3.0 KiB

Raw Blame History

Character Anchor Review V2

Status

Review status: user selected v2.
Image acceptance state: accepted as the current main character anchor board.
Generation purpose: repair walking posture while preserving the preferred v1 character image.
Next gated action: review character-identity-lock.md before any transparent slices or scene prompts.

Generation Context

Prompt document:

visual-system/characters/character-anchor-prompt-v2.md

Generated image:

visual-system/characters/character-anchor-v2-codex-posture-test.png

Tool default source retained:

C:\Users\wangq\.codex\generated_images\019ef2f7-e630-7303-a0e8-e5e7a86912fc\ig_059d9628223dbafb016a3a2f45e45c8198a75f641eb5f2295f.png

Image properties:

Width: 1672
Height: 941
Pixel format: RGB
Aspect: close to 16:9

User Feedback Addressed

Original feedback:

Character image in character-anchor-v1-codex-test.png is preferred.
Walking posture in v1 is too hunched.
Regenerate with walking posture closer to character-chatgpt.png: upright chest, not bent at the waist.

V2 prompt response:

Preserved v1 as preferred character-image reference.
Used character-chatgpt.png as positive walking-posture reference.
Added strict negative constraints against hunched walking, bent waist, rounded shoulders, bowed head, and collapsed posture.

Review Checklist

Check	Result	Notes
Preserve v1 character image direction	Pass	Face, hair, beard, coat, backpack, and boots remain close to v1.
Walking side less hunched than v1	Pass	The main central walking side cell is visibly more upright.
Chest / upper body more open	Pass	Main walking pose has a straighter upper body and less collapsed shoulder line.
Walking back not defeated	Pass	Rear walking pose is steady and does not read as collapsed.
Same-person consistency	Pass	Multi-view identity remains coherent.
Coat / backpack / boots stability	Pass	Object system remains strong and consistent.
Text dependence avoided	Pass	The board does not rely on exact generated labels.

Remaining Notes

The small lower-left walking pose still has mild forward lean, but it reads as motion rather than waist-bent defeat.
The main walking side cell is the strongest posture repair and is closer to the desired "挺胸走" direction.
Compared with v1, v2 has slightly more structured layout and a somewhat less intimate half-body portrait, but the identity direction remains usable.

Recommendation

V2 is a better candidate than v1 if walking posture is the priority.

Suggested decision:

If the user accepts v2, use character-anchor-v2-codex-posture-test.png as the first accepted character anchor candidate and create character-identity-lock.md.
If the user wants one more repair, keep v2 as the base and further specify: "all walking cells must be upright; no secondary walking pose may lean forward."
Do not create transparent slices until a character anchor candidate is accepted.