: setup_in_progress

Purpose

Second historical pilot after CCPE Patch 1.

This pilot checks:

1. Whether Patch 1 improves Web-style product diagnosis while preserving local full-file audit.
2. Whether review_turn can identify Round 04 issues without using Round 04.1 hindsight evidence.
3. Whether the same child session can continue with planning_turn.
4. Whether planning_turn can produce next-review requirements and submitted-material guidance.
5. Whether the output improves against pilot-01 and Web CCRA baseline lines 1-214.

This pilot is not Round 05 acceptance.

Source Evidence Scope

Primary review-turn evidence:

• ccra_review_bundle/round-04_2026-06-18_blind-input-routing-evaluation/
• reports/Round04_blind_routing_evaluation_report_2026-06-18.md
• reports/Round04_blind_input_candidates_2026-06-18.md
• selector/round04_blind_inputs.json
• selector/selector_rules.json
• selector/README.md
• tests/test_round04_blind_routing.py

Required knowledge base:

• knowledge_assets/

Fair-comparison exclusion:

• Round 04.1 post-patch result files are intentionally excluded from review_turn evidence. The purpose is to compare with the Web CCRA / GPT initial Round 04 review baseline, 2026-06-18产品交流-GPT.md lines 1-214, without giving the child reviewer hindsight from the later patch result.

Helper Commands

• review-context-builder: exit 0. review-context.md and review-file-manifest.json generated; no missing source roots; required knowledge_assets/ included.
• review-bundle-audit: exit 1. Generic profile reports missing manifest and validation_sidecar; BUNDLE_FILE_MANIFEST_04.md exists but is treated as extra by the generic profile.
• routing-behavior-diff-audit: skipped for review_turn; no before/after patch result is included in the initial Round 04 evidence scope.
• regression-validation-gate-runner --mode dry_run: exit 0. Three gates declared and skipped as dry run.
• lifecycle-status-guard-scan: exit 1. Scan reports blocking lifecycle/status candidates; many are broad-scope findings from older review materials and pilot-01 helper outputs, so reviewer must classify confidence/noise rather than treat the helper result as automatic judgment.

Dispatch Record

• carrier_type: codex_thread
• invocation_mode: prompt_path_reference
• child_session_id: 019edcde-24be-7593-99b2-5cf014467340
• review_turn_status: returned
• planning_turn_status: returned
• review_turn_duration_ms: 512317
• planning_turn_duration_ms: 342925

Return Record

• review_report_path: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/04_LOCAL_CCRA_REVIEW_REPORT.md
• planning_output_path: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/next-review-requirements.md
• returned_output_path: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/returned-output.md
• return_status: review_and_planning_returned

Comparison Plan

After both child turns return, compare:

1. Web baseline: C:\Users\wangq\Documents\Codex\knowledge-vault\work\internal\强哥的思想宇宙\讨论\2026-06-18产品交流-GPT.md lines 1-214.
2. Local pilot-01: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-01/04_LOCAL_CCRA_REVIEW_REPORT.md.
3. Local pilot-02 review turn: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/04_LOCAL_CCRA_REVIEW_REPORT.md.
4. Local pilot-02 planning turn: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/next-review-requirements.md.

Comparison Result

• comparison_report_path: local_ccra_reviews/round-04/pilot-02/05_WEB_LOCAL_CCRA_COMPARISON.md
• comparison_status: completed
• readiness_recommendation: ready_for_formal_local_first_review_with_conditions
• follow_up_ccpe_patch_request: requirements/ccpe/2026-06-19-ccra-local-reviewer-runtime-patch2.md
• follow_up_patch_type: non-blocking hardening

Resume Notes

For planning_turn, continue the same child session recorded above and provide the first-turn report path.